REVIVAL ON MAIN STREET APARTMENTS – or perhaps
CONDOS?
I never had any particular opinion of whether this large development was
a ‘good’ idea or a ‘bad’ idea. I just
watched it being developed like most of the rest of the City did. The most I ever said was that it either would
be the best thing since sliced bread or it would be a major
disaster.
Now it is up and people are living there and are posting on social media
just what they experience. See: https://www.yelp.com/biz/revival-on-main-kennesaw
Early days, but it seems to be heading towards ‘major disaster’. It is going to be a problem as a rental
property and ‘if’ you let it go condo it will only get
worse.
I have the experience of both renting (twice) in condos and buying
one. The initial social media postings
are of concern and show that what should be a nice downtown show piece
development may well end up being a black eye for
Kennesaw.
I recall that when I took the first developer tour of the building that
there were several comments from those on the tour, who were more knowledgeable
than myself, concerning the less than adequate construction of the
building. (i.e.: cheap
construction)
I will refer you to Yelp to see how the place is being rated and as
someone with some knowledge of how Yelp operates I will point out that firms are
approached by Yelp to join for membership which results in poor reviews being
removed or being relegated to back pages which are often overlooked by
readers.
The first page of Yelp reviews you will see all are 5 Stars, if you watch
the small type you will see links to ‘un recommended reviews’ and I will collect
3 and post them FYI. I believe others
are simply gone and probably these 3 will eventually disappear
also.
Do some research before you make any decisions on the condo issue. You may find that you have enough on your
plate with those units just being apartments.
COMMENTS FROM YELP:
Mia Y.
o
Kennesaw,
GA
o
0 friends
o
1 review
2/21/2016
Well
I can see Im not the only one frustrated lol.
The place is close to some restaurants like burger fi which is really nice and has a gas station right across the street which is also super convenient and the people that live here that ive met so far are all really sweet. But thats about where the good stops.
Unfortunately I have to agree with the management here being pretty bad, in fact its where all my frustrations stem from. The actual office staff are all very nice and accomodating, and Im trying to remain polite here, but the actual manager is not a very valuable or useful one at all. Shes never available to speak with even though shes right there in the office. When you try and get answers from the office staff instead, they just say theyll have to run it through the manager or theyll confirm that theyve already brought it to her attention multiple times and have not recieved any answer but will try again. It is incredibly rude and incredibly frustrating. It seems like this is her first manager position and she is in way over her head.
The building itself seems to be peeling apart at the seams and is not retaining a polished look at all. The carpet seams dont even reach each other in the hallways, the door frames have like inch wide gaps in them, its cheap looking and is embarrassing. The whole first floor smells like nasty weed all of the time and Ive pleaded with the manager for something to be done about it and she wont. One of my neighbors is actually having to move to a totally different apartment just to get away from the smell! All of the inconvenience is being put on my neighbor instead of her just doing her job and getting the smoking and noise to stop. He has to move his entire apartment because she refuses to manage, I can not get over it. On top of that it is illegal. IILEGAL. And potentialy bringing in other illegal activities like robbery (more on that in a minute) Plus I was told that this was a no smoking place. To be fair though I did not ask specifically about whether she allows the illegal smoking of marijuana on the property so....
There have been arrests here, cars are getting broken into in the parking garage on a regular basis and none of this has motivated her to do anything. The staircase next to the parking garage doesnt even lock and anyone can just walk right into it and go and steal from our cars. She knows about it and keeps saying its not her fault or her responsibility and the construction will probably get to it and all the while our cars continue to get broken into. No extra security at night, no extra cameras installed and not even a fix to the door.
Overall I am pretty upset that my experience has been what it has been and will not be renewing when that glorious day does finally come.
·
o
John
M.
o
Kennesaw,
GA
o
0 friends
o
1 review
2/18/2016
Revival
on Main is paying to have all of the bad reviews removed from Yelp. It is
unbelievably dishonest, underhanded and unethical. It is a direct attempt to
purposely mislead and defraud people. And let me just say that any place that is
truly great DOES NOT need to stoop to the deceitful lows of paying to have bad
reviews removed. I won't waste my time posting details of why I am unhappy here
since there is no telling how long before its taken down, but the place is
managed by a dishonest, uncaring manager who would rather take the time to try
and place blame on a us then to try and help find a solution to any of the
issues that arise.
She
is a pseudo manager who's spot is blown as soon as she opens her mouth and who
only serves to make matters here worse. And in amazingly amusing fashion, by
them paying to remove the bad reviews, you the reader have actually been
presented with the perfect example of the remarkably dishonorable manner in
which this place is managed.
Thats
exactly how things are done here. She will do anything to shun responsibility
for anything, even at the cost of her own residents well being. Whats done in
the dark will eventually be brought to light my dear. And believe me, your
pockets are not deep enough to buy off the damage that bad social media can do.
Taking the low road is a costly mistake these days and you just picked a fight
that you will not win. You've shown that you are the kind of person who would
rather choose to be conniving instead of embracing the opportunity to use the
negative reviews to better the community for everyone and to find areas where
you might be able to improve and grow as a manager, and that is sad.
Being
in your mid 60's or so you should really be better than that, and I actually
feel sorry for you. Yelp might be for sale dear, but not everyone is, and people
will be informed of this place whether you like it or not.
·
o
Lji
L.
o
Kennesaw,
GA
o
0 friends
o
0 reviews
12/30/2015
this
place is horrible! they will trick you do not do it. there is a train the comes
every hour during the night blowing the horn very very loud!!!!!!!!! it feels
like its in your house! theyre going to tell that the walls in the apartment is
sound proof!!!! thats a complete lie! no celluar service what so ever so they
are going to tell you that they are getting mobile boosters but thats a lie!
lets not talk about the fire alarm that goes off at 4:30 in the morning every
night so of course we all have to get up out of bed and evacuate which ruins my
sleep! they never return your calls ever when there is a problem! 2 vehicles
just got broken into in the parking deck but its suppose to be so safe here!
yeah right! theres dog poop everywhere. robin is the dumbest person you can ever
meet she doesnt know anything! they are always taking long vacation days off so
you dont know who to talk to because theres only 1 or 2 people in the office.
this place is very unprofessional! i hate it! nice place but its not worth it!
you would want to move out 2 months later!
1
Review Removed for Violating our Terms
of Service
- Revival
S.
- Kennesaw,
GA
- 0 friends
- 0 reviews
1/11/2016
This
review has been removed for violating our Terms of
Service
Photos from Developers June 2015 Tour:
Revival on Main has a FB page and I posted the above on it and got the below reply 3/7/16:
Revival on Main Hi, Davey –
Thank you for your post. As with any product or service, online reviews can be touch and go. I do wish you would have balanced your own post with some of the positive experiences our residents have published on Yelp, but those who view the link you shared will see those regardless. I also want to confirm that our community is for rent only, and no homes are for sale.
I would very much appreciate the opportunity to speak and host your tour of our community personally. It sounds as though you have not had a chance to experience Revival on Main for yourself.
Please reach out at your earliest convenience to schedule your tour. My direct email is cdrevival@matrixresidential.com or you can call me at 678.888.3736.
Thank you,
Robin Demorse
Community Director
Thank you for your post. As with any product or service, online reviews can be touch and go. I do wish you would have balanced your own post with some of the positive experiences our residents have published on Yelp, but those who view the link you shared will see those regardless. I also want to confirm that our community is for rent only, and no homes are for sale.
I would very much appreciate the opportunity to speak and host your tour of our community personally. It sounds as though you have not had a chance to experience Revival on Main for yourself.
Please reach out at your earliest convenience to schedule your tour. My direct email is cdrevival@matrixresidential.com or you can call me at 678.888.3736.
Thank you,
Robin Demorse
Community Director
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reports from August 1, 2015 – March 8, 2016 revealed the following information:
• Forty-Eight (48) total calls for service (less than 7 per month).• Six (6) thefts from auto ~ Three (3) occurred 12/29 – 1/3 and Three (3) occurred 2/2-3. Most had no signs of forced entry and no reports since Feb 3rd.• Eight (8) total arrests – Four (4) domestic related, One (1) alcohol related, One (1) drug related, One (1) traffic related and One (1) wanted person.
Our officers have been working with management to resolve security concerns as they arise. Apparently, a lock on an outside stairway to the upper deck was not working properly - The stairway access issue has been resolved. Additionally, KPD has made additional recommendations that are being evaluated by management.
Please let me know if you have any additional questions ~ Thanks.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kennesaw grapples with downtown rentals
Kennesaw grapples with downtown rentals
March 03, 2016
MARIETTA — The Kennesaw City Council plans to postpone a vote on whether to remove a city ordinance requiring apartment complexes downtown to convert to condominiums within five years that had been scheduled for Monday’s regular meeting.
The Council will still hold a third and final public hearing Monday, but Mayor Derek Easterling announced his intention at a work session Wednesday to make a motion to postpone the vote in order to allow officials more time to study the issue. He did not give a date for the vote, but the council appeared supportive of the delay.
The proposed amendment could have implications for two cornerstone developments of Kennesaw’s downtown: Revival on Main and the Dallas Street development, both mixed-use residential and commercial projects that include a total of more than 400 apartments.
Councilman Jim Sebastian expressed concern that changing the zoning ordinance after developers had committed to conversion to condominiums could potentially leave the city vulnerable to a lawsuit. He added that the ordinance was on the books when developers commenced the projects, and therefore they should be bound by it.
However, Bob Fox, the city’s economic development director, cast doubt on whether the developers for the two downtown projects were bound by the rule.
“It was always very clear that those were proposed and planned to be apartments without conversion,” Fox said. “There was no commitment that they would do that or could do that and there’s no way they would have gone forward with the project had that been the case.”
Business plans for the Revival and the Dallas Street developments were approved by the mayor and council, Fox added.
Councilman Jim Eaton addressed what he called the “gorilla” in the room, asking Fox point blank whether the developer behind Revival had requested the ordinance change.
“What they did was present exactly what they were planning to build and operate. … They were very clear that all they could build was multifamily (apartment housing),” Fox replied.
Eaton reminded the board that even if the units were converted to condominiums, those property owners could turn around and rent them out anyway.
Mayor Easterling then suggested that there were still “questions that need to be answered.”
“We need more time,” he said. “Let’s get our ducks in a row and get this right.”
In a separate but related item, the Council prepared to accept the handing over of parking and sidewalks on Main Street and Watts Drive from the developers of Revival on Main. The land was developed on private property, but will be dedicated to the city as right-of-way as per the development agreement signed by the developers and the city.
Kennesaw resident Timothy Heying, who attended the work session, said he was concerned if developers were making plans that ran counter to the public’s and the council’s understanding of the project.
“I think that apartments in the downtown area are necessary in the long term,” Heying said. “(But) I think that they need to be planned and they need to be presented as apartments the whole way through, that way the people who own it have a plan, the city has a plan and the residents have a plan.”
Speaking after the meeting, Eaton said he would like to see balance and variety in Kennesaw housing options, but he had not made up his mind on the ordinance amendment.
“I think we need a mix … I hate to see us eliminate housing for different levels of income folks, because some folks can’t afford to buy a condo,” Eaton said. “I also have a problem with big government telling private landowners what they can and cannot do with their property.”
The Council will still hold a third and final public hearing Monday, but Mayor Derek Easterling announced his intention at a work session Wednesday to make a motion to postpone the vote in order to allow officials more time to study the issue. He did not give a date for the vote, but the council appeared supportive of the delay.
The proposed amendment could have implications for two cornerstone developments of Kennesaw’s downtown: Revival on Main and the Dallas Street development, both mixed-use residential and commercial projects that include a total of more than 400 apartments.
Councilman Jim Sebastian expressed concern that changing the zoning ordinance after developers had committed to conversion to condominiums could potentially leave the city vulnerable to a lawsuit. He added that the ordinance was on the books when developers commenced the projects, and therefore they should be bound by it.
However, Bob Fox, the city’s economic development director, cast doubt on whether the developers for the two downtown projects were bound by the rule.
“It was always very clear that those were proposed and planned to be apartments without conversion,” Fox said. “There was no commitment that they would do that or could do that and there’s no way they would have gone forward with the project had that been the case.”
Business plans for the Revival and the Dallas Street developments were approved by the mayor and council, Fox added.
Councilman Jim Eaton addressed what he called the “gorilla” in the room, asking Fox point blank whether the developer behind Revival had requested the ordinance change.
“What they did was present exactly what they were planning to build and operate. … They were very clear that all they could build was multifamily (apartment housing),” Fox replied.
Eaton reminded the board that even if the units were converted to condominiums, those property owners could turn around and rent them out anyway.
Mayor Easterling then suggested that there were still “questions that need to be answered.”
“We need more time,” he said. “Let’s get our ducks in a row and get this right.”
In a separate but related item, the Council prepared to accept the handing over of parking and sidewalks on Main Street and Watts Drive from the developers of Revival on Main. The land was developed on private property, but will be dedicated to the city as right-of-way as per the development agreement signed by the developers and the city.
Kennesaw resident Timothy Heying, who attended the work session, said he was concerned if developers were making plans that ran counter to the public’s and the council’s understanding of the project.
“I think that apartments in the downtown area are necessary in the long term,” Heying said. “(But) I think that they need to be planned and they need to be presented as apartments the whole way through, that way the people who own it have a plan, the city has a plan and the residents have a plan.”
Speaking after the meeting, Eaton said he would like to see balance and variety in Kennesaw housing options, but he had not made up his mind on the ordinance amendment.
“I think we need a mix … I hate to see us eliminate housing for different levels of income folks, because some folks can’t afford to buy a condo,” Eaton said. “I also have a problem with big government telling private landowners what they can and cannot do with their property.”
==========================================
2/29/16
Above Original Condition of Kennesaw's Castle Lake Mobile Home Park (Barrett Pky at Bottom, Cobb Pky L to R at top of photo):
What it looks like today as it is being developed:
-------------------------------------------------------------------
GANG ACTIVITY, LEGACY PARK – KENNESAW – COBB
From a 2/28/16 11 Alive Report:
Cobb District Attorney says: “Legacy Park is in Kennesaw, Ga. - probably one of the most conservative places in the state of Georgia -- it's pro-law enforcement, a place where most people would imagine is one of the safest places you can find in Georgia,” he said. “Reality is - we have gang issues here. We had two drive by shootings at the same house in Legacy Park.
The intended victim: a member of the Piru Bloods Gang.
When fellow members learned he wanted out, they came twice and fired shots at his house.
He lived in Legacy Park - the same neighborhood as the former mayor of this city.
So how many gang members are in Cobb County right now?
“I would guestimate that number would run between 50 to 70 gangs,” Reynolds said.
And that’s just in Cobb County.
See the full 11 Alive Report at:
http://www.11alive.com/…/crime-next-door-gangs-no…/81009962/
http://www.11alive.com/…/crime-next-door-gangs-no…/81009962/
--------------------------------------------------------
Misc Comment: I’ve been saying it for a couple of years, Kennesaw is on a downward slide, it isn’t today the nice place I moved to in 2000.
It is going downhill fast. We have abandoned gas stations, far more Title Pawn and Pawn shops than are needed, 2nd rate motels and a lot of empty store fronts on the major highways/streets.
--------------------------------------------------------------
2/20/16
KIDDIE COPS AT KSU - 1st my comments, then the news story from the MDJUniversity and College police, in Georgia and in all states that I have experience with are these days State Certified (POST) to have the same arrest powers as all police.The problem here is that these 'Kiddie Kops' are a step above a security guard and a step below REAL cops.The vast majority of them are either waiting for an opening on a REAL police force or are people who just can't make the cut for a real police job.So what you have are a bunch of 'wanna be' cops extending their patrols off campus to look for law breakers. It isn't real interesting to be writing traffic citations on campus or helping students get into their locked out vehicles.Much more exciting to cruse around in the University Police car and look for real crimes to to stop.Yes, they are 'certified' as police officers, No, they are not REAL cops. These folks need to remain on campus and do the jobs that they were hired to do and NOT roam around area streets looking for crime to fight.----------------------------------------
"Georgia Supreme Court to hear case involving DUI arrest by KSU policeby MDJ staff February 20, 2016The Georgia Supreme Court is scheduled to hear arguments Monday regarding a 2013 DUI charge being appealed by a Marietta man who said his arrest was invalid, according to a news release.Bajrodin Zilke, 51, was stopped, arrested and charged with DUI on Powder Springs Road by a police officer who was employed by Kennesaw State University in 2013, according to the release.In court, Zilke’s attorney asked the court to disregard the breath test administered by the officer at the time of the arrest. The attorney argued the officer lacked jurisdiction as the offense had occurred more than 500 yards off of Kennesaw State University’s campus.The trial court granted the attorney’s request, but the decision was reversed by the Court of Appeals.Zilke is now appealing the ruling to the state Supreme Court, which has agreed to review the case to determine whether a campus police officer has the authority to make arrests for a traffic violation committed in his presence off campus."
KENNESAW COUNCIL MEMBER DANIEL: JUST WONDERING?Last year the below ‘law firm’ (ie: Collection Agency) was looking for our City Council Member Ms Yvette Daniel about that $191,600 debt.Wonder if they ever found her?Maybe someone should drop them a note and let them know where she is?“THIS LAW FIRM IS ACTING AS A DEBT COLLECTOR ATTEMPTING TO COLLECT A DEBT. ANY INFORMATION OBTAINED WILL BE USED FOR THAT PURPOSE.BARRETT DAFFIN FRAPPIER LEVINE & BLOCK, LLP 15000 Surveyor Boulevard Addison, Texas 75001 Telephone: (972) 341 5398.”
MARK MATHEWS JOINS HENSSLER FINANCIAL
Henssler Financial is proud to announce former Kennesaw Mayor and Cobb
Chamber of Commerce Kennesaw Citizen of the Year (2015) Mark Mathews has joined
the firm as Business Development Director.
“We are very excited to have Mark join our team,” said Gene W. Henssler,
Ph.D., the firm’s President and Chief Investment Officer. “Mark is eager to
pursue a career in business. He has earned a great reputation during his nearly
20 years serving the Kennesaw community.”
With a passion for developing relationships, Mathews will focus on
identifying and strategically assessing opportunities to create long-term value
for the firm. He will work closely with firm managers to engage new clients and
business associations.
“I’m honored to be part of a wealth management firm with an excellent
reputation for providing clients the personal attention needed for their
financial future,” Mathews said. “I’m excited about this wonderful opportunity
to be able to draw upon my experience in dealing with individuals and local
businesses.”
“We are thrilled to have him on board and look forward to incorporating his
extensive understanding of the Cobb County community into our business,” said
firm principal William G. Lako, Jr., CFP®, who also serves as Henssler
Financial’s Managing Director.
Henssler and Lako agreed that Mathews’ experience, leadership skills and
business insight should be tremendous assets for Henssler Financial, which will
deepen client relationships and bring new opportunities for the firm.
Mathews additionally serves as a member of the board on the Atlanta
Regional Commission as well as the Cobb Competitive EDGE. Mr. Mathews served as
Mayor for the City of Kennesaw since 2008 prior to joining Henssler.
As Mayor, he presided over all City Council meetings and executed
contracts, deeds and other official documents as authorized by the City Council.
While Mayor, Mathews also worked as Government Relations Manager for the Metro
Atlanta Ambulance Service. Mr. Mathews has been involved in the community since
1996.
From: http://brightsidenews.com/web.nc.pdf page 6 and reported in the MDJ of Feb 1st.
See company info via: http://www.henssler.com/
See company info via: http://www.henssler.com/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What is going on in Cobb County Superior Court with Council Member Ms. Daniel?
Summary 1st and 3rd listed actions involve husband Leon A. Fletcher and 2 children of that marriage, Leona M. Flethcher (5/23/07) and Alexandria N. Fletcher (8/31/08).
The middle filing is a suit by a newer husband Ivery Marquez of 228 Piedmont Ct, Temple, Ga. 30179, who sues Yvette Michelle Ann Daniel for a divorce alleging 'desertion for over a year'.
Married 3/8/14 and Seperated 3/1/15 - no Children. Filed 3/31/15 as 'Complaint For Divorce With Out Minor Children'. Case #15-1-2422-40.
Edit Search | New Searchh Results Max Rows:
|
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2/3/16
KENNESAW CITY COUNCIL MEETING FEB 1, 2016
RE: Yvette Michelle Ann Daniel, Carleen Fregeolle, Debbie Williams
This half hour meeting is available at: https://vimeo.com/153905231
The 'interesting parts' come in 2 places when the public could address the Mayor and Council.
First when Carleen Fregeolle spoke from the recorded CD time of 10:30 minutes to 16:00. Initially about credit cards for the first half of her presentation then going into specifics and at one time mentioning Yvette Daniel by name, then going on about bankruptcy and how a certain Council member (name already mentioned) was behind by 192K to her landlord (ie: RJ Patel) who had tried to settle the amount.
Second when former Council member and unsucessful candidate for Mayor Debbie Williams spoke from the CD time of 16:30 until 19:20 when she addressed the credit card issue and as my notes reflect "took a shot at the mayor". Ms Williams did not mention Yvette Daniel by name. FYI: Ms Daniel and Mayor Easterling have had bankruptcies. Both sets of citizen comments are to long to reasonably recap but are worth watching via the above link.
RE: Yvette Michelle Ann Daniel, Carleen Fregeolle, Debbie Williams
This half hour meeting is available at: https://vimeo.com/153905231
The 'interesting parts' come in 2 places when the public could address the Mayor and Council.
First when Carleen Fregeolle spoke from the recorded CD time of 10:30 minutes to 16:00. Initially about credit cards for the first half of her presentation then going into specifics and at one time mentioning Yvette Daniel by name, then going on about bankruptcy and how a certain Council member (name already mentioned) was behind by 192K to her landlord (ie: RJ Patel) who had tried to settle the amount.
Second when former Council member and unsucessful candidate for Mayor Debbie Williams spoke from the CD time of 16:30 until 19:20 when she addressed the credit card issue and as my notes reflect "took a shot at the mayor". Ms Williams did not mention Yvette Daniel by name. FYI: Ms Daniel and Mayor Easterling have had bankruptcies. Both sets of citizen comments are to long to reasonably recap but are worth watching via the above link.
Kennesaw sets fee to qualify for special election
The Kennesaw City Council has announced a special May 24 election for the seat vacated by former Councilman Leonard Church. Church pleaded guilty to child molestation and possession of child pornography in December and was sentenced to 18 years.
The qualifying fee for the Post 3 seat is $360. The term ends Dec. 31, 2017.
In other business Monday, council approved the following:
A government purchasing card and credit card policy for elected officials, which provides penalties to elected officials who abuse or misuse government-issued purchasing cards. The policy states city-issued purchasing cards or credit cards should never be used for personal purchases and any documents related to purchases must be available for public inspection. Penalties include civil fines and criminal charges;
Authorized the city to work with Cobb TV 23 to test the quality of recorded City Council meetings for possible rebroadcast on Cobb TV. Recorded City Council meetings are currently available on the city’s website.
The qualifying fee for the Post 3 seat is $360. The term ends Dec. 31, 2017.
In other business Monday, council approved the following:
A government purchasing card and credit card policy for elected officials, which provides penalties to elected officials who abuse or misuse government-issued purchasing cards. The policy states city-issued purchasing cards or credit cards should never be used for personal purchases and any documents related to purchases must be available for public inspection. Penalties include civil fines and criminal charges;
Authorized the city to work with Cobb TV 23 to test the quality of recorded City Council meetings for possible rebroadcast on Cobb TV. Recorded City Council meetings are currently available on the city’s website.
1/12/16
LIVE CAMERA SHOWS DOWNTOWN CONSTRUCTION
If you want to see a real time live shot of the downtown Kennesaw construction site, just across from City Hall, you can go to: http://kennesawmainstreet.info/ for 24/7 viewing and choose either the full screen version or the smaller 800 PX size.
Use 'public' for both username and password. Now that sections of the building are occupied you can see people sitting out on their balcony, as in the below photo.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
1/12/16
F.O.I.A. REQUEST & REPLY
Q) HOW MUCH WILL FORMER MAYOR MATHEWS MAKE IN RETIREMENT?
A) THE SHORT ANSWER IS $1,300 A MONTH, OR 15,600 A YEAR.
From: dctaylor@kennesaw-ga.gov
Sent: 1/12/2016 1:55:53 P.M. Eastern Standard Time
Subj: RE: FOIA Request
Mr. Harris,
Below is are the responses to your open records request. There is no charge.
1. What benefits are Mark Mathews entitled to now he has left office?
Mark Mathews is not entitled to any benefits after leaving his seat as Mayor.
2. What amount will be receive by way of pension for his service to the City (as Mayor and Councilmember)?
When Mark Mathews is eligible for retirement, he will receive $65 per each year of service. The flat dollar amount, per each year of service, has changed over time. As a result, Mathews would receive the flat dollar amount that was applicable at each point in his service.
3. When will his pension start and how long will it run?
Mark Mathew’s pension will start when he applies for retirement. The Mayor and Council are eligible for retirement at age 65. Mathew’s retirement will run for the rest of his life.
Debra Taylor,
MMC, City Clerk
City of Kennesaw
----------------------------------------------------------------
FYI: But from a different source - further Monthly Pension Info is:
Leonard Church: $600
Killingsworth: $520
Welsh: $390
Sebastian: $130
*NOTE: Several Council members have indicated they will not take a pension from the City.
1/9/16
Subject: UNFINISHED MATHEWS BUSINESS FOR THE NEW ADMINISTRATION
Date: 1/9/2016 11:14:52 P.M. Eastern Standard Time From: bloggercentral@aol.com
To: deasterling@kennesaw-ga.gov, jsebastian@kennesaw-ga.gov, jdickens@kennesaw-ga.gov, ydaniel@kennesaw-ga.gov, jeaton@kennesaw-ga.gov, jdrobney@kennesaw-ga.gov
CC: jon@11alive.com, hbutschek@mdjonline.com, mike.paluska@cbsatlanta.com, will.frampton@cbs46.com, mike.dunston@cbs46.com, lgarrett@mdjonline.com, mlutz@mdjonline.com, Nedra.Rhone@ajc.com, Ty.Tagami@ajc.com
UNFINISHED MATHEWS BUSINESS FOR THE NEW ADMINISTRATION
4 Newcomers to the City Administration may not be aware of the issue of the former mayor having expended City tax money on a private matter wherein he attempted to use City resources to blunt criticism of his administration.
The below is supplied to you for your information and the entire matter, including the Ethics complaint, are dealt with fully at: http://kennesawethicscomplaint.blogspot.com/
The short summary is that in 2014 the mayor was under fire for his and the Cities actions regarding the Castle Lake MHP annexation and rezoning.
I accurately quoted his statements before a KSU Journalism class. These statements made the mayor look foolish and he instructed the City Attorney to draft a 'Cease and Desist' letter to be served on me with threats of legal action for having made up the referenced statements.
He lied to the City Attorney and the Council in order to use his office to attempt to silence my criticism of his actions.
Information from the City Clerk showed an initial expenditure of $1,000 to have the Bentley firm draft and attempt to serve the letter. I believe the final costs put that up to about $1,500.
Council members of that time pointed out to the City Attorney that the quotes were accurate and were available via an online video of his entire 1 1/2 hour talk to the class, plus they were published online by a class member.
The letter was completed and service was attempted but it was never served and was subsequently withdrawn by the City Attorney. I obtained a copy via a FOIA request.
My subsequent Ethics complaint to the City Ethics Board about the mayor's use of City tax money in a private cause was not sustained due to poorly crafted Ethics regulations of that time.
Now that the prior administration is gone it is time for former mayor Mathews to be billed for those funds expended in his private quest to silence a critic of his administration.
The current Mayor and Council are now formally requested to take up the matter and recover the Kennesaw tax money which the former mayor used in his pursuit of his own private matter.
Bill Harris
Citizen Journalist
http://kennesawethicscomplaint.blogspot.com/
------------------------------------------------
1/7/15
TAX $ WELL SPENT OR NOT? Read the article then the comment. OR just skip to the comment which is the real story here.
-----------------------------------
Smith-Gilbert Gardens seeks volunteers
by MDJ staff January 07, 2016 12:00 AM
The Smith-Gilbert Gardens, 2382 Pine Mountain Road in Kennesaw, is seeking volunteers to lead tours of the Gardens.
“The wonder on children’s faces as they admire the koi or see the bonsai tree is so rewarding,” said Stefanie Haerynck, the Garden’s education coordinator.
Haerynck originally started working with the Gardens as a volunteer docent. Now, she helps to schedule docent classes and tours.
Smith-Gilbert Gardens is 16 acres with more than 3,000 species of plants, several rare in American gardens. United by woodland paths, the Gardens consist of separate groupings with individual elements that include the Bonsai Exhibit, Palladino Camellia Garden, tea house and waterfall area, Rose Garden and Conifer Display.
The Smith-Gilbert Gardens is a member of various horticultural groups, including the American Conifer, American Daffodil, American Hosta and the Southeastern Camellia societies. It is also a designated wildlife habitat by the Atlanta Audubon Society and both the Rose Garden and the Conifer Collection have received special recognition as places to visit by their respective societies.
For more information about volunteer training in February, call (770) 919-0248 or email info@smithgilbertgardens.com.
---------------------------------------------
Comment FYI:
Going back 2 Kennesaw election cycles I recall giving some input to a then potential candidate for Council about some issues which we discussed.
Subsequently a statement was put forth about the large deficit being plugged by the City taxes for both the Railroad Museum and the Gardens.
My suggestion after that was put forward was that the issue should be tabled until AFTER the person got elected as it was not going to generate any votes and may well cost votes. The initial reaction was of course negative and the issue was not heard of again, said candidate went on to win.
Years have now gone by with the matter of the black holes eating up Kennesaw tax dollars for both the Railroad museum and Gardens and there is still no sign that there is any interest in taking the matter under consideration.
I said at the time and still say, that there is no good option for either, but both should have a public airing to make the Citizens and Taxpayers aware of how much City money goes into supporting both losing propositions and some hard decisions should be made after discussions as to whether funding of these black holes should continue and if so how much, if any, should be provided by Taxpayers to funding these 2 money losing propositions.
There is no 'upside' here, no correct answer. No one will win any friends by this discussion. No one on the 'old' Council wanted to start the ball rolling. It is like the old story about 'tar baby', once you touch it, you won't be able to get rid of it and you probably won't get any votes for having brought it up.
One major division of opinion here is that it will put the OLD Kennesaw residents, who have heavily backed the museum, which is in fact a railroad museum but is regarded by the old line folks with roots here for generations, as a CIVIL WAR museum, against the relative NEW residents who might really care where their scarce tax dollars are going and who really could not care less about any museum, railroad or Civil War.
Those NEWER residents might want those tax dollars going for better police service or lower taxes and not plowed back into 2 areas which have never showed any profit and never will.
So there is a considerable divide here between the long term City residents (read 'area' residents as not all are within the City limits) and those newer residents, many of which live here and commute to greater Atlanta to work.
Q) Will anything get done with a new Mayor and mostly new Council?
A) Probably not.
KENNESAW — It was a historic night in Kennesaw Monday night as Mayor Derek Easterling and council members Jim Eaton and Yvette Daniel took their oaths of office and presided over their first council meeting.
After being sworn in and taking his place on the dais, Easterling, a retired sheriff’s deputy, told a packed room at City Hall he needed the public’s help in moving the city forward.
“We are but ordinary people put in place to do great things, but we cannot do it without your support. So thank you for being here. This is the beginning,” Easterling said.
Daniel joins Council member Jimmy Dickens as the first black members of the Kennesaw City Council in the city’s history. Though Daniel and Dickens were both elected in November, Dickens took office about six weeks before Daniel because he was elected to fill the unexpired term of former Council member Debra Williams, who resigned to run against Easterling for mayor.
Daniel thanked her family and supporters, calling the feeling of being on the dais “overwhelming.” She was also well aware of the historic nature of her and Dickens’ presence on the council.
“This is a historic moment for all of us, not just me. So pay it forward,” Daniel said.
Marietta Councilman Anthony Coleman was in attendance Monday to offer his support to the new council members. Coleman said he hopes to be a mentor for the new council members, just as he was helped by Councilman Philip Goldstein when he was first elected in 2002.
“This is a very historic moment, and I’m proud of these two people being elected in the city of Kennesaw,” Coleman said. “I know they’re going to do great things.”
Eaton, a professor at Life University and father of outgoing Council Member Cris Eaton-Welsh, said he’s been dreaming of being on the council “for a long time,” and thanked voters for helping get him on the council.
“I’m humbled that you all saw fit to put me up here, and I’m planning to serve you well and faithfully,” Eaton said.
Easterling’s nerves showed a bit as he was leading his first council meeting after the swearing in, though most of the items on the agenda were routine actions for the new year, such as reappointing certain officials and electing a mayor pro tem. Though he stumbled a bit with some of the bureaucratic steps of a meeting, Easterling was quick with a joke to take the edge off the situation.
“I’ll get used to it, I promise. I can only get better,” Easterling said with a smile.
After being sworn in and taking his place on the dais, Easterling, a retired sheriff’s deputy, told a packed room at City Hall he needed the public’s help in moving the city forward.
“We are but ordinary people put in place to do great things, but we cannot do it without your support. So thank you for being here. This is the beginning,” Easterling said.
Daniel joins Council member Jimmy Dickens as the first black members of the Kennesaw City Council in the city’s history. Though Daniel and Dickens were both elected in November, Dickens took office about six weeks before Daniel because he was elected to fill the unexpired term of former Council member Debra Williams, who resigned to run against Easterling for mayor.
Daniel thanked her family and supporters, calling the feeling of being on the dais “overwhelming.” She was also well aware of the historic nature of her and Dickens’ presence on the council.
“This is a historic moment for all of us, not just me. So pay it forward,” Daniel said.
Marietta Councilman Anthony Coleman was in attendance Monday to offer his support to the new council members. Coleman said he hopes to be a mentor for the new council members, just as he was helped by Councilman Philip Goldstein when he was first elected in 2002.
“This is a very historic moment, and I’m proud of these two people being elected in the city of Kennesaw,” Coleman said. “I know they’re going to do great things.”
Eaton, a professor at Life University and father of outgoing Council Member Cris Eaton-Welsh, said he’s been dreaming of being on the council “for a long time,” and thanked voters for helping get him on the council.
“I’m humbled that you all saw fit to put me up here, and I’m planning to serve you well and faithfully,” Eaton said.
Easterling’s nerves showed a bit as he was leading his first council meeting after the swearing in, though most of the items on the agenda were routine actions for the new year, such as reappointing certain officials and electing a mayor pro tem. Though he stumbled a bit with some of the bureaucratic steps of a meeting, Easterling was quick with a joke to take the edge off the situation.
“I’ll get used to it, I promise. I can only get better,” Easterling said with a smile.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1/3/16
In the great scheme of things Kennesaw, I would opine that new Council Member Yvette Daniel is a bit past due for another bankruptcy.
This time around she can unload the large debt she ran up with her exercise/pole dancing business at B J Patels strip mall in Kennesaw.
2 Bankruptcy Results | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Party Name | Court | Case | Ch | Date Filed | Date Closed | Disposition | |||
Yvette Daniel | |||||||||
1 | Daniel, Yvette (pla) | gasbke | 1:02-ap-01101 | 11/25/2002 | 07/31/2003 | Dismissed or Settled Without Entry of Judgment | |||
Daniel and Aurora Loan Services | |||||||||
2 | Daniel, Yvette E. (db) | ganbke | 1:96-bk-64735 | 7 | 03/25/1996 | 02/24/1998 | Standard Discharge 02/24/1998 |
See: http://catcherfreeman.blogspot.com/ and also
https://www.facebook.com/n/?catcher.freeman.180&aref=1444856639422229&medium=email&mid=522169d287c43G5af51055274aG52216e6be7f15G52Gaa39&bcode=1.1444856639.AblPjOF9YVd42rXG&n_m=harris2016@aol.com&lloc=image
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Powder Springs, Kennesaw mayors to be sworn in
January 04, 2016 MDJ
MARIETTA — New leadership comes with the new year for the cities of Powder Springs and Kennesaw as mayors-elect Al Thurman and Derek Easterling will be sworn into their respective cities tonight.
Thurman, a 58-year-old former councilman and landscaping business owner, will be sworn in as Powder Springs’ first black mayor.
Meanwhile, former sheriff’s deputy and retired Navy Lt. Easterling, 55, will be sworn in as Kennesaw’s new mayor after Mark Mathews, mayor of eight years, chose not to run for re-election.
MOVING FORWARD WITH OPPORTUNITY
The position as Kennesaw mayor will be Easterling’s first experience with politics, but he said he is ready to get started.
“I’m super excited about the opportunity. That’s what I’m looking forward to, the opportunity to move forward,” Easterling said.
After his swearing-in during tonight’s city council meeting, Easterling said one of the first issues he plans to tackle is inclusion.
“My first order of business is truly to get through (tonight) and then begin listening to a knowledgeable staff because it’s all about the learning curve,” he said.
Councilman Jimmy Dickens, who was elected as the city’s first black councilman in November, said he’s excited to see Easterling’s vision.
“We’re all excited for the new mayor, but we’re also going to miss Mark,” Dickens said. “Mark did an outstanding job.”
Dickens said he was sad to see outgoing councilmembers Tim Killingsworth and Cris Eaton-Welsh leave, but he was eager to begin working with the new council — including Yvette Daniel, also one of Kennesaw’s first black councilmembers.
Easterling will be sworn in at Kennesaw Council Chambers at 6:30 p.m. with a reception immediately following the city council meeting.
Thurman, a 58-year-old former councilman and landscaping business owner, will be sworn in as Powder Springs’ first black mayor.
Meanwhile, former sheriff’s deputy and retired Navy Lt. Easterling, 55, will be sworn in as Kennesaw’s new mayor after Mark Mathews, mayor of eight years, chose not to run for re-election.
MOVING FORWARD WITH OPPORTUNITY
The position as Kennesaw mayor will be Easterling’s first experience with politics, but he said he is ready to get started.
“I’m super excited about the opportunity. That’s what I’m looking forward to, the opportunity to move forward,” Easterling said.
After his swearing-in during tonight’s city council meeting, Easterling said one of the first issues he plans to tackle is inclusion.
“My first order of business is truly to get through (tonight) and then begin listening to a knowledgeable staff because it’s all about the learning curve,” he said.
Councilman Jimmy Dickens, who was elected as the city’s first black councilman in November, said he’s excited to see Easterling’s vision.
“We’re all excited for the new mayor, but we’re also going to miss Mark,” Dickens said. “Mark did an outstanding job.”
Dickens said he was sad to see outgoing councilmembers Tim Killingsworth and Cris Eaton-Welsh leave, but he was eager to begin working with the new council — including Yvette Daniel, also one of Kennesaw’s first black councilmembers.
Easterling will be sworn in at Kennesaw Council Chambers at 6:30 p.m. with a reception immediately following the city council meeting.
MDJ Top 10: No. 3 - Church sentenced to 18 years for child molestation, pornography
January 01, 2016 12:00 AM
MARIETTA — Kennesaw Councilman and former mayor Leonard Church was sentenced to 18 years in prison on Dec. 7 after pleading guilty to child molestation and possession of child pornography, putting an end to a saga that began with his arrest in the summer of 2014.
Church accepted a plea deal from Cobb District Attorney Vic Reynolds after refusing to step down for a year and a half, despite his arrest and subsequent indictment on six counts: aggravated child molestation, child molestation, and four counts of sexual exploitation of children for child pornography.
A fixture of Kennesaw public life for over two decades, Church admitted to molesting and showing pornography to a then-9-year-old boy at his home in spring of 2014. The child came forward several weeks later, and investigators eventually discovered between 800 and 1,000 images of child pornography on computers belonging to Church.
Church cried in court as he admitted guilt, but offered no words of apology or explanation.
Reynolds said his office agreed to a plea deal, which reduced the aggravated child molestation charge to child molestation, in order to spare the child from having to take the stand.
“It’s easier to admit a murder than it is molesting a child and possessing the volume of child pornography that he possessed,” Reynolds said. “I hope and pray that he was remorseful for what he’s done. … I can tell you he’s going to have a long time to think about it.”
A special election to fill Church’s seat is scheduled to run concurrently with primary elections on May 24, 2016.
While retiring Mayor Mark Mathews insisted that Kennesaw City Council had continued to conduct “business as usual,” retiring Council member Cris Eaton-Welsh said she and many others were angry that Church refused to resign.
“Why would you carry a community that you love through the darkest chapter of your life?” she asked.
Church accepted a plea deal from Cobb District Attorney Vic Reynolds after refusing to step down for a year and a half, despite his arrest and subsequent indictment on six counts: aggravated child molestation, child molestation, and four counts of sexual exploitation of children for child pornography.
A fixture of Kennesaw public life for over two decades, Church admitted to molesting and showing pornography to a then-9-year-old boy at his home in spring of 2014. The child came forward several weeks later, and investigators eventually discovered between 800 and 1,000 images of child pornography on computers belonging to Church.
Church cried in court as he admitted guilt, but offered no words of apology or explanation.
Reynolds said his office agreed to a plea deal, which reduced the aggravated child molestation charge to child molestation, in order to spare the child from having to take the stand.
“It’s easier to admit a murder than it is molesting a child and possessing the volume of child pornography that he possessed,” Reynolds said. “I hope and pray that he was remorseful for what he’s done. … I can tell you he’s going to have a long time to think about it.”
A special election to fill Church’s seat is scheduled to run concurrently with primary elections on May 24, 2016.
While retiring Mayor Mark Mathews insisted that Kennesaw City Council had continued to conduct “business as usual,” retiring Council member Cris Eaton-Welsh said she and many others were angry that Church refused to resign.
“Why would you carry a community that you love through the darkest chapter of your life?” she asked.
Davey Crockett on Facebook at:
NEIGHBOR, HOW STANDS THE UNION?
If Daniel Webster were to return today and ask this question, what do you think the answer would be?
The days of admiring the 'bright shining city on a hill' seem to be gone and the Country is ill served by a worthless President and a Congress that has an approval rating of 9 percent of those polled.
Are our 'best days' behind us or can we recover both with our economy and our place in the world leadership?
The 2016 elections may be out last chance to stop our decline and reply: "she stands as she stood, rock-bottomed and copper-sheathed, one and indivisible."
------------------------------------------
"Neighbor, how stands the Union?" from 'the Devil & Daniel Webster'
Yes, Dan'l Webster's dead ----- or, at least, they buried him. But every time there's a thunderstorm around Marshfield, they say you can hear his rolling voice in the hollows of the sky. And they say that if you go to his grave and speak loud and clear, "Dan'l Webster ----- Dan'l Webster!" the ground'll begin to shiver and the trees begin to shake. And after a while you'll hear a deep voice saying, "Neighbor, how stands the Union?" Then you better answer the Union stands as she stood, rock-bottomed and copper-sheathed, one and indivisible, or he's liable to rear right out of the ground. At least, that's what I was told when I was a youngster.
by steven vincent benet
------------------------------------------------
12/25/15
NEXT COURT DATE FOR THE CASTLE LAKE MHP CIVIL SUIT
For the few people who are keeping up with this potential 'class action' civil suit against the Castle Lake MHP, on 12/15/15 the next Court date was set by Superior Court Judge Kell for July 22, 2016.
2 1/2 hours are reserved and the Order of Special Setting is below FYI.
Should this actually go to trial it may well be another 2 years, or about six months after the new 450,000 sq ft retail center is opened for business.
See also: http://castlelakemhp.blogspot.com/
NEIGHBOR, HOW STANDS THE UNION?
If Daniel Webster were to return today and ask this question, what do you think the answer would be?
The days of admiring the 'bright shining city on a hill' seem to be gone and the Country is ill served by a worthless President and a Congress that has an approval rating of 9 percent of those polled.
Are our 'best days' behind us or can we recover both with our economy and our place in the world leadership?
The 2016 elections may be out last chance to stop our decline and reply: "she stands as she stood, rock-bottomed and copper-sheathed, one and indivisible."
------------------------------------------
"Neighbor, how stands the Union?" from 'the Devil & Daniel Webster'
Yes, Dan'l Webster's dead ----- or, at least, they buried him. But every time there's a thunderstorm around Marshfield, they say you can hear his rolling voice in the hollows of the sky. And they say that if you go to his grave and speak loud and clear, "Dan'l Webster ----- Dan'l Webster!" the ground'll begin to shiver and the trees begin to shake. And after a while you'll hear a deep voice saying, "Neighbor, how stands the Union?" Then you better answer the Union stands as she stood, rock-bottomed and copper-sheathed, one and indivisible, or he's liable to rear right out of the ground. At least, that's what I was told when I was a youngster.
by steven vincent benet
------------------------------------------------
12/25/15
NEXT COURT DATE FOR THE CASTLE LAKE MHP CIVIL SUIT
Should this actually go to trial it may well be another 2 years, or about six months after the new 450,000 sq ft retail center is opened for business.
See also: http://castlelakemhp.blogspot.com/
12/23/15
CASTLE LAKE MHP SITE KENNESAW
Days of rain and the Holiday have temporarily closed down the 52 acre construction project on the old home of the Castle Lake trailer park.
Castle Lake Info is available at these sites:
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
12/21/15
CHURCH, LEONARD LEROY
GDC ID: 1001688600
PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION
YOB: 1948 RACE: WHITE GENDER: MALE HEIGHT: 5'11''
WEIGHT: 190 EYE COLOR: BROWN HAIR COLOR: GRAY
INCARCERATION DETAILS
MAJOR OFFENSE: CHILD MOLESTATION
MOST RECENT INSTITUTION: COASTAL STATE PRISON
MAX POSSIBLE RELEASE DATE: 12/03/2033 Important Release Information
For parole information please go to Georgia State Board of Pardons and Paroles website.
ACTUAL RELEASE DATE: CURRENTLY SERVING
CURRENT STATUS: ACTIVE
KNOWN ALIASES A.K.A. CHURCH,LEONARD LEROY
STATE OF GEORGIA - CURRENT SENTENCES
CASE NO: 814657
OFFENSE: SEX EXPLOITATION CHILD
CONVICTION COUNTY: COBB COUNTY
CRIME COMMIT DATE: 05/15/2014
SENTENCE LENGTH: 20 YEARS, 0 MONTHS, 0 DAYS
CASE NO: 814657
OFFENSE: CHILD MOLESTATION
CONVICTION COUNTY: COBB COUNTY
CRIME COMMIT DATE: 05/09/2014
SENTENCE LENGTH: 20 YEARS, 0 MONTHS, 0 DAYS
CASE NO: 814657
OFFENSE: CHILD MOLESTATION
CONVICTION COUNTY: COBB COUNTY
CRIME COMMIT DATE: 05/09/2014
SENTENCE LENGTH: 20 YEARS, 0 MONTHS, 0 DAYS
CASE NO: 814657
OFFENSE: SEX EXPLOITATION CHILD
CONVICTION COUNTY: COBB COUNTY
CRIME COMMIT DATE: 12/07/2006
SENTENCE LENGTH: 20 YEARS, 0 MONTHS, 0 DAYS
CASE NO: 814657
OFFENSE: SEX EXPLOITATION CHILD
CONVICTION COUNTY: COBB COUNTY
CRIME COMMIT DATE: 12/07/2006
SENTENCE LENGTH: 20 YEARS, 0 MONTHS, 0 DAYS
CASE NO: 814657
OFFENSE: SEX EXPLOITATION CHILD
CONVICTION COUNTY: COBB COUNTY
CRIME COMMIT DATE: 12/07/2006
SENTENCE LENGTH: 20 YEARS, 0 MONTHS, 0 DAYS
2/17/15
Credit monitoring sign-up opens for Georgia voters
by Kathleen Foody, Associated Press December 16, 2015
ATLANTA (AP) — An online sign-up for free credit monitoring opened Wednesday for registered voters whose personal information was released to media and political parties by the Georgia secretary of state's office.
The services with CSID opened Wednesday, 12 days after Secretary of State Brian Kemp announced that his office would cover the estimated $1.2 million cost with reserve funds. People registered to vote as of Oct. 13 can sign up for the services through Feb. 14.
"While I am confident that every voter's personal data is secure, these services are being offered to provide Georgia voters with peace of mind," Kemp said in a written statement.
Voters can sign up for the service at https://www.csid.com/gasos .
A lawsuit filed in November revealed that media and political parties received 12 CDs labeled Oct. 13 containing Social Security and drivers' license numbers and birth dates for nearly 6.2 million registered voters. Kemp has said his office destroyed or accounted for all of the discs.
A report produced by his office and released this week contained no details about that process. At least one recipient who regularly received the voter file has said he threw away the October disc, not realizing it contained sensitive information.
Kemp's office regularly sends an updated list of all registered voters in the state to political parties and news organizations as required by Georgia law. The state sells the file to others. It is supposed to include only a voter's name, residence, mailing address, race, gender, registration date and last voting date.
The report from Kemp's office faulted an employee in the office's Information Technology Division for violating policies and procedures, being unclear with a contractor and giving another employee his login to access a file containing voters' information.
The employee, Gary Cooley, was fired Nov. 17. He has said the report contained "a number of untrue statements."
Kemp has hired the Deloitte consulting firm to audit his office's technology operations, costing $395,000.
Gov. Nathan Deal this week also appointed three private-practice lawyers as special attorneys general representing Kemp in the lawsuit filed by two Georgia voters. No cost estimate was provided.
Deal's executive order said Attorney General Sam Olens and the Georgia Department of Law declined to represent Kemp "due to the potential conflict of interest." A spokesman for Olens said the office's consumer protection responsibilities could cause a conflict.
===============================
KEEP READING PEOPLE:
You might think that you are going to get a free look at your 3 credit reports.
Nope, not gonna happen. Here is what you get after you sign up:
"Welcome to the CSID Identity Monitoring Portal, provided on behalf of the Georgia Secretary of State.
You have now been enrolled into comprehensive credit and identity monitoring services.
You will receive Email notifications in the event that there are identity alerts to detect if there is any fraudulent activity around key pieces of your personal information, as well if there are any changes to your TransUnion credit file."
and:
"Alerts Summary
Good news! You have no new alerts. We are actively monitoring your identity. You will receive an email notification if there are changes to your credit report, or if your monitored personal information is found to be compromised.
Good news! You have no new alerts. We are actively monitoring your identity. You will receive an email notification if there are changes to your credit report, or if your monitored personal information is found to be compromised.
CSID Protector Coverage Includes:
Credit Monitoring:
TransUnion® credit monitoring for changes in your credit file, such as credit inquires, delinquencies, judgments and liens, bankruptcies, new loans and more.
Internet Surveillance:
Monitors websites, chat rooms and bulletin boards 24/7 to identify trading or selling of your personal information.
Change of Address Monitoring:
Monitor to see if someone has redirected your mail.
Social Security Number Trace:
Know if your Social Security number becomes associated with another individual’s name or address.
Identity Restoration:
Work with a certified identity theft restoration specialist to restore your identity and let you get on with your life. This service is available for affected individuals even if you do not enroll.
______________________________
From the MDJ of 12/15/15 Letters Column
12/12/15
CASTLE LAKE - ROUND 2 IN SUPERIOR COURT
Regular readers of my various blog sites(*) are well aware of the Castle Lake Mobile Home Park and how 2/3rds of that downmarket trailer park was abruptly rezoned and brought into the City of Kennesaw, all in a remarkable time of 28 days from proposal to approval and also how badly the low income tenants were treated by Jeff Fuqua ("Atlanta's Most Controversial Developer") and the Vancouver, BC slum lords of the Ergas family.
The trailers on those 52 acres are now gone, the retiries, low income residents and the large Hispanic population are all scattered to other parks, counties and even other states.
The land clearing for the new 450,000 sq ft retail and residential buildings is well advanced. You can have lunch at the IHOP and watch the blasting and earth moving while you have lunch, which was quite likely prepared and served by former CLMHP residents as several cooks and waitresses once resided at the park and probably still work at IHOP.
What you may not be aware of, is that 10 months ago a dozen former residents and trailer owners of this park banded together and filed what is hoped to be a 'class action' suit against 3 of the corprate entities of the Canadian slumlord* for various misdeeds over the years in the administration of the MHP(**).
The matter is alive and well, slowly winding its way through the convoluted Georgia legal system.
It is likely to be in the courts for several more years as these cases are seldom short and sweet.
The latest activity is just last month but going back one month more you find an interesting letter from the Plaintiff's law firm (see attached) and to show you just how litigious this is I will briefly quote from the Carroll Law Firm's 10/15/15 letter to Judge Kell. Keep in mind that delay is usual for Defendants in such proceedings, they benefit from drawing out such suits and 'papering' Plaintiffs as you will see is being done here:
"Dear Judge Kell:
I represent the Plaintiffs in the above-referenced class action lawsuit, which was filed on February 13, 2015. Plaintiffs would like to request that the discovery conference pertaining to class certification issues, as contemplated by OCGA 9-11-23(f)(1), be scheduled so that a scheduling order regarding class certification discovery and motions can be established.
Plaintiffs would also like to address at the conference voluminous discovery requests that Defendants have recently served on the class Plaintiffs. Collectively, Defendants have served Plaintiffs with 2,448 Requests for Admission, 756 Interrogatories, and 216 Requests for Production. Because such discovery relates to the merits of the case rather than class certification, and because the class certification discovery conference has not yet occurred,
Plaintiffs have objected to such discovery as premature".
While the millions of dollars of profit for the sale of those 52 acres is probably long out of reach of the Plaintiffs, there remains another 23 acres of the CLMHP and while it remains in the County the land is extremely valuable with the major retail and townhome development just across Noonday Creek from the shabby park.
Even with the delays by the CL lawyers, any future class judgment against the park owners is likely to result in substantial payouts to all those who have lived under egregious conditions mandated by the park owners(***).
Eventually the case will be tried for those 12 original plaintiffs and perhaps, if the class is certified, there will be hundreds or thousands who might benefit from this civil action.
-----------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------
** 1) Castle Lake Homes Corp, 2) Masal Partners Ltd LP and 3) Amak Partners LP. These are the offshoots of the Vancouver, B.C., Canada firm called 'The Ergas Group', owned by a wealthy Jewish family of property investors in Vancouver.
----------------------------------------------
*** What is the Castle Lake suit all about?
This class action lawsuit is premised on the egregious conduct of Defendants, who preyed on low-income tenants in Defendants' mobile home park by illegally taking on the role of law enforcement and ticketing and fining them - sometimes in amounts exceeding their rent - and by secretly charging those tenants for water and sewer usage well in excess of the amounts actually paid by Defendants to Cobb County.
Plaintiffs' Class Action complaint sets forth two classes of plaintiffs:
(1) All current and former tenants of Castle Lake Mobile Home Park who paid any Defendant for purported water and/or sewer charges; and
(2) All current and former tenants of Castle Lake Mobile Home Park who paid any Defendant for any fine or penalty.
Collectively, Defendants are the owners, operators and managers of a 300 plus lot mobile home park in Kennesaw, known as Castle Lake mobile Home Park (CLMHP). All of the 300 plus lots in CLMHP are rented to tenants on a month-to-month basis pursuant to written lease agreements.
Georgia law prohibits fines and penalties in contracts and such penalties are legally void and unenforceable. Nevertheless, Defendants repeatedly ticketed, fined and penalized tenants for alleged trivial violations and for alleged violations not listed in the tenants' lease agreements, such as parking in a neighbor's driveway with that neighbor's permission, hosting a birthday party or playing music.
Defendants threatened eviction, either expressly or implicitly, to all tenants who did not promptly pay the illegal fines, thereby extorting payment from each tenant. Illegal fines sometimes exceeding the amount of the tenant's monthly rent payment.
_______________________________
12/11/15
8 FINAL DOCUMENTS filed in the Closed Kennesaw Church case, are now available at: http://leonardchurch.blogspot.com/
Additional documents have been filed and most of the case can be seen at the Cobb County Superior Court web site.
-----------------------------------------------------------
12/9/15
A FINAL WORD ON KENNESAW'S PEDOPHILE COUNCILMAN
----------------------------------------
Below is from the City of Kennesaw Internet site. Keep in mind that the various mayor and Council members statements on the matter come AFTER Pedophile Church admitted his guilt on the 6 Felony charges.
A worthless mayor and 4 useless Council members allowed this creep to sit on the dais with them from 6/27/14 until his conviction 12/7/15. Not one of these useless excuses for public servants had the guts to stand up on their hind legs and DEMAND that this sick SOB resign his position.
Yes, all of us with connected brain cells know that he could not be forced to resign but he should have been confronted in the open at Council meetings with the mayor's and Council's demands that he resign. The City should have been on record from 6/28/14 that he was UNWANTED on the City Council.
Now the mayor and Council members are slowly crawling out from their hiding places and whining and moaning about how they could not have done anything and they claim that they had quietly asked him to resign and he refused.
Quietly asking some scumbag in a back hallway to quit is useless, even if it did happen and I'm not sure it ever did.
What I know is that this totally useless group of elected officials not only refused to say anything in public BUT Debbie Williams came to the defense of this scumbag and her comments are on video tape and are summarized in the minutes of the Council.
This defense of Pedophile Church came after a local citizen spoke to the Council asking why they remained silent and HE demanded Church resign when the mayor and Council would not do so.
Debbie Williams subsequently resigned her seat to run for mayor and of course she lost big time, by 385 votes as I recall, and this was due in large part to her having come to the defense of Pedophile Church.
2016 finds Kennesaw with a new Mayor and 3 new people on the Council. None of these people have the baggage of the old administration and hopefully if some similar situation comes up they will have the guts that their predecessors did not have and they would handle the issue in a direct and forceful manner.
Those elected officials departing should go into retirement throughly ashamed of their silence for all those months that they sat next to this scumbag and said nothing.
----- From The City Site -----
Special Election Will Be Held to Fill Council Vacancy
December 7th, 2015 by Pam Davis
The following statement was released by Mayor Mark Mathews following the report of the conviction of former Councilmember Leonard Church:
“Our thoughts and prayers are with anyone who may have been affected by the former Councilmember’s actions. With the announcement of Church’s plea from District Attorney Reynold’s office, a vacancy has been immediately created on our city council. In accordance with state law and our city charter, a special election will be held in May to fill the vacant seat. As a city, we are closing this unfortunate chapter and moving forward.”
More information will be provided on the details of the Special Election in the coming weeks.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With Councilman’s plea deal, the black clouds lift over Kennesaw
December 09, 2015 MDJ Editorial
In a surprise move, Kennesaw Councilman Leonard Church, 67, pleaded guilty Monday to six counts of sex crimes against children, bringing an end to the black cloud over Kennesaw politics for the last 17 months.
The plea requires him to serve 18 years in prison. (Had a jury found Church guilty, he faced a lifetime sentence plus 100 years.) Ending this nightmare before it went to trial was the best outcome for the victim, the courts and the people and politics of Kennesaw.
Church’s plea was part of a negotiated plea bargain with the district attorney’s office that spared his victim, a 9-year-old boy, from having to take the stand.
“In this case, as in any case of this nature, it’s the state’s primary concern to keep the victim off the stand, as well as to not re-victimize the children (depicted in) the photographs,” said the assistant district attorney prosecuting the case, Hannah Palmquist.
Church would have had three fewer years to serve in prison had he not rejected the district attorney’s offer last month of a 15-year prison sentence. But for whatever reason, he turned that offer down.
It was not until the first day of the trial Monday as jury selection was set to begin that he decided to accept the terms of the harsher punishment.
In the end, the plea deal is the best course for all involved. It saves the community from a protracted trial that would have attracted the kind of negative publicity no one in Kennesaw wants. It saves the young victim from having to take the traumatizing step of testifying and potentially being painted a liar by Church’s defense attorneys. And it allows the Kennesaw City Council to move on with the business of governing the city.
After his arrest on June 27, 2014, Church’s ability to serve his constituents was severely impaired with a court order preventing him from entering City Hall through the front door, given that children are able to attend council meetings. Instead, he had to attend the meetings by entering and exiting through a backdoor. A court order required him to be separated from the audience “by a long podium” allowing him “no contact with nor interaction with audience members.”
The councilman was also reportedly quiet during council meetings, rather than arguing on behalf of his constituents. Although, even if he were to debate, his ability to make any convincing argument was overshadowed by the criminal charges.
Retiring Councilwoman Cris Eaton-Welsh repeatedly called for Church to step down while he faced the charges, a call he ignored.
“It was completely counterproductive and very uncomfortable” to have him on the council, Welsh said.
District Attorney Vic Reynolds shed some light on why Church may have not stepped down, saying it’s easier to admit murder than admit molesting a child and possessing such a large volume of child pornography. Investigators found between 800 and 1,000 images of child pornography on computer devices in Church’s home.
“I hope and pray that he was remorseful for what he’s done … whether … (his tears were) sincere or not, I can tell you he’s going to have a long time to think about it,” Reynolds said.
Following his plea deal, Church was transported directly to the county jail in preparation for transfer to Jackson State Prison. A special election for this council seat is set for May.
The dark cloud overhanging Kennesaw since Church’s arrest 17 months ago has now lifted.
For Mayor-elect Derek Easterling and new members of the Kennesaw City Council, the plea deal offers a fresh start for the New Year. With this horrifying chapter in the city’s history behind them, city leaders can carry out what they were elected to do in a positive environment free of the distractions.
The plea requires him to serve 18 years in prison. (Had a jury found Church guilty, he faced a lifetime sentence plus 100 years.) Ending this nightmare before it went to trial was the best outcome for the victim, the courts and the people and politics of Kennesaw.
Church’s plea was part of a negotiated plea bargain with the district attorney’s office that spared his victim, a 9-year-old boy, from having to take the stand.
“In this case, as in any case of this nature, it’s the state’s primary concern to keep the victim off the stand, as well as to not re-victimize the children (depicted in) the photographs,” said the assistant district attorney prosecuting the case, Hannah Palmquist.
Church would have had three fewer years to serve in prison had he not rejected the district attorney’s offer last month of a 15-year prison sentence. But for whatever reason, he turned that offer down.
It was not until the first day of the trial Monday as jury selection was set to begin that he decided to accept the terms of the harsher punishment.
In the end, the plea deal is the best course for all involved. It saves the community from a protracted trial that would have attracted the kind of negative publicity no one in Kennesaw wants. It saves the young victim from having to take the traumatizing step of testifying and potentially being painted a liar by Church’s defense attorneys. And it allows the Kennesaw City Council to move on with the business of governing the city.
After his arrest on June 27, 2014, Church’s ability to serve his constituents was severely impaired with a court order preventing him from entering City Hall through the front door, given that children are able to attend council meetings. Instead, he had to attend the meetings by entering and exiting through a backdoor. A court order required him to be separated from the audience “by a long podium” allowing him “no contact with nor interaction with audience members.”
The councilman was also reportedly quiet during council meetings, rather than arguing on behalf of his constituents. Although, even if he were to debate, his ability to make any convincing argument was overshadowed by the criminal charges.
Retiring Councilwoman Cris Eaton-Welsh repeatedly called for Church to step down while he faced the charges, a call he ignored.
“It was completely counterproductive and very uncomfortable” to have him on the council, Welsh said.
District Attorney Vic Reynolds shed some light on why Church may have not stepped down, saying it’s easier to admit murder than admit molesting a child and possessing such a large volume of child pornography. Investigators found between 800 and 1,000 images of child pornography on computer devices in Church’s home.
“I hope and pray that he was remorseful for what he’s done … whether … (his tears were) sincere or not, I can tell you he’s going to have a long time to think about it,” Reynolds said.
Following his plea deal, Church was transported directly to the county jail in preparation for transfer to Jackson State Prison. A special election for this council seat is set for May.
The dark cloud overhanging Kennesaw since Church’s arrest 17 months ago has now lifted.
For Mayor-elect Derek Easterling and new members of the Kennesaw City Council, the plea deal offers a fresh start for the New Year. With this horrifying chapter in the city’s history behind them, city leaders can carry out what they were elected to do in a positive environment free of the distractions.
___________________________
KENNESAW ELECTORIAL LINE UP CHANGES FOR 2016
Two years ago, the 'winds of change' started blowing for the long running Mathews administration.
The 2015 elections have finished off the remaining members and a few others for good measure.
With the Church seat now set to come up in a May 2016 Special Election the chess board of Kennesaw politics still lacks that one piece. We will just have to wait and see who takes that seat to see how calm or tumultuous the next 2 or 4 years will be.
The current 4 person City Council will not find itself deadlocked on votes as any Council tie can be broken by the Mayor casting the deciding vote.
Of the top 6 elective positions in 2015 only one will continue into the 2016 term.
The Kennesaw scorecard so far shows:
1 City Council member resigned and failed in her bid for
Mayor, (Debbie Williams)
1 Mayor who did not seek another term, (Mathews)
1 long standing Council member who lost the recent election, (Killingsworth)
1 Council member who did not run for another term, (Welsh)
1 Council member who lost his seat after pleading guilty to various Felony charges, (Church)
While it is always 'possible' that a former serving Council member will run for the vacant Church seat we would remind those potential candidates that they are OUT of office for a good reason and we hope they will continue in their retirement and let another 'new face' take the Council seat this May.
______________________________
Special election to be held for Church’s Kennesaw City Council seat
December 08, 2015
MARIETTA — The City of Kennesaw will hold a special election in May to fill the City Council seat previously held by Leonard Church, the former mayor and councilman who pleaded guilty to child molestation and child pornography charges Monday.
Church had refused to step down following his arrest in June 2014 and indictment in January 2015. His conviction leaves his seat open immediately, and just over a month after Kennesaw held municipal elections.
Mayor Mark Mathews offered “thoughts and prayers” to “anyone who may have been affected by the former Councilmember’s actions,” in a statement announcing the special election.
Janine Eveler, director of the Cobb Board of Elections and Registration, said she anticipated the special election would be held concurrently with primary elections on May 24.
“I’m glad that the whole thing is over with,” Mathews told the MDJ. He denied that Church’s presence on the council was a distraction.
“We’ve just been business as usual,” he said.
Councilmember Cris Eaton-Welsh, who has repeatedly called for Church to step down, painted a different picture of the atmosphere on the council over the past year and a half since Church’s arrest.
“It was completely counterproductive and very uncomfortable” to have him on the council, she said.
Eaton-Welsh said many people were angry that Church refused to step down, only to plead guilty.
“Why would you carry a community that you love through the darkest chapter of your life?” she asked.
City Attorney Randall Bentley said he was still researching whether Church would lose his vestment in the city’s pension plan.
Councilmen Jim Sebastian and Tim Killingsworth could not be reached for comment. Mayor-elect Derek Eastlering could also not be reached for comment.
Church had refused to step down following his arrest in June 2014 and indictment in January 2015. His conviction leaves his seat open immediately, and just over a month after Kennesaw held municipal elections.
Mayor Mark Mathews offered “thoughts and prayers” to “anyone who may have been affected by the former Councilmember’s actions,” in a statement announcing the special election.
Janine Eveler, director of the Cobb Board of Elections and Registration, said she anticipated the special election would be held concurrently with primary elections on May 24.
“We’ve just been business as usual,” he said.
Councilmember Cris Eaton-Welsh, who has repeatedly called for Church to step down, painted a different picture of the atmosphere on the council over the past year and a half since Church’s arrest.
“It was completely counterproductive and very uncomfortable” to have him on the council, she said.
Eaton-Welsh said many people were angry that Church refused to step down, only to plead guilty.
“Why would you carry a community that you love through the darkest chapter of your life?” she asked.
City Attorney Randall Bentley said he was still researching whether Church would lose his vestment in the city’s pension plan.
Councilmen Jim Sebastian and Tim Killingsworth could not be reached for comment. Mayor-elect Derek Eastlering could also not be reached for comment.
Former Kennesaw mayor admits to child molestation
WSB-TV (ABC) Monday, Dec. 7, 2015
COBB COUNTY, Ga. —
The former mayor of Kennesaw passed on a plea deal and admitted to child molestation charges on Monday.
Leonard Church, 67, stood before a Cobb County judge and pleaded guilty to two counts of child molestation and four counts of sexual exploitation of a child.
He is a two-term mayor who most recently served on the City Council.
Church admitted he molested a 9-year-old and exposed the child to 800,000 images of child pornography.
Channel 2’s Dave Huddleston sat in the courtroom behind Church as he received his sentence – 40 years, to serve 18.
Church will be 85 years old when he gets out of prison under strict supervision that keeps him away from all minors.
Prosecutors said Church abused the boy in the spring of 2014.
“Hopefully by what’s happened today the parents can explain to this young victim that you were believed. That not only did the DA’s office believe you but everyone in the court because this defendant has accepted responsibility,” said Cobb County District Attorney Vic Reynolds.
Church was offered a plea deal two months ago but rejected it. The sentence is severe but it’s a sentence that prosecutors and the victim’s family said provides justice.
An election for Church’s council seat will be held in May.
-------------------------------------
Kennesaw Councilman pleads guilty to child molestation, gets 18 years in Prison
December 07, 2015
Kennesaw Councilman Leonard Church faces
an 18-year prison sentence after pleading guilty to child molestation and other
charges Monday morning as his jury trial was set to begin. .
Church, 67, a former mayor of Kennesaw, was arrested in June 2014 and charged with six counts — aggravated child molestation, child molestation and four counts of sexual exploitation of children for allegedly possessing child pornography.
The aggravated child molestation charge was reduced to a second count of child molestation as part of the plea deal.
Church was sentenced to 40 years Monday, with 18 years to serve in prison and the remainder on probation.
The Kennesaw councilman rejected a plea deal from the Cobb District Attorney’s office in November that would have seen him receive a 30-year sentence with 15 years to serve in prison.
----------------------------------------------
Church, 67, a former mayor of Kennesaw, was arrested in June 2014 and charged with six counts — aggravated child molestation, child molestation and four counts of sexual exploitation of children for allegedly possessing child pornography.
The aggravated child molestation charge was reduced to a second count of child molestation as part of the plea deal.
Church was sentenced to 40 years Monday, with 18 years to serve in prison and the remainder on probation.
The Kennesaw councilman rejected a plea deal from the Cobb District Attorney’s office in November that would have seen him receive a 30-year sentence with 15 years to serve in prison.
Leonard Church trial to start Monday; defense faces difficult balancing act
MDJ Article of December 05, 2015
MARIETTA — Kennesaw Councilman Leonard Church’s defense team will have to convince jurors that he is innocent of sexually molesting a 9-year-old boy and possessing child pornography without appearing to go after the alleged victim, several defense attorneys who are unconnected to the case told the MDJ.
Church’s trial is scheduled to begin Monday, when Cobb Superior Court Judge Mary Staley is expected to deny a motion submitted by the defense to compel the prosecution to hand over copies of certain evidence.
Church, 66, a former mayor of Kennesaw, was arrested in June 2014 and charged with six counts — aggravated child molestation, child molestation and four counts of sexual exploitation of children for allegedly possessing child pornography.
Defense attorneys who have represented clients accused of sex crimes against children said the prosecution will likely center its case around the testimony of the boy and the evidence collected from Church’s computers.
The defense could try to undermine the prosecution’s timeline, which Church’s lawyers have already indicated they intend to do. They could also attempt to show that Church was unaware of the child pornography prosecutors say was stored on his computers, or argue that the child was coached or somehow influenced to make his accusation.
However, focusing too hard on the boy could backfire.
“You can’t go after a kid, the jury is going to hate your guts,” said Jill Polster, an attorney with the Cohen Law Firm in Atlanta.
She said often there was not much to be gained through cross examination of a child witness, but some attorneys choose to ask the child seemingly innocuous details in an attempt to discover inconsistencies, such as asking them to recall details of the room where the alleged abuse took place.
John Garland of Garland, Samuel & Loeb in Atlanta, said strict guidelines exist for forensic interviews with children because deviation could bias the testimony.
“The child may in fact believe it’s true” even if it’s not, he said. Rather than accuse the child of lying, he said, a good defense lawyer would highlight external factors that could have influenced the child by asking questions such as “isn’t it true that this person was disciplining you? Isn’t it true that your mother had just caught you watching porn when you said that?” At a hearing last month, Church’s lawyers suggested a similar tack, arguing they needed more time to examine a PlayStation on which the child was allegedly caught viewing porn.
Attorney Kevin Pratt of Atlanta said when working with young children he would talk to them about their imagination.
“Try to show that he was told a story and that he’s just retelling that story,” he said, adding that the defense could also question the motives of the first person the child reported the abuse to.
The prosecution, led by Assistant District Attorney Hannah Palmquist, will not rely solely on witness testimony, however. Polster said the child pornography allegedly found on Church’s computer would be seen to substantiate the child’s accusations.
“If they find him guilty of child porn, they will convict him on the other charges,” she said. “That’s an uphill battle on that defense.”
Garland said the case could hinge on the analysis of the devices taken from Church’s home. He said details such as whether the contraband was in the search history or downloaded, how it was downloaded and whether it was buried in a larger file or mislabeled could all help put distance between Church and the images.
“There has to be a detailed analysis of how the images ended up on the computer, and who had access to the computer,” he said. But the window of plausible deniability was narrow, he suggested.
“All they have to prove is you had it and you knew about it,” he said.
Judge Staley has ruled that hundreds of images investigators say they found on devices belonging to Church could be admitted as evidence.
Before any arguments, lawyers for both sides will have to find unbiased jurors, which could be difficult given Church’s status as a public figure.
“There’s that extra scrutiny on it, so you have to worry about taint of the jury pool,” said Garland, but added: “You would be surprised at how many people will say ‘never heard of him.’ Some people just don’t ever look at the news.”
Pratt said, handled correctly, Church’s involvement in civic affairs could play well with the jury, but bringing his character into play would open the door for the prosecution to do so as well.
“If he has no criminal history … absolutely you bring it out and you might even try to make it political,” he said.
Pratt said in cases like Church’s, the jury will want and expect him to take the stand, even though they are instructed not to hold it against the defendant if he does not.
“If he doesn’t deny it, the question becomes why not,” he said.
Church and his attorneys, Reid Thompson and Jimmy Berry, did not return calls for comment. The DA’s office declined to comment on specifics.
8/13/14
ETHICS COMPLAINT BROUGHT AGAINST KENNESAW MAYOR
First page in the MDJ was the report of my Mathews complaint, you can see the article at: http://mdjonline.com/view/full_story/25599487/article-Ethics-complaint-brought-against-Kennesaw-mayor?instance=home_top_bullets
================================================
8/8/14
Recent posts have been about our ethically challenged Kennesaw mayor and the bull shit he gets up to, but don't lose sight of the major problem faced by residents of the Castle Lake Mobile Home Park and how poorly they are being treated.
I see that as of today's post the park is still trying to sell some trailers and rent out lots, all this is being done despite the park being sold next month. The Ergas Group seems to want to squeeze every last dollar they can out of this park before it is sold to Fuqua.
===========================================================
Malfeasance allegation put before City Council
Saturday, July 26, 2014
Dear Council Members:
RE:
Complaint About Malfeasance by Kennesaw mayor
During June and July of 2014 the current Kennesaw mayor
mis-used City of Kennesaw resources, namely City employees and City funds, in an
attempt to vex, hinder, annoy and intimidate a Kennesaw resident, myself, who
has been a critic of the mayor for several years.
Specifically, said mayor related to the City Attorney and
Council members, various allegations regarding a blog site maintained by me,
which is in part critical of various actions of the mayor dealing with several
issues, but more recently the issue of Castle Lake Mobile Home
Park.
* "The mobile
home residents are just being lied to everyday by the seller who is more
interested in keeping his monthly cash flow . . .
* What the owner is doing is borderline unethical in my opinion . . .
* He is having his managers tell the tenants the land is not sold, which technically it is not, so he is continuing to rent to unsuspecting tenants never bothering to tell them they may have to be gone by June of this year. . .
* It's pitiful, taking something super positive and it gets undermined by the residents not even knowing they are about to be put out."
The mayor claimed to the City Attorney and Council that he had
not said these things and required the City Attorney to do research over several
days and draft a 3 page 'Cease and Desist; Retraction Demand
Letter', all based on mis-statements and lies by the mayor*.
Billing records, incomplete at this writing, show that the
City Attorney and his Marietta legal firm have claimed fees and expenses of at
least $1,055.47 for research,
drafting, phone calls and emails. Also the failed attempt to serve this letter
cost $180.00!
Per my FOIA request this letter, billing information and
emails became available and are now posted at the above referenced blog site and
they are incorporated by reference as part of my complaint.
The quotes the mayor denied making were made before a KSU Journalism class in March this year, and were published by these students as part of their class work and a video of the mayors 1 hour and 28 minute address to this class was also put online by them**.
Clearly the mayor lied to the City Attorney and Council and
cost the City of Kennesaw taxpayers a considerable amount of money on what was a
personal vendetta with the mayor using his office in an attempt to silence a
critic of his mayoral administration. The legal term for this is Malfeasance.
REQUESTED ACTIONS TO BE TAKEN BY THE COUNCIL
ARE:
1) That the City Council vote a measure of censure for the mayors actions, and
2) Require him to
pay the entire costs of his actions in this matter.
Sincerely,
Bill Harris
Citizen Journalist
Kennesaw Resident 14 years
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*
Bentley, Bentley &
Bentley
Attorneys at Law
241 Washington Avenue
Marietta, Georgia 30060
(770) 422-2300
June 20, 2014
Mr. Bill Harris
3236 Summer Stream Lane
Kennesaw, Georgia 30152
Dear Mr. Harris:
This Firm represents the City of Kennesaw, the Honorable Mark Mathews, and the City Council of Kennesaw.
DEMAND IS HEREBY FORMALLY MADE that Bill Harris, alleged owner/author of
the blog (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com)
immediately cease and desist publishing any and all statements about Mayor
Mathews and the City of Kennesaw that are purported to be quoted by the Mayor
Mark Mathews; and any that are false, defamatory, and cause significant hard to
his reputation and good name; and to the reputation and good name of the City of
Kennesaw. We are giving you formal notice that, you, Bill Harris at your blog
(www.mayormathers.blogspot.com)
have posted misleading and false statements that have caused and are causing
irreparable damage.
The blog you have created and operate appears to impersonate Mayor Mathews by using his name as the title of the blog and stating "Current Mayor of Kennesaw, Ga", yet making no claim that is conspicuous and public in manner of author/ownership by Bill Harris, and in fact you conceal the fact that you are the author/creator/publisher of the blog. Your blog is misleading and confusing to the public by leading them to possibly believe that the opinions and statements are from Mayor Mark Mathews.
Mr. Harris, at your blog (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com)
you have published the following false, malicious and libelous statements, among
others, about Mayor Mathews, and impersonating Mayor Mathews by misleading the
public to believe the Mayor wrote the blog. We were alerted by concerned
citizens of Kennesaw, that the following example appeared on the front page on
June 16, 2014 which falsely "appears" to be statements from the Mayor including
"1" statements.
Monday, June 16, 2014
What happened to the often promised 'relocation package'?
This seems to be the latest news of the Castle Lake MHP with
residents getting a 30 day notice to quit. But where is the often promised
'relocation package'.
Fuqua claims via his lawyer, Garvis Sams of Marietta, that by the
time of the August closing that there will be one, but by then it seems the
residents (or most of them) will have been removed leaving only a few for Fuqua
to have to relocate at the 'claimed' cost of $3,000 per lot.
So what we seem to have is a purposely delayed closing moved to August so the MHP can clean house and get rid of most of the affected residents before Jeff Fuqua takes over and is responsible for any relocation.
I never believed there was going to be a relocation package and I made this clear to the City Council. They should not have allowed any annexation or rezoning to go forward without a firm package, of course they paid NO attention and rushed into approving everything Fuqua and the Canadian owners* of the MHP wanted.
Now residents are being told to pack up and leave in 30 days.
Another example of false and defamatory offered as the Mayor's misquotes
are as follows:
* "The mobile home residents are just being lied to everyday by
the seller who is more interested in keeping his monthly cash flow . . .
* What the owner is doing is borderline unethical in my opinion . . .
* He is having his managers tell the tenants the land is not sold, which technically it is not, so he is continuing to rent to unsuspecting tenants never bothering to tell them they may have to be gone by June of this year. . .
* It's pitiful, taking something super positive and it gets undermined by the residents not even knowing they are about to be put out."
* What the owner is doing is borderline unethical in my opinion . . .
* He is having his managers tell the tenants the land is not sold, which technically it is not, so he is continuing to rent to unsuspecting tenants never bothering to tell them they may have to be gone by June of this year. . .
* It's pitiful, taking something super positive and it gets undermined by the residents not even knowing they are about to be put out."
The statements, representations, and false light published/authored by you, Mr. Harris at your blog: (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com) are categorically false. There is no factual basis for them. Instead the facts establish that they are NOT true.
At this point, any further republication at your blog: (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com), after receipt of this letter, is a knowing publication of untrue statements and misquotes, and as such, deliberately defamatory communications. Further republication includes failure to delete the link and/or publish a correction.
Toward this end, DEMAND is hereby made that you, Bill Harris, at your blog (www.mayormathers.blogspot.com) remove from any false and defamatory statement purporting to be made by quoting the Mayor Mathews or other City Council members: (including, but not limited to, those referenced above) and take aggressive steps to ensure that you, at (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com) do not publish any false statements of this sort in any subsequent blog posts or other forums by you as (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com). We also demand that you place in a comspicuous manner in the header of the blog; that you are the author and owner of the blog; and the blog represents your opinions. alone.
Your failure to comply with this demand by July 2, 2014 pursuant to O.C.G.A. 51-5-11; will leave us no choice but to recommend that the City of Kennesaw to pursue all legal causes of action that they might have, which includes litigation in which the City of Kennesaw, and the Mayor of the City of Kennesaw, et al. would pursue damages, attorney's fees, and costs.
Sincerely
Bentley, Bentley and Bentley
R. Randall Bentley Sr.
City Attorney
City Attorney
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
** The 4 quotes come from the
short article "Kennesaw Mayor Blasts Owner of Annexed Mobile Home
Park" written by Alicia Newton for the April 3, 2014 issue of
CapstoneQuarterly, see: http://capstonequarterly.wordpress.com/tag/whole-foods-kennesaw-development/
and you can watch the video tape of the mayors address at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=geEulOuU7Gg
===============================================================7/25/14
By outright lies to the City Attorney, the current Kennesaw mayor got the below 3 page letter drafted by the City Attorney. Reference in the letter is to 4 quotes of the mayor which were made before a KSU journalism class in March.
Our ethically challenged mayor claimed to the City Attorney and Council that he never made those quoted statements. The mayor seems to think that bombastic statements made to a journalism class are off the record and if he simply denies having said them they will go away and he can use $1,055.47 of City money in a foolish attempt to intimidate me into removing them.
The quotes come from the short article "Kennesaw Mayor blasts owner of annexed mobile home park" written by Alicia Newton for the April 3, 2014 issue of CapstoneQuarterly, see: http://capstonequarterly.wordpress.com/tag/whole-foods-kennesaw-development/ or if you have a spare hour and a half to waste you can watch the video tape of the mayors address at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=geEulOuU7Gg
Below are five Documents - 3 are the proposed 'Letter' and 2 billing items
Shown below are the actual pages followed by a larger text version, the actual documents are just a bit hard to read, thus the text is replicated FYI:
June 20, 2014
Mr. Bill Harris
3236 Summer Stream Lane
Kennesaw, Georgia 30152
Re: Cease and Desist; Retraction demand letter
Dear Mr. Harris:
This Firm represents the City of Kennesaw, the Honorable Mark Mathews, and the City Council of Kennesaw.
DEMAND IS HEREBY FORMALLY MADE that Bill Harris, alleged owner/author of the blog (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com) immediately cease and desist publishing any and all statements about Mayor Mathews and the City of Kennesaw that are purported to be quoted by the Mayor Mark Mathews; and any that are false, defamatory, and cause signifigant hard to his reputation and good name; and to the reputation and good name of the City of Kennesaw. We are giving you formal notice that, you, Bill Harris at your blog (www.mayormathers.blogspot.com) have posted misleading and false statements that have caused and are causing irreparable damage.
The blog you have created and operate appears to impersonate Mayor Mathews by using his name as the title of the blog and stating "Current Mayor of Kennesaw, Ga", yet making no claim that is conspicuous and public in manner of author/ownership by Bill Harris, and in fact you conceal the fact that you are the author/creator/publisher of the blog. Your blog is misleading and confusing to the public by leading them to possibly believe that the opinions and statements are from Mayor Mark Mathews.
Mr. Harris, at y our blog (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com) you have published the following false, malicious and libelous statements, among others, about Mayor Mathews, and impersonating Mayor Mathews by misleading the public to believe the Mayor wrote the blog. We were alerted by concerned citizens of Kennesaw, that the following example appeared on the front page on June 16, 2014 which falsely "appears" to be statements from the Mayor including "1" statements.
Monday, June 16, 2014
What happened to the often promised 'relocation package'?
This seems to be the latest news of the Castle Lake MHP with residents getting a 30 day notice to quit. But where is the often promised 'relocation package'.
Fuqua claims via his lawyer, Garvis Sams of Marietta, that by the time of the August closing that there will be one, but by then it seems the residents (or most of them) will have been removed leaving only a few for Fuqua to have to relocate at the 'claimed' cost of $3,000 per lot.
So what we seem to have is a purposely delayed closing moved to August so the MHP can clean house and get rid of most of the affected residents before Jeff Fuqua takes over and is responsible for any relocation.
I never believed there was going to be a relocation package and I made this clear to the City Council. They should not have allowed any annexation or rezoning to go forward without a firm package, of course they paid NO attention and rushed into approving everything Fuqua and the Canadian owners* of the MHP wanted.
Now residents are being told to pack up and leave in 30 days.
Another example of false and defamatory offered as the Mayor's misquotes are as follows:
* "The mobile home residents are just being lied to everyday by the seller who is more interested in keeping his monthly cash flow . . .
* What the owner is doing is borderline unethical in my opinion . . .
* He is having his managers tell the tenants the land is not sold, which technically it is not, so he is continuing to rent to unsuspecting tenants never bothering to tell them they may have to be gone by June of this year. . .
* It's pitiful, taking something super positive and it gets undermined by the residents not even knowing they are about to be put out."
The statements, representations, and false light published/authored by you, Mr. Harris at your blog: (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com) are categorically false. There is no factual basis for them. Instead the facts establish that they are NOT true.
At this point, any further republication at your blog: (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com), after receipt of this letter, is a knowing publication of untrue statements and misquotes, and as such, delibertly defamatory communications. Further republication includes failure to delete the link and/or publish a correction.
Toward this end, DEMAND is hereby made that you, Bill Harris, at your blog (www.mayormathers.blogspot.com) remove from any false and defamatory statement purporting to be made by quoting the Mayor Mathews or other City Council members: (including, but not limited to, those referenced above) and take aggressive stept to ensure that you, at (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com) do not publish any false statements of this sort in any subsequent blog posts or other forums by you as (www.mayormathews.blogspot.com). We also demand that you place in a comspicuous manner in the header of the blog; that you are the author and owner of the blog; and the blog represents your opinions. alone.
Your failure to comply with this demand by July 2, 2014 pursuant to O.C.G.A. 51-5-11; will leave us no choice but to recommend that the City of Kennesaw to pursue all legal causes of action that they might have, which includes litigation in which the City of Kennesaw, and the Mayor of the City of Kennesaw, et al. would pursue damages, attorney's fees, and costs.
Sincerely
Bentley, Bentley and Bentley
R. Randall Bentley Sr.
City Attorney
Total cost as above 2 pages is $1,055.47 and the July billing is not yet closed out.
=======================================================
7/23/14
KENNESAW CITY COUNCIL ITEMS 7/21/14
If you don't go to Council meetings you have to hope that the MDJ will turn up and report on things. That did not happen in this last Council meeting, no MDJ.
FYI: That end run by Castle Lake Owners to get the remaining 32 acres into Kennesaw and have it rezoned is finished for the next six months.
In prior Council meetings we saw attorney Garvis Sams write in a July 3rd letter that he was withdrawing the CLMHP Owners requests and in this weeks Council meeting that withdrawal was approved 5-0.
So any annexation/rezoning for the remaining acres can't be brought up again for 6 months and the process has to start all over again
Also in a rare report in the Atlanta Journal Constitution the below appeared, normally the AJC forgets that there is a Kennesaw, here is their blurb:
Annexation/rezoning in Kennesaw on hold
The Kennesaw City Council on Monday withdrew a rezoning and annexation application for a $40 million mixed-use development off Old Highway 41. Developers Amak Partners and Masal Partners can reapply after six months.
The council delayed a vote last month after residents opposed the plan to redevelop 32 acres of the 84-acre Castle Lake Mobile Home Park. The rest of the park was annexed in February for a $150 million retail and residential development.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7/22/14
This is a popular site. Here is who looked in the last 7 days (those cities with under 5 'hits' were not shown)
===========================================
On July 17th a 2 page FOIA records request was made to the City Clerk of Kennesaw. The information and documents requested are found on page 2 of this filing.
The reason for this FOIA is that Mayor Mathews appears to have misused his position to have the City Attorney and the City Attornies private legal firm investigate me and subsequently attempt to serve me with a letter or complaint regarding my having (correctly and accurately) reported a series of comments made by the Mayor before a KSU Journalism class.
The Mayor said in part and was quoted by me as having said:
“The mobile home residents are just being lied to everyday by the seller who is more interested in keeping his monthly cash flow . . .
What the owner is doing is borderline unethical in my opinion . . .
He is having his managers tell the tenants the land is not sold, which technically it is not, so he is continuing to rent to unsuspecting tenants never bothering to tell them they may have to be gone by June of this year . . .
It’s pitiful, taking something super positive and it gets undermined by the residents not even knowing they are about to be put out.”
I understand that the Mayor has claimed publically and to the City Attorney that he did NOT say this.
However these quotes come from the short article "Kennesaw Mayor blasts owner of annexed mobile home park" written by Alicia Newton for the April 3, 2014 issue of CapstoneQuarterly, see: http://capstonequarterly.wordpress.com/tag/whole-foods-kennesaw-development/ or if you have a spare hour and a half to waste you can watch the video tape of this address at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=geEulOuU7Gg
The Mayor seems to have used City personnel and spent City money on a personal vendetta with the view to harassing, intimidating, vexing and annoying a blogger who has been critical of his conduct in office. The requested documentation should provide ample information to determine if this is the case.
P. #2 of 2 pages
I request the following:
- Copies of all emails and correspondence for June and July 2014, regarding Bill Harris and the blog site, http://mayormathews.blogspot.com/.
- Costs to the City to have a 'letter or complaint' drafted on or about June 16, 2014, by the City Attorney dealing with the publication on the above referenced blog site, of various quotes of the Mayor to a KSU Journalism Class.
- Costs to the City, directly and indirectly related to the above referenced activity, this to include the costs of using the Marietta law firm of Bentley, Bentley and Bentley on at least June 16, June 17, June 19 and June 20 when said firm accessed referenced blog site 49 times from the Bentley firms computer at the behest of the Mayor and/or the City Attorney.
- All documentation including calls, emails, voicemails, letters and faxes used in the utilization of a process server and/or a City employee to attempt service of the 'letter or complaint' that the Mayor instructed City Attorney to prepare and serve on Bill Harris. At least one such attempt being made between 7:30-9:30 a.m. on July 7, 2014.
- Any documentation of usage of the Kennesaw Police Department in any form or manner in this issue.
- Any documentation regarding the Mayor's request to City or Board employees or others to set up a public lunch meeting with Bill Harris and inform the Mayor so that Bill Harris could be 'served' with the referenced 'letter or complaint.'
- A copy of the 'letter or complaint' drafted by the City Attorney at the instruction of the Mayor.
Those not following my posts on facebook can find a sample of them dealing with the Castle Lake MHP below.
You can see these and others at: https://www.facebook.com/wm.inkennesaw?fref=nf
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CASTLE LAKE - WHAT IS IT WORTH?
The County establishes a 'Fair Market Value' (FMV) for tax purposes and this fluxuates from year to year depending on the realty market. Such estimates are frequently 'low ball' estimates and probably are not reflective of what might actually be paid for a property.
If you go back to the FMV of those 83.23 acres in 2009 you will find that it was valued at $4,028,580 and taxed at $46,328.68.
Moving forward to 2013 we find the MHP having a FMV of $3,259,480 and the taxes paid were $39,061.
You can only speculate as to what the price to Fuqua Development LLC will be for that section now annexed and rezoned in Kennesaw.
Who actually owns these acres now? Owners reflected in Cobb County records show it is: Masal Partners, Ltd and Amak Partners LP, all of the address of The Ergas Group 1185 W. Georgia St #1520, Vancouver, B.C. V6E 4E6. Prior listings for ownership had included ISBE and Benadam Corporations, all the above names are Ergas companies (same circus, just different names on the tents).
Seems that Ergas Group is divesting itself of other property in the US. Just FYI and your collection of information: The 200 unit Woodstone Apartments in Ft Worth was sold by The Ergas Group in March of this year to The Tipton Group of California.
The Woodstone Apartments are located at 6051 Bridge Street in Fort Worth, Texas and was owned by the Ergas Group for nearly 20 years and had at sale 95% occupancy. The 6.24 acre property had a 2012 assessed value for taxes $4,250,000.
----------------------------------------------------------------
BOYCOTT WHOLE FOODS?
Whole Foods has announced that they will be an anchor store in the coming Kennesaw (Ga) development of Jeff Fuqua. Until now, Whole Foods has had a good reputation in the Atlanta area community, now this may be changing.
There is a major problem with the proposed new location for their Kennesaw store as both Fuqua and the current Canadian owners of the 52 acre retail development are dealing with the low income Castle Lake Mobile Home Park residents in what is in my opinion a very consumer unfriendly way.
Even the Kennesaw Mayor has been critical of their treatment of the 1,500 or so residents.
In my opinion Whole Foods should be boycotted by all consumers until they show their community involvement by making sure that Fuqua Development LLC and the Park owners The Ergas Group, STOP their intimidation and harassment of these park residents and put a meaningful and fair 'relocation plan' into effect for them.
A considerable amount of information on this topic is available for you, click on the provided link:
also see: http://theergasgroup.blogspot.com/, http://fuquadevelopment.blogspot.com/,
https://www.facebook.com/wm.inkennesaw?fref=nf
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
CLMHP HANDICAPPED DISCRIMINATION SUIT and 2003 INVOLVMENT OF KENNESAW MAYOR WITH CLMHP OWNER
Looking up some court filings regarding the Castle Lake MHP, I found an interesting Federal Civil Suit filed 12/1/2003.
The allegations of Dean Vereen and Deborah Shria, from 11 years ago involved the violations of the Fair Housing Act and Handicapped Discrimination, against the various LLC's and LLLP's, Joseph and Marcus Ergas and the Park manager Marilyn Hagy.
As expected the Plaintiff's allegations are along the lines that we have come to expect from this Park:
* Poor trailer conditions
* Fraud
* Eviction Threats
* Retaliations for complaints
* a 9/26/03 phone call from Joseph Ergas in which he threatened the Plaintiffs, demanding they drop their HUD complaints or have Mgr Hagy 'start the eviction process on 10/1/03'.
The above is an example of how this group always dealt with tenants, even back in 2003 and up to today, as reported in various Georgia media.
One other item from this 2003 filing was of interest and I will quote from page 3:
"(11) That according to information received these Defendants Mr. Joseph Ergas Group Corporation et. al. is alleged to be making efforts to sale this Castle lake (MHC) Corporation et al and has meeting with parties on this issues including Mayor of Kennesaw, Georgia, this good cause for granting the T.R.O. to prohibit any sales or transfers of properties, or bankrupting this company."
Why is this quoted section of interest?
It shows that as far back as 2003 the Canadian MHP owners were looking to sell their Park (2012 fair market value of $4,250,000) and were even then in contact with the then Mayor of Kennesaw. So the fingerprints of both Mayors Church and Mathews are all over this Park issue.
See this U.S. Federal Court filing at: http://castlelakekennesaw.blogspot.com/
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Castle Lake is only 1 Ergas property being sold
Seems that Ergas Group is divesting itself of other property in the US. Just FYI and your collection of information: The 200 unit Woodstone Apartments in Ft Worth was sold by The Ergas Group in March of this year.
The Woodstone Apartments are located at 6051 Bridge Street in Fort Worth, Texas and was owned by the Ergas Group for nearly 20 years and had at sale 95% occupancy.
The 6.24 acre property had a 2012 assessed value for taxes $4,250,000.
Details at: http://dallas.citybizlist.com/article/marcus-millichap-arranges-sale-200-unit-apartment-building
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FROM THE CITY WEBSITE:
Council Actions Summary Jul 7 Meeting
The following actions were taken at the City Council meeting on July 7: Update on rezoning and annexation cases AX2014-02, RZ2014-03 and -04 for 1810 Old Hwy 41 and 1650 Cobb Parkway.
No action taken.
Public Hearings continued to July 21 at which time action will be taken on the request to withdraw.
MY COMMENT: Public reaction to the unethical conduct of the Ergas Group, owners of the Castle Lake Mobile Home Park made their lawyer ask for the motions to annex and rezone be withdrawn.
It will be impossible for CLMHP to be taken into Kennesaw in the near future as both the Council and residents of Kennesaw have had enough of this unsavory group who are mistreating 2,500 residents at this park. It will also be extremely unlikely that any permits for construction will be issued for the land already annexed, until and unless the Park STOPS its mistreatment of residents there and also a firm and fair 'Relocation Plan' is put into place by 'Atlanta's Most Controversial Developer' Mr. Jeff Fuqua.
At this stage the whole sale might be reconsidered as the matter has been botched from the start.
My own opinion is that we don't need this type of people in Kennesaw, whether as a Mobile Home Park or a new retail development.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ARE MOBILE HOMES BANNED FROM MOVING IF OLDER THAN 10 YEARS?
A Castle Lake MHP resident provided information in the 6/16/14 Council Session that mobile homes over ten years old could not be moved.
This is not correct as of 2010. Previously various Counties had such restrictions but the Ga Legislature changed this (found at O.C.G.A. § 8-2-70-170-171) and said in part:
(b) No county or municipality shall impose any health and safety standards or conditions based upon the age of a manufactured home.
(c) A county or municipality may establish health and safety standards and conditions and an inspection program for pre-owned manufactured homes which are relocated from their current locations.
Additionally Cobb County requires various things including, "A Move Permit is required by law and must be obtained before a mobile home can be moved into the county, to another location within Cobb County (lot to lot), moved out of the county or state, dismantled, to an impound lot or land fill."
So as of 9/1/10: "The age of a manufactured home may no longer be used as a limitation on its relocation within a county."
Of course the Parks themselves may well have restrictions on the age of mobile homes which they will allow into the Park.
Reviewing the various State and County regulations made me realize that owning a mobile home can be a pain in the rear, plus moving a 20K trailer could cost over 5K. I suggest you do not BUY any mobile home, just rent if you have to but DO NOT buy one.
=============================================================
7/8/14
Castle Lake MHP Information
FROM THE CITY of KENNESAW WEBSITE:
Council Actions Summary Jul 7 Meeting
The following actions were taken at the City Council meeting on July 7:
Update on rezoning and annexation cases AX2014-02, RZ2014-03 and -04 for 1810 Old Hwy 41 and 1650 Cobb Parkway.
No action taken.
Public Hearings continued to July 21 at which time action will be taken on the request to withdraw.
Council Actions Summary Jul 7 Meeting
The following actions were taken at the City Council meeting on July 7:
Update on rezoning and annexation cases AX2014-02, RZ2014-03 and -04 for 1810 Old Hwy 41 and 1650 Cobb Parkway.
No action taken.
Public Hearings continued to July 21 at which time action will be taken on the request to withdraw.
marcergas@ergasgroup.com
aeergas@ergasgroup.com
The Ergas Group (photo R)
1185 Georgia St W Unit 1520
Vancouver, BC V6E 4E6, Canada
Fax: (604) 687-2380
Phone: (604) 687-2310
If you want to contact the people behind the fiasco at the Castle Lake Mobile Home Park you can reach the Atlanta developer at the below addresses:
jeff.fuqua@fuquadev.com
heather.correa@fuquadev.com
angelowf@bellsouth.net
jennifer.ledbetter@fuquadev.com
aeergas@ergasgroup.com
The Ergas Group (photo R)
1185 Georgia St W Unit 1520
Vancouver, BC V6E 4E6, Canada
Fax: (604) 687-2380
Phone: (604) 687-2310
If you want to contact the people behind the fiasco at the Castle Lake Mobile Home Park you can reach the Atlanta developer at the below addresses:
jeff.fuqua@fuquadev.com
heather.correa@fuquadev.com
angelowf@bellsouth.net
jennifer.ledbetter@fuquadev.com
FUQUA DEVELOPMENT HOLDINGS L.L.C.
Eleven Piedmont Center
3495 Piedmont Rd NE Ste 905
Atlanta, Ga. 30305
And don't forget to cc their proposed major tenant Whole Foods via:
John.Mackey@wholefoods.com,
Walter.Robb@wholefoods.com
Darrah.Horgan@wholefoods.com
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WHAT IS CASTLE LAKE WORTH?
Q) What do the Owners of Castle Lake actually own?
A) 1 large tract and 2 small ones
The owners are: MASAL PARTNERS LTD LP &
& AMAK PARTNERS LP
1810 OLD 41 HWY
Total Acres 1.16
ERNEST BARRETT PKY Total Acres 2.64
1650 N COBB PKY Total
Acres 83.2267
(Total acres: 87)
(Total acres: 87)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What else is The Ergas Group selling
http://thewoodstoneapts.com
Seems that Ergas Group is divesting itself of other property in the US. Just FYI and your collection of information: The 200 unit Woodstone Apartments in Ft Worth was sold by The Ergas Group in March of this year to The Tipton Group. (photo at right)
The Woodstone Apartments are located at 6051 Bridge Street in Fort Worth, Texas and was owned by the Ergas Group for nearly 20 years and had at sale 95% occupancy.
The 6.24 acre property had a 2012 assessed value for taxes $4,250,000.
Details at: http://dallas.citybizlist.com/article/marcus-millichap-arranges-sale-200-unit-apartment-building
Seems that Ergas Group is divesting itself of other property in the US. Just FYI and your collection of information: The 200 unit Woodstone Apartments in Ft Worth was sold by The Ergas Group in March of this year to The Tipton Group. (photo at right)
The Woodstone Apartments are located at 6051 Bridge Street in Fort Worth, Texas and was owned by the Ergas Group for nearly 20 years and had at sale 95% occupancy.
The 6.24 acre property had a 2012 assessed value for taxes $4,250,000.
Details at: http://dallas.citybizlist.com/article/marcus-millichap-arranges-sale-200-unit-apartment-building
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN TO THE REMAINING ACRES AT CASTLE LAKE MHP?
A submission put in by Canadian Developer Mr. Marcus Ergas (Email: marcergas@ergasgroup.com) on an application for 'Developments of Regional Impact' shows that 2 Ergas firms wish to develop the remaining 32 acres of the Castle Lake MHP, calling the proposed development: 'Old 41 Development'.
The Project is described as a "Mixed Use Development on 31.86 acres with the following components: 16,000 square feet of retail 49 townhome units @ 900 square feet per unit 648 multifamily units @ 600 square feet per unit ( min 1 bedroom)"
and "Mixed Use Development on 31.86 acres with the following components: 16,000 square feet of retail 49 townhome units @ 900 square feet per unit 648 multifamily units @ 600 square feet per unit ( min 1 bedroom)"
Estimated Project Completion Dates:
This project/phase: January 2017
Overall project: January 2019
Ergas wants this project to be annexed and rezoned as his first CLMHP property was, however, the Kennesaw City Council denied the requests based on how poorly the Park was treating the current tenants. The development could proceed without being taken into Kennesaw, just developed under Cobb County where the Park is already licensed.
The property would be developed by the Ergas firms of: Masal Partners LTD., L.P. & Amak Partners L.P.
See original paperwork at: http://masalpartners.blogspot.com/
A submission put in by Canadian Developer Mr. Marcus Ergas (Email: marcergas@ergasgroup.com) on an application for 'Developments of Regional Impact' shows that 2 Ergas firms wish to develop the remaining 32 acres of the Castle Lake MHP, calling the proposed development: 'Old 41 Development'.
The Project is described as a "Mixed Use Development on 31.86 acres with the following components: 16,000 square feet of retail 49 townhome units @ 900 square feet per unit 648 multifamily units @ 600 square feet per unit ( min 1 bedroom)"
and "Mixed Use Development on 31.86 acres with the following components: 16,000 square feet of retail 49 townhome units @ 900 square feet per unit 648 multifamily units @ 600 square feet per unit ( min 1 bedroom)"
Estimated Project Completion Dates:
This project/phase: January 2017
Overall project: January 2019
Ergas wants this project to be annexed and rezoned as his first CLMHP property was, however, the Kennesaw City Council denied the requests based on how poorly the Park was treating the current tenants. The development could proceed without being taken into Kennesaw, just developed under Cobb County where the Park is already licensed.
The property would be developed by the Ergas firms of: Masal Partners LTD., L.P. & Amak Partners L.P.
See original paperwork at: http://masalpartners.blogspot.com/
Also direct links at:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
======================================================================
6/26/14 Update:
Information today suggests that residents at CLMHP have retained a lawyer. Those contacted are reluctant to speak, probably on advise of the lawyer. I also understand that 3 day notices have been sent. The date for closing on the property seems to have been put off until September.
===========================================================
Wealthy Jewish Canadian property developer Morris Ergas (Principal at Ergas Group of Companies) attended the Vancouver Heart and Stroke Foundation’s Golden Heart gala dinner which was held at the Fairmont Hotel Vancouver last week.
I am sure that all the 1,500 soon to be evicted low income tenants and mobile home owners of his Castle Lake Mobile Home Park hope that he and Gillian Dixon-Boxer had a nice time.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
34 CLMHP PHOTOS can be found at: http://mayormathews.blogspot.com/2014/06/mathews-accused-correctly-of-being.html no copyright attaches, use them if you want. See various posts at- http://mayormathews.blogspot.com/2014/06/mathews-accused-correctly-of-being.html
Minutes of City Council Meeting 6/16/14
MINUTES OF MAYOR & CITY COUNCIL MEETING
CITY OF KENNESAW
Council Chambers
Monday, June 16, 2014
6:30 p.m.
(Extract of Minutes for pages 26 to 36)
Zoning Administrator Darryl Simmons presented agenda items IX-D, E and F
concurrently.
Mayor Mathews said he was recently made aware of a blog implying that it comes from
him. The last date was June 10th. This is not his blog, he knows who owns the blog
and will look into it further. The blog does not express his opinions or comments. The
City will do all to help the developer and any outstanding issues for residents. Laws
have to be followed and you cannot be displaced from your home automatically.
Tonight, if you agree with public comments being made on agenda items IX-D, E and F,
stand up from your chair to show support of those comments. We will make every effort
to keep this as open as we can. He thanked everyone for coming this evening.
D. Authorization for approval of an ORDINANCE granting a rezoning request
submitted by Amak Partners and Masal Partners for property located at 1810 Old
41 Highway. Property identified as 1.29+/- acre tract in Land Lot 207, Tax Parcel
05 of the 20th District, 2nd Section, Cobb County. Applicant is seeking to rezone
property from City GC (General Commercial) to City PVC (Planned Village
Community) for inclusion into a commercial development with a residential
component. Application was advertised in the May 16, 2014 edition of the
Marietta Daily Journal. Property posted May 20, 2014. Planning Commission at
a meeting held on June 04, 2014 made recommendation to approve the rezoning
of the 1.29+/- acres from City GC (General Commercial) to City PVC (Planned
Village Community) with stipulations in attached May 30, 2014 letter from Sams,
Larkin and Huff law firm. In addition two friendly amendments to the list of
stipulations to include the following: 1). Garages to be used for vehicle storage
and 2). Driveways to be 18' in length. Vote: 5-0. Yeas: Adam Ambrecht, Jeff
Powers, Cindi Michael, Fred Moore, Craig MacNaughton. Nays: None. Staff
Recommendation: Darryl Simmons, Zoning Administrator recommended
approval with incorporation of all conditions referenced in stipulation letter dated
May 30, 2014 as prepared by law firm Sams, Larkin and Huff in addition to the
two additional conditions requested by the Planning Commission: 1) Garages to
be used for vehicle storage; and 2) Driveways to be 18' in length.
Zoning Administrator Darryl Simmons presented the rezoning request submitted by
Amak Partners and Masal Partners for property located at 1810 Old 41 Highway, the
rezoning on item IX-E and the annexation on item IX-F. The entire project is 32± acres
and the intended project is composed of four main components – 16,000 feet of retail
space along Old 41, 328 multi-family units (class A apartments), 49 townhomes, and of
that 32± acres, 11.4 is identified for future development. This is a logical extension for
the City. No objections were received from Cobb County and there were recommended
conditions from Cobb Department of Transportation. The Planning Commission
recommended unanimously to rezone and annex, along with existing conditions plus
two additional conditions: 1) Garages to be used for vehicle storage; and 2) Driveways
to be 18' in length. Attached to the agenda packet is a June 9th letter from the
applicant’s attorney Garvis Sams, restating all 36 conditions.
GARVIS SAMS (Applicant’s Attorney): Mr. Sams redistributed materials attached to the
agenda packet showing images of the project area. Since Mr. Fuqua’s 53 acre
annexation, this annexation is a logical step. Mr. Fuqua’s timeframe will be to close on
the 53 acre property at the end of this summer and vertical construction will begin in the
summer of 2015 for his $150 million development. Tonight his client is the current
property owner. At the Work Session there was an indication some issues needed to
be addressed tonight. This Cobb County property is surrounded on three sides by City
boundaries. The Intergovernmental Agreement between the County and all Cobb cities
states the County can object to the annexation, and they did not, but has certain
stipulations and steps to be addressed – traffic and transportation. These Cobb
recommendation were incorporated into the 36 stipulations within his letter. The
rezoning will be for a Planned Village Community consisting of 49 townhomes, 328
multi-family units, and retail. This proposal has been reviewed at a local and regional
level and any issues were incorporated into the stipulations.
One Councilmember
expressed that perhaps 36 stipulations may be too many. Not all of these stipulations
come from the County or the City, but from his client as well.
In Fuqua’s presentation there was not a specific relocation plan, but was incorporated to
be a part of plan review. In this instance they addressed existing residents with more
specificity. They will have $2,500 assistance for relocation to the head of household
that lives in the mobile home. These funds will not go to a homeowner or absentee
landlord, but to the resident. There are approximately 160 mobile homes on this tract
which is approximately $400,000 for assistance. Also, the property owners will provide
food and lodging allowance particularly from departure from their mobile home to an
apartment or a different mobile home. They are working with sales folks regarding the
sales of existing mobile homes. They’ll make sure schools, lodging, etc. is addressed
for the existing resident to be relocated. Fuqua is presently working with two relocation
experts. If this works well he expects this client will follow the same path. Mr. Sams
emphasized the Old 41 Highway entry that will connect with the Fuqua development by
a bridge between the two properties for vehicle and pedestrian traffic. They will have a
development agreement to pay for this bridge between the two property owners. This
will give access via Barrett Parkway as well. Some existing businesses along Stanley
Road are in negotiations with his client; Croy Engineering is working on a plan and
they’re working with Ross Memorial. His client will exert continued good faith talks. It is
estimated it will cost $235,000 to provide signalization. They agreed to Public Works
requirements regarding water detention and McCullum Airport building height
restrictions of 1,065-ft. No buildings will be this tall, it will apply to cranes during
construction. Parking ratio requirements are exceeded and there will be shared parking
between businesses and residents. These are conceptual site plans only; architectural
designs will come back to the Mayor and City Council. This will be the same for the
11.4 acre site which will come back to Council in its entirety. Branch Capital completed
a demographic study, especially regarding residential needs. There is a need for more
multi-family inventory. The report also showed rents will be $1.30 per foot. There is an
average of 95% occupancy presently in the City in multi-family units; townhomes are
anticipated to replicate Fuqua townhomes. Mr. Sams said the townhomes will sell for
$300,000 and up, will have 2-car garages, 18-ft driveways, 9-ft high ceilings and granite
countertops. Whoever develops this property will not participate in Section 8 housing or
any type of subsidized residences. He described plans and qualities of these Class A
townhomes which can be changed to condos. They will be owner occupied townhomes
only and no developers will be able to buy multiples for rentals. He discussed planned
amenities and layout – 50% will be 1-bedroom units, 45% will be 2-bedroom units, 5%
will be 3-bedroom townhomes and apartments and there will be no impact to the school
system. Retail will be similar as the Fuqua project including lighting and illumination
requirements and restrictions. He reiterated verbatim disallowed uses which are the
same as the Fuqua project. There will be on-site management; they will ensure the
Home Owners Association is properly funded and insured at all times. This is a great
opportunity to complete a five year dream with a $40 million project, expand the City
horizon and expand the tax base by over $1 million per year. Due to a humanitarian
approach for relocation and the number of stipulations, he thinks this is a great benefit
to the City.
Councilmember Killingsworth asked if Fuqua agreed to provide the same relocation
assistance. Mr. Sams replied no, Mr. Fuqua’s relocation plan has to be submitted to the
City. Councilmember Killingsworth asked for clarity on Stipulation #18 about conversion
from apartments to townhomes. Mayor Mathews said apartments can convert to
condos. Councilmember Welsh feels 600-plus apartments would be entitled and feels
this is a set up for disappointment. Mr. Sams said the plans for the 11.4 acres will come
in the future – the 300-plus would be the maximum.
Ms. Welsh said she is excited to
welcome this area into the City. She doesn’t feel a fairytale developer is the best
course of action and prefers having a developer in hand. She doesn’t want 6, 9, 12
months to go by and the residents still not know who the developer will be. Mr. Sams
assured that whoever the developer is, they will be vetted by staff, Mayor and City
Council and they can be rejected or approved in the future. Ms. Welsh commented that
entitlements really don’t mean anything – why not wait until a developer is in hand? Mr.
Sams replied that entitlements are important to a developer and all the stipulations will
be in place. Councilmember Sebastian questioned stipulation #1 – are the 328
maximum Class A apartments all on the 30+ acres? Mr. Sams replied yes. Mr.
Sebastian pointed out stipulation #18 and if you do the math, it does come to more than
600 [apartments]. What about the 11.6 acres – no more apartments? Mayor Mathews
stated that stipulation #1 is in conflict with stipulation #18. What is the intent? Mr.
Sams said both – 328 apartments is pertinent for the 34 acres; the 11 acres will be
considered later. City Attorney Randall Bentley confirms this does not include the 11+
acres and the two stipulations need to be re-written. Councilmember Welsh asked if
300+ apartments can be added to the 11+ acres? Mr. Sams replied conceivably, yes.
Councilmember Williams said the property owner has received three letters of intent
[from developers], yet this is being presented by the property owner instead of a
developer. We’re being asked to vote on a conceptual site plan from the current owner.
Mr. Sams said yes and that detailed plans would be presented at a later date. Ms.
Williams asked if the three potential developers are aware of the 36 stipulations. Will
they agree to give residents the same relocation assistance? Mayor Mathews added
the stipulations are tied to the property, not the property owner. Any developer has to
come before the Mayor and City Council. Ms. Williams questioned if the stipulations
were in place before or after the letters of intent were received – do the developers all
know? Mr. Sams said two of them know. Ms. Williams stated that she is being asked to
vote on something and she needs more than a hope and a prayer. Mr. Sams said it
was cut off at three letters of intent, but many more were interested. Ms. Williams wants
to know what a developer wants to do – they may want more townhomes instead of
apartments. It seems 600+ total, of which 50% are one-bedrooms seems to say no one
get married or have children.
Mr. Sams said he doesn’t feel developers want any more
townhomes with less apartments on the 11.3 acres. Mayor Mathews pointed out that
whatever happens, it has to come back to the Mayor and City Council. Planned Village
Community (PVC) is site plan specific. This conceptual plan may or may not look
anything like this in the future, but will have to meet these requirements. Ms. Williams
went back to stipulations #1 and #18 – if in the future this came back to us and we then
deny, she does not want to be setup for a lawsuit. Mr. Sams said this is not exactly
negotiating from a position of strength. The 11.4 acre site is starting from scratch and it
could be the same developer for both tracts. Councilmember Killingsworth went back to
the 95% need for apartments in the study – how old is the study? Mr. Sams said the
report was provided two weeks ago. Attorney Bentley recommended changes for
stipulation #1 to include “Uthis condition shall not include 11.40 acres for future
development.” Councilmember Sebastian requested the same language be added to
stipulation #18. Councilmember Williams asked if the third party management will be
on-site. Mr. Sams said typically no and also confirmed the HOA is mandatory.
8:13 PM Floor Open for Public Comments
JACQUELINE LOPEZ (Castle Lake resident): We realize we are not the land owners
and our rights are minimal, but there are two roads for every action. Treat us fairly and
with respect.
Mayor Mathews said that is the intent of the City. We don’t own the land, it’s not in the
City, we can’t act on the owners or renters behalf and are trying to be fair and equitable
to everyone.
Ms. Lopez to Mr. Sams - are the 34 acres under contract? No. Ms. Lopez confirmed
the $2,500 moving assistance is for the head of household – define head of household.
Is one single person also head of household? Mr. Sams replied said there is only one
individual as head of household whether it is one person or multiple people. Ms. Lopez
asked if she moved before a “certain event” would she still be compensated the $2,500
moving assistance. What is the “certain event?” Mr. Sams said upon Mayor and
Council approval of annexation. Mayor Mathews reminded this only applies to the 34
acres only. Ms. Lopez reconfirmed with Mr. Sams that once annexed one can move
and get the moving assistance $2,500. Mr. Sams said correct, if the Council approves it
tonight. Ms. Lopez would like that in writing. Mr. Sams pointed out it is listed in the
stipulation letter and part of the public record tonight. Ms. Lopez said that at the last
meeting [Fuqua] they said homeowners have 60-days to move once they receive a
written notice – how many days for renters? Mr. Sams replied the owner is required to
give 60 days minimum notice. Mayor Mathews said if the renter has a signed
agreement that states less than 60 days, then they must abide. Ms. Lopez asked if
management can ask us to move out of our premises before? Mr. Sams said it’s on an
individual basis, depending on the lease agreement. Ms. Lopez said many residents
have received a 30-day notice to move and doesn’t even say why. Mayor Mathews said
he heard the same rumor. Unless someone can show this in writingUwe want to see
and to share this with Mr. Sams.
Ms. Lopez said she will fax this. Not all notices to
vacate are for ethical reasons; perhaps some tenants received warnings before, but it
could have been for as simple as a barking dog or an unpaid parking ticket. A neighbor
let a visitor park on his property while visiting someone else, but management didn’t
agree and wrote a ticket. Mayor Mathews said Mr. Sams represents the owner and
may have more knowledge as it has nothing to do with the City. Mr. Sams asked her to
please fax and provide him more information. Ms. Lopez said it is important for
residents to know they have rights. If we do receive one of these letters, should we find
out why and go see a lawyer? Mayor Mathews replied that is safe advice. Ms. Lopez
thanked the smart ladies [referencing Councilmembers Welsh and Williams]. To
approve the annexation without knowing the developer who may have to start over
doesn’t make sense.
CAROL McLAUGHTON (new Kennesaw resident): She bought her trailer in March
2014 and no one told her it was obvious the property was going to be sold. She got a
letter saying there is no developer. She is 69 years old. She did some research and
found out you cannot move a mobile home if it is older than 10 years – most of them
are. She was told she has to move the trailer or get penalized. They offered to move to
the other section. She has no place to go, no money and doesn’t know what to do.
They are being kept in the dark. What’s going to happen – just throw me out with a 60
day notice? There are college kids looking for low end housing. She lives in a 53 acre
development. She understands it will happened. She’s been advised to consult with an
attorney because they should not have sold her the trailer in March. She feels she is
not the only one this has happened to.
Mayor Mathews said it was good advice to get an attorney. Anyone else in a similar
situation should get together to see an attorney. Ms. McLaughton said that when she
initially looked at Castle Lake with her brother, he asked do you know what this property
is worth. She didn’t care, this is a perfect location for her. They’re being told the
residents will be talked to individually, but she does not like letting strangers into her
home, especially because she lives alone. Mayor Mathews advised that if she is
approached by someone offering to help, contact City Hall; we will do our best to verify.
The developer will get a relocation company to administer the process and that will not
start until after they own the property. They are not going to come to her home on the
day of closing and say you have 60 days to move. Ms. McLaughton asked if she would
be notified by mail to anticipate a visitor to discuss relocation. Mayor Mathews said yes,
that is possible. City staff or the developer can perhaps send a letter out first notifying
residents to anticipate visitors.
DALE HUGHES (Kennesaw resident): He’s been a resident of Kennesaw for 26 years.
He’s getting to know these residents and the first speaker, Ms. Lopez, was the
translator. Mr. Sams gave a good presentation and first brought out the relocation
package. A few stories of people recently being sold trailers are true. It will cost $8,000
or more to move a trailer and its money the residents do not have. Mr. Hughes
implored the Council to hold back on entitlements. The property owner has proved he
will sell trailers even though he knows these changes are in the works. Mr. Sams is
selling the owner a good package with these entitlements. If the report/study he
referenced is accurate
CINDY BICKFORD (Castle Lake Resident): She moved in a trailer to Castle Lake on
May 5th for $15,000. She didn’t know any of this. It’s the best place she’s lived. $2,500
will not keep them in Cobb County and apartments are as much as mortgage payments.
We are your service people working in stores, restaurants, hotels. She’s raising two
kids and will not move to the projects. This is a safe area. Where do you want us to
go? She pays $500 a month for lot rent, which leaves money for food. She was told
she makes too much money to qualify for food stamps or Section 8 housing – and she
only makes $10.30 per hour. What we say is from our heart. What would you do if you
came home and had 60 days to move? Castle Lake outright lied to everybody. $2,500
will not be enough money. Moving trailers to the end [of the property] will be in a flood
zone and they can’t get flood insurance. We can’t make more money. She has a
school loan of $12,000 that is due. She had to take a retail job, but that’s okay. She
doesn’t understand what you want us to do. Let your conscious be your guide.
Christians don’t put Christians on the road with $2,500 in the pockets and children to
feed and no place to live.
Mayor Mathews asked Attorney Sams when he had an agreement with the property
owner to represent on this issue. Mr. Sams was contracted April 2014. The Mayor
asked doesn’t the property owner or management has to sign off on everything. Mr.
Sams said he is not cognizant of that occurring.
MARIA EREZ (Castle Lake resident): She does not want $2,500 and this other lady just
purchased that home. It isn’t fair. They use all their money from their life for just
$2,500. Her mobile home is very old and $2,500 is not enough to even rent an
apartment. Make sure to check the bad administration at the mobile park. That money
is not enough for anything.
MARY HEWELL (Castle Lake resident): She has lived at Castle Lake for 44 years. Her
main concern is the $2,500 to move. She bought the trailer brand new, has done a lot
of work to the home over the years, and it will cost $6,000 and up to move the trailer.
This is not a good choice or option to relocate. Her husband passed in 2012. To sell
her trailer she would ask more than $2,500. She does not have $6,000 or more to
move and tries to make her money stretch as it is. She knows they have to move. She
called the manager asking to call a meeting to notify the residents about a possible sale.
Management said the owner is not selling – she told her that last month. If there is no
money to move her home and she has to be out in 60 days, what is she supposed to
do?
Attorney Sams said he represents the owner specifically on the applications [rezoning
and annexation]. It may be prudent to continue or table these items so he can consult
with his client regarding these issues. He does not have answers to these questions.
Mayor Mathews said his opinion is to continue these agenda items instead of tabling so
the public hearing can continue to another meeting. Tonight was advertised for a public
hearing. Future speakers will have the opportunity in a public hearing if the item is
continued. The applicant is requesting the delay. Mr. Sams is a reputable attorney and
works hard to do what is right. By asking for a continuance indicates he is not aware of
these residential issues.
MARIA GARCIA (Castle Lake resident): She was told to leave in 30 days and she has
no time to raise $5,000 to move. She does not have money for a hotel. They say she
can’t be there even now. $2,500 won’t be enough money for anything. Stop the office
people from their harassment – they don’t even give back deposits.
GRAMMIE BILLINGSLY (Castle Lake resident): She had a small stroke and left
Kennestone to be here tonight. She has lived at Castle Lake for 37 years and everyone
calls her Grammie. She cannot speak with management whose name is Marilyn. She
was taught to respect elders and she gets no respect from Marilyn – Marilyn only
respects money. These people are not telling you lies tonight. Marilyn keeps saying
they are not going to sell. Ms. Billingsly has her faith to help carry her home.
MARY YOUNG (Castle Lake resident): She too has been told by management that
nothing is going on and yet another neighbor was given 30 days to leave. Ms. Young’s
daughter has this mobile home for 12 years. Ms. Aggie said the letter was a mistake –
all the way up to a month ago. She does not want Section 8 housing. This is a 1986
trailer; her daughter is disabled and will need special attention and help. Please stop
telling us stories.
FABIAN (Castle Lake resident): She and her family live comfortable in their mobile
home and she has a special needs child. The Castle Lake personnel keep saying
nothing is going on, on numerous occasions, each and every time they are asked. This
$2,500 won’t be enough for anything, especially on low income. A mobile home is very
expensive to buy or move. Please consider each individual family. Come now to visit –
our homes are open to see how we live now.
Mayor Mathews said to Mr. Sams there is a lot of work to be done. The Mayor asked
the audience to understand the property has not been sold and no offer has been made
yet. Each person, each situation is different and $2,500 is not adequate. He thanked
the audience for speaking or coming tonight and sharing their stories. Unless the
property is annexed into the City, we can’t do anything. If annexed, then we have some
control over the development. We’ll close the meeting tonight, do some research, open
the public comment the next time and hope to see and hear progress. (An unnamed
woman in the audience complained about the issues with management.)
DALE HUGHES: He learned on Saturday there is a lack of effective communication.
Brad and the church folks are trying to set up an email communications chain. Wanda
Steele and Steve Kennedy have been very helpful. Please get in touch with Brad so
folks know when to show up.
MANUAL SEDONE (Castle Lake resident): Riverstone Church said $2,500 for people
in the 34 acre zone; no money for the 53 acre zone. Mayor Mathews reminded
everyone that residents in the 53 acres will have conversations after the developer, Mr.
Fuqua purchases the property and they will have a relocation company take care of
those residents.
ANTONIO ALVAREZ (Castle Lake resident): One year ago he tried to purchase a
mobile home for $21,000 and gave $10,000 down and was not told of any sale due to
development. A neighbor sent a letter saying the land was being sold. He’s so scared
he went to the office and spoke to the manager. She got mad and said the land is not
being sold. We don’t know the truth. In the 34 acre site, just three months ago they
were selling a trailer, but told those purchasers they could not move the trailer. Please
tell the manager to stop or put a sign at the entrance/exit of Castle Lake saying no
purchases [of mobile homes].
MARIA [no last name provided]: She showed a document about the 53 acre sale.
She’s afraid to go home, she’s lived 35 years at Castle Lake and no longer has a home.
Where’s she going to go? She is very scared. Please stop management. They even
sell a bad trailer for $18,000. There are a lot of families here. It says in the coming
month they will have to leave. The meeting interpreter read the document which was
calling for a community meeting to explain annexation; that meeting already occurred.
ANTONIO SABENSES (Castle Lake resident): Why pay rent to people who don’t own
the land any more? Mayor Mathews stated they still do own the land. Attorney Bentley
added that even if the landowner changes, you still have to pay rent. Mayor Mathews
restated the 53 acres is under contract to sell. The 34 acres being discussed tonight
are not under contract, but are asking to be annexed into the City for development.
Until the property is annexed, sold, and the developer gets approval – there will be no
construction.
Councilmember Killingsworth referenced a bracelet he wears with a verse from James
1:19 which is quick to listen, slow to speak, slow to anger. He is very angry. He
requested an Executive Session but all discussions have to be public, so it was not
granted. Mayor Mathews noted Mr. Sams has asked for continuance because of the
issues brought up tonight. Mr. Killingsworth said to Mr. Sams he hopes and prays that if
something illegal is occurring, they are held to the fullest extent of the law.
9:36 PM Floor Closed to Public Comments
Motion by Councilmember Killingsworth to continue agenda items IX-D, E and F to a
future date yet to be determined, motion seconded by Councilmember Church.
Councilmember Welsh asked if the date can be firmed this evening, and Mr. Sams said
that is impossible. Mayor Mathews requested an update be provided at the next
regularly scheduled meeting on July 7, 2014 at which time he can present a firm date
for the continued public hearings and the property owner will send a letter to all
residents of the 34 acres with proof of service given to City staff. Councilmember
Williams respectfully requests the property owner attend the final meeting. Mr. Sams
said he would like him there as well. Vote taken, approved unanimously, 5-0 on items
IX-D, E, and F. Motion carried.
Zoning Administrator Darryl Simmons presented agenda items IX-D, E and F
concurrently.
E. Authorization for approval of an ORDINANCE granting a rezoning request
submitted by Amak Partners and Masal Partners for property located at 1650
Cobb Parkway. Property identified as 30.86+/- acre tract in Land Lots 207, 212
of the 20th District, 2nd Section, Cobb County. Applicant is seeking to annex
and rezoning property from County MHP to City PVC (Planned Village
Page 34 of 119
Community) for purpose of commercial development with a residential
component. Application was advertised in the May 16, 2014 edition of the
Marietta Daily Journal. Property posted May 20, 2014. Planning Commission at
a meeting held on June 04, 2014 made recommendation to approve the rezoning
of the 30.86+/- acres from County MHP to City PVC (Planned Village
Community) with stipulations in May 30, 2014 letter from Sams, Larkin and Huff
law firm. In addition two friendly amendments to the list of stipulations to include
the following: 1). Garages to be used for vehicle storage and 2). Driveways to be
18' in length. Vote: 5-0. Yeas: Cindi Michael, Adam Ambrecht, Jeff Powers, Fred
Moore, Craig MacNaughton. Nays: None. Staff Recommendation: Darryl
Simmons, Zoning Administrator recommended approval with incorporation of all
conditions reference in stipulation letter dated May 30, 2014, and prepared by
law firm Sams, Larkin and Huff in addition to conditions added by the Planning
Commission: 1). Garages to be used for vehicle storage and 2). Driveways to be
18' in length.
Zoning Administrator Darryl Simmons presented the rezoning request submitted by
Amak Partners and Masal Partners for property located at 1650 Cobb Parkway. See all
comments under Agenda Item IX-D.
9:37 PM Floor Open for Public Comments
No additional comments – see item IX-D.
9:38 PM Floor Closed to Public Comments
Motion by Councilmember Killingsworth to continue agenda items IX-D, E and F to a
future date yet to be determined, motion seconded by Councilmember Church.
Councilmember Welsh asked if the date can be firmed this evening, and Mr. Sams said
that is impossible. Mayor Mathews requested an update be provided at the next
regularly scheduled meeting on July 7, 2014 at which time he can present a firm date
for the continued public hearings and the property owner will send a letter to all
residents of the 34 acres with proof of service given to City staff.
Councilmember Williams respectfully requests the property owner attend the final meeting. Mr. Sams said he would like him there as well. Vote taken, approved unanimously, 5-0 on items
IX-D, E, and F. Motion carried.
Zoning Administrator Darryl Simmons presented agenda items IX-D, E and F
concurrently.
F. Authorization for approval of an ORDINANCE granting an annexation request
submitted by Amak Partners and Masal Partners for property located at 1650
Cobb Parkway. Property identified as 30.86+/- acre tract in Land Lots 207, 212
of the 20th District, 2nd Section, Cobb County. Applicant is seeking to annex
and rezone property from County MHP to City PVC (Planned Village Community)
for purposed of commercial development with a residential component.
Application was advertised in the May 16, 2014 edition of the Marietta Daily
Journal. Property posted May 20, 2014. Planning Commission at a meeting held
on June 04, 2014 made recommendation to approve the annexation of the
Page 35 of 119
30.86+/- acres into the City of Kennesaw with stipulations in May 30, 2014 letter
from Sams, Larkin and Huff law firm. In addition two friendly amendments to be
added to the list of stipulations include the following:
1). Garages to be used for
vehicle storage and
2). Driveways to be 18' in length.
Vote: 5-0. Yeas: Adam
Ambrecht, Jeff Powers, Cindi Michael, Fred Moore, Craig MacNaughton. Nays:
None. Staff Recommendation: Darryl Simmons, Zoning Administrator
recommended approval with incorporation of all conditions reference in
stipulation letter dated May 30, 2014, and prepared by law firm Sams, Larkin and
Huff in addition to two conditions requested by the Planning Commission: 1)
Garages to be used for vehicle storage; and 2) Driveways to be 18' in length.
Zoning Administrator Darryl Simmons presented the annexation request submitted by
Amak Partners and Masal Partners for property located at 1650 Cobb Parkway. See all
comments under Agenda Item IX-D.
9:38 PM Floor Open for Public Comments
No further comments – see item IX-D.
9:39 PM Floor Closed to Public Comments
Motion by Councilmember Killingsworth to continue agenda items IX-D, E and F to a
future date yet to be determined, motion seconded by Councilmember Church.
Councilmember Welsh asked if the date can be firmed this evening, and Mr. Sams said
that is impossible. Mayor Mathews requested an update be provided at the next
regularly scheduled meeting on July 7, 2014 at which time he can present a firm date
for the continued public hearings and the property owner will send a letter to all
residents of the 34 acres with proof of service given to City staff. Councilmember
Williams respectfully requests the property owner attend the final meeting. Mr. Sams
said he would like him there as well.
Vote taken, approved unanimously, 5-0 on items
IX-D, E, and F. Motion carried.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IS IT TIME FOR A BOYCOTT OF WHOLE FOODS?
(New Store to displace low income renters)
In March I wrote to them to bring to their attention the problems with their proposed site on a Jeff Fuqua property and to point out that the 1,500 tenants there were going to be evicted to make room for the development, which included their new Whole Foods store. Here is what I got back from them:
From: Darrah.Horgan@wholefoods.com
"Hello Mr. Harris,
Thanks for reaching out to Whole Foods Market about this development and its affect on the neighbors of Castle Lake. We are confident in our partners at Fuqua, and they will be working with the residents to provide assistance and a fair relocation package. At this time, please contact Jeff Fuqua jeff.fuqua@fuquadev.com directly."
I have written again today and included all the new information on this project and a link to my blog site with even more information (see: http://mayormathews.blogspot.com/).
If Whole Foods is not part of the solution, then it is part of the problem and people should boycott this chain until they see that Fuqua (developer) and Ergas (owner of property) absolutely guarantee that a fair and equitable 'relocation package' is made available to tenants and mobile home owners on that Castle Lake Property.
Get ready, if they ignore this then there will be a boycott of Whole Foods!
Bill, Kennesaw
from craigslist post http://atlanta.craigslist.org/wat/vnn/4525758729.html
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DELAYED: Kennesaw annexation, rezoning pushed back after resident outcry
Comment: Bill H, Kennesaw
But just in case this isn't clear to them or the reader, here it is in simple words that all can understand: In my opinion the reason this deal was put off until August is so that the MHP owner can clear the decks of as many residents as they can intimidate into leaving before Fuqua has to actually provide any relocation funds.
Here is the contact info for the Castle Lake MHP slum lords, drop them a line and let them know what you think of them.
June 17, 2014
KENNESAW — A potential new development in Kennesaw has been delayed after its city council voted 5-0 Monday night to delay an annexation and rezoning vote on propery at the northwest corner of Cobb and Barrett Parkways.
The proposed $40 million development would include 328 new apartments and 49 townhomes on 32 acres, according to Garvis Sams, an attorney with Marietta-based Sams, Larkin, Huff and Balli, LP. Sams represents Amak Partners, L.P. and Masal Partners Ltd. L.P. of Vancouver, Canada, who are selling the property. Sams said there is a large amount of interest in the development, although no company has come forward to actually buy the land.
During public comment, nearly a dozen residents of Castle Lake Mobile Home Park — who would be dispersed to make way for the new construction — told the council the property owners had deceived them and the proposed $2,500 relocation money wouldn’t be enough to haul their trailers to another area.
Residents shared horror stories about the landowners. Several said they’d received notices saying they had 30 days to leave their homes. Cindy Blackford, who works at Northern Tool and Equipment in Marietta, said she bought a $15,000 trailer in Castle Lake on May 5, and management did not mention anything about moving or a new development.
“Castle Lake outright lied to everyone here,” she said. “Our neighbors flooded us with information. Castle Lake hid it.”
Several speakers said it would cost between $6,000 and $8,000 to move their trailers to another park. Some asked if they’d be evicted after the required 60 days’ notice if they couldn’t afford to move.
Juanita Billingsley, a housewife who has lived in Castle Lake 37 years, said she’d had a mild stroke that morning but checked out of WellStar Kennestone hospital to make sure she could be heard at the meeting.
Dozens of families live in the property’s 320 mobile homes, many of whom are Spanish-speaking Latino residents. An interpreter was present at the meeting, which drew more than 100 people from the community. Attendees were asked to stand up if they agreed with the person speaking, and almost everyone in the room stood up at several points.
After being asked several questions about the treatment of tenants by Castle Lake, Sams responded that he’s only representing the company regarding the new development and has no knowledge of the management situation.
One site, two developments
Sams said there is no construction timeline for the potential development because no one has purchased the property, but added that more than 13 builders are interested and said plans call for the owners to sell the property “as soon as they can.” Kennesaw’s Planning Commission voted 5-0 to rezone the property on June 9.
The annexation of the additional 32 acres would have meant the entire Castle Lake Mobile Home Park would fall inside Kennesaw’s city limits.
The proposed development sits adjacent to a 53-acre property annexed into the city by a unanimous vote in February, which will be developed by Atlanta-based Fuqua Development. That property will become a 450,000-square-foot shopping center — valued at $150 million and anchored by Whole Foods Market — Sams said will open no later than fall 2016. Sams said Fuqua will close on the property this fall, with major construction commencing in summer 2015.
However, Sams said Fuqua will work with Castle Lake tenants on an individual basis on that side of the property, rather than paying a flat rate.
During his presentation to the council, Sams said the new townhomes will sell for at least $300,000, while the apartments could be owner-occupied condominiums in the future, with nine-foot-high ceilings and granite countertops. Sams said previously they are mostly one or two-bedroom apartments meant to attract young professionals without school-aged children.
Sams said the two projects combined will generate more than $1 million in annual tax revenue for Kennesaw, compared to the current mobile home park which contributes “negligible” tax dollars.
Kennesaw Mayor Mark Mathews said the property owner requested the annexation.
Council hits the brakes
Following the lengthy public comment, city council members were less than pleased, including Post 2’s Tim Killingsworth.
“Mr. Sams, I hope and I pray that if something illegal is happening, somebody is held accountable to the fullest extent of the law,” he said.
Post 4 representative Debra Williams specifically asked that the property owner and property manager be present when the issue comes before the council again. The annexation was tabled indefinitely, but the council asked for an update on the situation from the company at their next meeting July 7. When the council hears the proposal again, more public comment will be taken.
The proposed $40 million development would include 328 new apartments and 49 townhomes on 32 acres, according to Garvis Sams, an attorney with Marietta-based Sams, Larkin, Huff and Balli, LP. Sams represents Amak Partners, L.P. and Masal Partners Ltd. L.P. of Vancouver, Canada, who are selling the property. Sams said there is a large amount of interest in the development, although no company has come forward to actually buy the land.
During public comment, nearly a dozen residents of Castle Lake Mobile Home Park — who would be dispersed to make way for the new construction — told the council the property owners had deceived them and the proposed $2,500 relocation money wouldn’t be enough to haul their trailers to another area.
Residents shared horror stories about the landowners. Several said they’d received notices saying they had 30 days to leave their homes. Cindy Blackford, who works at Northern Tool and Equipment in Marietta, said she bought a $15,000 trailer in Castle Lake on May 5, and management did not mention anything about moving or a new development.
“Castle Lake outright lied to everyone here,” she said. “Our neighbors flooded us with information. Castle Lake hid it.”
Several speakers said it would cost between $6,000 and $8,000 to move their trailers to another park. Some asked if they’d be evicted after the required 60 days’ notice if they couldn’t afford to move.
Juanita Billingsley, a housewife who has lived in Castle Lake 37 years, said she’d had a mild stroke that morning but checked out of WellStar Kennestone hospital to make sure she could be heard at the meeting.
Dozens of families live in the property’s 320 mobile homes, many of whom are Spanish-speaking Latino residents. An interpreter was present at the meeting, which drew more than 100 people from the community. Attendees were asked to stand up if they agreed with the person speaking, and almost everyone in the room stood up at several points.
After being asked several questions about the treatment of tenants by Castle Lake, Sams responded that he’s only representing the company regarding the new development and has no knowledge of the management situation.
One site, two developments
Sams said there is no construction timeline for the potential development because no one has purchased the property, but added that more than 13 builders are interested and said plans call for the owners to sell the property “as soon as they can.” Kennesaw’s Planning Commission voted 5-0 to rezone the property on June 9.
The annexation of the additional 32 acres would have meant the entire Castle Lake Mobile Home Park would fall inside Kennesaw’s city limits.
The proposed development sits adjacent to a 53-acre property annexed into the city by a unanimous vote in February, which will be developed by Atlanta-based Fuqua Development. That property will become a 450,000-square-foot shopping center — valued at $150 million and anchored by Whole Foods Market — Sams said will open no later than fall 2016. Sams said Fuqua will close on the property this fall, with major construction commencing in summer 2015.
However, Sams said Fuqua will work with Castle Lake tenants on an individual basis on that side of the property, rather than paying a flat rate.
During his presentation to the council, Sams said the new townhomes will sell for at least $300,000, while the apartments could be owner-occupied condominiums in the future, with nine-foot-high ceilings and granite countertops. Sams said previously they are mostly one or two-bedroom apartments meant to attract young professionals without school-aged children.
Sams said the two projects combined will generate more than $1 million in annual tax revenue for Kennesaw, compared to the current mobile home park which contributes “negligible” tax dollars.
Kennesaw Mayor Mark Mathews said the property owner requested the annexation.
Council hits the brakes
Following the lengthy public comment, city council members were less than pleased, including Post 2’s Tim Killingsworth.
“Mr. Sams, I hope and I pray that if something illegal is happening, somebody is held accountable to the fullest extent of the law,” he said.
Post 4 representative Debra Williams specifically asked that the property owner and property manager be present when the issue comes before the council again. The annexation was tabled indefinitely, but the council asked for an update on the situation from the company at their next meeting July 7. When the council hears the proposal again, more public comment will be taken.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Comment: Bill H, Kennesaw
I have been blogging about this issue since Feb. at http://mayormathews.blogspot.com/ and I early on told the Council that this was going to be a disaster and the Council should NOT approve any annexation or rezoning until and unless a FIRM relocation plan was put on the table.
What happened? The council voted 5-0 to roll over for Fuqua and the wealthy Ergas family in Vancouver. Both got what they wanted with empty assurances that things would be alright at some future time.
Now I see the council has finally gotten their rear ends in gear and applied some common sense to this matter.
But just in case this isn't clear to them or the reader, here it is in simple words that all can understand: In my opinion the reason this deal was put off until August is so that the MHP owner can clear the decks of as many residents as they can intimidate into leaving before Fuqua has to actually provide any relocation funds.
Here is the contact info for the Castle Lake MHP slum lords, drop them a line and let them know what you think of them.
The Ergas Group, (Morris Ergas, Joseph Ergas, Marcos Ergas) Tel: 604-687-2310, 1185 Georgia St W, #1520, Vancouver, BC V6E 4E6, Canada, Joseph Ergas, Home (604) 926-6536, 2250 Bellevue Ave West Vancouver, BC V7V 1C6, Marcos Ergas, (604) 925-4350, 1340 Jefferson Ave, West Vancouver BC V7T2B2
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What Happened to the Often Promised 'Relocation Package?'
=============================================================
4/4/14
The initial 'mid-June' closing on the property has now been moved back by several months and may change again before finalized.
---------------------------------------------------------------
An April 3rd article in Capstone Quarterly by Alicia Newton titled: "Kennesaw Mayor blasts owner of annexed Mobile Home Park", she reports on a lecture given by Kennesaw Mayor Mathews to KSU journalism students. He said in part:
The entire article is found at: http://capstonequarterly.wordpress.com/tag/whole-foods-kennesaw-development/
This is an extract from a longer article
KENNESAW— The Castle Lake Mobile Home Park has been annexed into the City of Kennesaw and residents will have to move before the year is over, yet manager Yolanda was renting lots as late as April our field reporter Alicia Newton found out.
The city of Kennesaw annexed 53 acres of county property at the Cobb Parkway and Barrett Parkway intersection, which is currently the home of Castle Lake Mobile Home Park.
Darryl Simmons, the planning and zoning administrator for Kennesaw, said that Fuqua Development has the property under contract and the Kennesaw city council voted to rezone the property from a residential mobile home park to a city planned village community. Whole Foods will anchor the Fuqua development.
While potentially adding economic impact through jobs and taxes, this new commercial development is not without controversy. Mathews said he believes what the Castle Lake landowner is doing is borderline unethical. Even though the Mathews said residents may have to be gone this year, management was still renting lots in April on a month-to-month basis, without informing tenants of the development plans, reporter Alicia Newton said.
A lot to place a single-wide trailer cost $455 per month and $465 for a double-wide, manager Yolanda said in a taped interview secretly conducted by Newton. Yolanda makes no mention to potential renters about the impending sale, Newton said.
“The lots are being rented month to month; it’s up to you if you wanted to move next month. If you have some money it’s your choice,” Yolanda said.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read the below article at: http://www.cbsatlanta.com/story/24965294/development-moves-in-forces-out-families If you want to drop Mr. Fuqua a line you can reach him at: jeff.fuqua@fuquadev.com
Development moves in, forces out families
Updated: Apr 02, 2014 11:10 PM EDT
Jennifer Mayerle - ATLANTA (CBS46) -
Atlanta and the surrounding area is growing by leaps and bounds. Time and time again undeveloped or under-developed property becomes mixed use space or retail. That's what's happening in Kennesaw at the intersection of Cobb and Barrett Parkways. But it doesn't come without controversy.
Castle Lake is the only neighborhood Jennifer Arreguin knows. "I like that we know this whole community," Arreguin said. It's full of mobile homes, some owned, others rented, mainly by families.
"We're all immigrants in my household and this is the place we felt most at home because of the heavy immigrant population here," Arturo Zertuche said.
Moneita Lewis bought her retirement home a year ago. "It belongs to me and I was planning on being here for the rest of my life," Lewis said.
Now, they realize their dreams will soon be dashed. "They're gonna tear down all this place," Arreguin said.
That's because most of Castle Lake has recently been annexed into the city of Kennesaw and rezoned. The land owner and developer are working on a deal to build a mixed use space comprised of retail, restaurants, and grocery stores. According to Kennesaw Mayor Mark Matthews the development will have a positive impact.
"It's jobs, its tax base, it's sales tax being generated in not just the city, the county, the schools, the state, it's an impact for everybody," Matthews said.
Just how much impact? The entire 84 acres at stake is currently valued at $1.3 million. Only 53 acres will be developed, but the assessed value is expected to skyrocket to $60 million.
Right now, only about $39,000 is paid in taxes per year to the county and school district. That should jump to $1.8 million. And because the property is now in Kennesaw, once complete, the city gets another $575,000. And that doesn't even consider job growth.
"To make it worthwhile it has to be sold and utilized to the highest and best use to justify the sale price. The value is a lot more than just what it's going to end up generating in property tax value," Matthews said.
And while the numbers stack up in favor of the development, these families feel it comes at their expense.
"It's obvious this is prime property. I know it would bring huge revenue into the city of Kennesaw and I know it's all about the dollar, all about the money, and it's not about people," Lewis said.
Many at Castle Lake live within walking distance of work. But most choose this neighborhood because it's affordable. "It's a lot cheaper to live here especially with the amount of space you get to live in compared to what you have to pay at apartment complexes," Zertuche said.
And now they are forced to find a new place to live. "I might have to move to Mexico, because they're going to tear down this place, and in Mexico I have this house where I can live," Arreguin said.
Jeff Fuqua of Fuqua Development said he would like to do an interview, but can't because of a confidentiality agreement. The company will help the families with relocation. Here is the statement by Fuqua:
"Here at Fuqua Development we take pride in our constant efforts to be aware of community issues and concerns in all projects in which we are involved.
Our Castle Lake project is no exception. From the beginning, we have been sensitive to the possible impact of this project on some of the current residents (143 trailers) in this mobile home park.
At this point, however, months away from closing on the 52 acres we are acquiring, it is impossible to establish a clear timeline and a detailed program to address resident relocation issues.
Nevertheless, we are already beginning to develop such a program, which we may be able to share with the affected residents probably in late spring. Those residents will be able to ask questions and comment on all elements of the program before its implementation.
While we are unable to provide relocation details for Castle Lake at this time, the tenant relocation plan that I managed during the development of Town Brookhaven is testament to Fuqua Development's commitment to put in place sensitive and beneficial relocation assistance programs when those are called for.
Town Brookhaven was developed on a 530-unit apartment complex, which required tenant relocation assistance for a large percentage of residents. Many community meetings were held to keep tenants abreast of the project and to discuss various assistance possibilities. Because a large percentage of the residents were Hispanic, all the meetings were conducted in Spanish and English, and all informational materials were in both languages as well.
Eventually, the Town Brookhaven relocation program included benefits such as assistance finding suitable apartments for relocation, security deposit assistance, moving and utility transfer assistance and cash bonuses related to individual moving dates.
Regarding the Castle Lake development, we want to reassure everyone concerned that Fuqua Development remains as committed today as it has been in the past to a substantive relocation assistance program for those affected and, further, that we will implement that plan on a timely basis, so that there will be no last-minute pressure to move."
Mayor Matthews said he, as well as, teachers and school administrators are concerned about the kids and families, and plan to help with the transition.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
A long article about Fuqua is available at: http://clatl.com/atlanta/jeff-fuqua-atlantas-most-controversial-developer/Content?oid=9217716 he is called Atlanta's most controversial developer.
This seems to be the latest news of the Castle Lake MHP with residents getting a 30 day notice to quit. But where is the often promised 'relocation package'.
Fuqua claims via his lawyer, Garvis Sams of Marietta, that by the time of the August closing that there will be one, but by then it seems the residents (or most of them) will have been removed leaving only a few for Fuqua to have to relocate at the 'claimed' cost of $3,000 per lot.
So what we seem to have is a purposely delayed closing moved to August so the MHP can clean house and get rid of most of the affected residents before Jeff Fuqua takes over and is responsible for any relocation.
Fuqua claims via his lawyer, Garvis Sams of Marietta, that by the time of the August closing that there will be one, but by then it seems the residents (or most of them) will have been removed leaving only a few for Fuqua to have to relocate at the 'claimed' cost of $3,000 per lot.
So what we seem to have is a purposely delayed closing moved to August so the MHP can clean house and get rid of most of the affected residents before Jeff Fuqua takes over and is responsible for any relocation.
I never believed there was going to be a relocation package and I made this clear to the City Council. They should not have allowed any annexation or rezoning to go forward without a firm package, they paid NO attention and rushed info approving everything Fuqua and the Canadian owners* of the MHP wanted.
Now residents are being told to pack up and leave in 30 days.
*
1) Joseph and Marcos Ergas of Vancouver, BC, Canada. CLMHP opened in 1961 and has approx 377 lots and 1,500 residents (numbers vary on lots and residents)
2) In March 2014 the Ergas Group sold the 200 unit Woodstone Apartments, 6051 Bridge Street in Fort Worth, Texas. It was built in 1984 and Ergas had owned the property for 19 years.
Now residents are being told to pack up and leave in 30 days.
*
1) Joseph and Marcos Ergas of Vancouver, BC, Canada. CLMHP opened in 1961 and has approx 377 lots and 1,500 residents (numbers vary on lots and residents)
2) In March 2014 the Ergas Group sold the 200 unit Woodstone Apartments, 6051 Bridge Street in Fort Worth, Texas. It was built in 1984 and Ergas had owned the property for 19 years.
Below item is from the much longer article of May 22, 2014
Sprawled Out in Atlanta – Rebecca Burns – POLITICO Magazine
Just four miles up Cobb Parkway from MUST, the entrance to Castle Lake Mobile Home Park is almost hidden by a cluster of trees. You drive through the park on pothole-filled roads lined on each side by dozens of trailers. You can hear the sound of a creek at the back of the property, and a family of geese waddles across the road before settling down in the grassy spot in front of a beige-sided trailer.
Ever Rodriguez has lived in Castle Lake for about four years. He works as a cook at Caper’s, a restaurant in a shopping center anchored by a Publix, an upscale supermarket just off Barrett Parkway. Menu items at the restaurant include herb-crusted grouper ($18) and baby back ribs ($14 for a half-rack; $22 for a full). Rodriguez cooks at home, too—with four kids, he has to, he says. “I’m pretty good,” he shrugs. His wife, Maria Garcia, also works as a cook, at Bahama Breeze, in Town Center Commons, less than two miles up Barrett Parkway. I met Rodriguez and Garcia on a sunny April afternoon, as they were walking their son, Miguel, home from the bus stop, along with a cluster of parents and children who live in Castle Lake. Miguel, who’s in second grade at Hayes Elementary School, says math and reading are his favorite subjects; he’s also a fan of Spider-Man.
We stood in front of the family’s trailer, which is butter yellow and surrounded by shrubs and plants. Garcia loves to garden. But she had already begun to dig up and pot her favorites. The family will have to leave Castle Lake; the 52-acre property is under contract to Fuqua Development, which plans to raze the trailer park to build a massive retail complex with a Whole Foods. Fuqua’s mixed-use development will include 30 townhomes—for sale, not rent. There are currently about 1,500 people living in Castle Lake, but what will happen to them is anybody’s guess. (“The developer will be working with them,” says Mark Matthews, the mayor of Kennesaw, the Cobb County municipality that will be annexing the Castle Lake property. Fuqua did not respond to requests for comment.)
“We got a letter telling us we have 30 days to leave,” Rodriguez says. His trailer hook-up at Castle Lake costs $576 a month—and includes water. Even with payments on a trailer, there are few cheaper options nearby, he says. There are several hundred units in a nearby apartment complex that takes Section 8 vouchers, but even those rents are higher—and most of the units are already leased. Rodriguez says that he has found a spot in a trailer park in Acworth, a city about 10 miles away. But moving the trailer will cost $5,000, he figures. “Who can get that kind of money in 30 days?”
It’s unlikely the residents of Castle Lake will have an easy time finding places to live in Cobb. The county tops nationwide rankings for lack of affordable housing for very low-income families. For every 100 households in Cobb classified as “extremely low income,” a recent Urban Institute study found, there are just 2.9 available affordable housing units. Two other suburban Atlanta counties, DeKalb and Gwinnett, also make the top 10 list.
=============================================================
4/4/14
The initial 'mid-June' closing on the property has now been moved back by several months and may change again before finalized.
---------------------------------------------------------------
An April 3rd article in Capstone Quarterly by Alicia Newton titled: "Kennesaw Mayor blasts owner of annexed Mobile Home Park", she reports on a lecture given by Kennesaw Mayor Mathews to KSU journalism students. He said in part:
- “The mobile home residents are just being lied to everyday by the seller who is more interested in keeping his monthly cash flow . . .
- What the owner is doing is borderline unethical in my opinion . . .
- He is having his managers tell the tenants the land is not sold, which technically it is not, so he is continuing to rent to unsuspecting tenants never bothering to tell them they may have to be gone by June of this year . . .
- It’s pitiful, taking something super positive and it gets undermined by the residents not even knowing they are about to be put out.”
Kennesaw’s transformation begins with
commercial development
MAY 7, 2014 CAPSTONE QUARTERLY
By Alicia Newton, Ellen Eldridge, Destyni Thomas and Roderic GrahamThis is an extract from a longer article
KENNESAW— The Castle Lake Mobile Home Park has been annexed into the City of Kennesaw and residents will have to move before the year is over, yet manager Yolanda was renting lots as late as April our field reporter Alicia Newton found out.
The city of Kennesaw annexed 53 acres of county property at the Cobb Parkway and Barrett Parkway intersection, which is currently the home of Castle Lake Mobile Home Park.
Darryl Simmons, the planning and zoning administrator for Kennesaw, said that Fuqua Development has the property under contract and the Kennesaw city council voted to rezone the property from a residential mobile home park to a city planned village community. Whole Foods will anchor the Fuqua development.
While potentially adding economic impact through jobs and taxes, this new commercial development is not without controversy. Mathews said he believes what the Castle Lake landowner is doing is borderline unethical. Even though the Mathews said residents may have to be gone this year, management was still renting lots in April on a month-to-month basis, without informing tenants of the development plans, reporter Alicia Newton said.
A lot to place a single-wide trailer cost $455 per month and $465 for a double-wide, manager Yolanda said in a taped interview secretly conducted by Newton. Yolanda makes no mention to potential renters about the impending sale, Newton said.
“The lots are being rented month to month; it’s up to you if you wanted to move next month. If you have some money it’s your choice,” Yolanda said.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read the below article at: http://www.cbsatlanta.com/story/24965294/development-moves-in-forces-out-families If you want to drop Mr. Fuqua a line you can reach him at: jeff.fuqua@fuquadev.com
Development moves in, forces out families
Updated: Apr 02, 2014 11:10 PM EDT
Jennifer Mayerle - ATLANTA (CBS46) -
Atlanta and the surrounding area is growing by leaps and bounds. Time and time again undeveloped or under-developed property becomes mixed use space or retail. That's what's happening in Kennesaw at the intersection of Cobb and Barrett Parkways. But it doesn't come without controversy.
Castle Lake is the only neighborhood Jennifer Arreguin knows. "I like that we know this whole community," Arreguin said. It's full of mobile homes, some owned, others rented, mainly by families.
"We're all immigrants in my household and this is the place we felt most at home because of the heavy immigrant population here," Arturo Zertuche said.
Moneita Lewis bought her retirement home a year ago. "It belongs to me and I was planning on being here for the rest of my life," Lewis said.
Now, they realize their dreams will soon be dashed. "They're gonna tear down all this place," Arreguin said.
That's because most of Castle Lake has recently been annexed into the city of Kennesaw and rezoned. The land owner and developer are working on a deal to build a mixed use space comprised of retail, restaurants, and grocery stores. According to Kennesaw Mayor Mark Matthews the development will have a positive impact.
"It's jobs, its tax base, it's sales tax being generated in not just the city, the county, the schools, the state, it's an impact for everybody," Matthews said.
Just how much impact? The entire 84 acres at stake is currently valued at $1.3 million. Only 53 acres will be developed, but the assessed value is expected to skyrocket to $60 million.
Right now, only about $39,000 is paid in taxes per year to the county and school district. That should jump to $1.8 million. And because the property is now in Kennesaw, once complete, the city gets another $575,000. And that doesn't even consider job growth.
"To make it worthwhile it has to be sold and utilized to the highest and best use to justify the sale price. The value is a lot more than just what it's going to end up generating in property tax value," Matthews said.
And while the numbers stack up in favor of the development, these families feel it comes at their expense.
"It's obvious this is prime property. I know it would bring huge revenue into the city of Kennesaw and I know it's all about the dollar, all about the money, and it's not about people," Lewis said.
Many at Castle Lake live within walking distance of work. But most choose this neighborhood because it's affordable. "It's a lot cheaper to live here especially with the amount of space you get to live in compared to what you have to pay at apartment complexes," Zertuche said.
And now they are forced to find a new place to live. "I might have to move to Mexico, because they're going to tear down this place, and in Mexico I have this house where I can live," Arreguin said.
Jeff Fuqua of Fuqua Development said he would like to do an interview, but can't because of a confidentiality agreement. The company will help the families with relocation. Here is the statement by Fuqua:
"Here at Fuqua Development we take pride in our constant efforts to be aware of community issues and concerns in all projects in which we are involved.
Our Castle Lake project is no exception. From the beginning, we have been sensitive to the possible impact of this project on some of the current residents (143 trailers) in this mobile home park.
At this point, however, months away from closing on the 52 acres we are acquiring, it is impossible to establish a clear timeline and a detailed program to address resident relocation issues.
Nevertheless, we are already beginning to develop such a program, which we may be able to share with the affected residents probably in late spring. Those residents will be able to ask questions and comment on all elements of the program before its implementation.
While we are unable to provide relocation details for Castle Lake at this time, the tenant relocation plan that I managed during the development of Town Brookhaven is testament to Fuqua Development's commitment to put in place sensitive and beneficial relocation assistance programs when those are called for.
Town Brookhaven was developed on a 530-unit apartment complex, which required tenant relocation assistance for a large percentage of residents. Many community meetings were held to keep tenants abreast of the project and to discuss various assistance possibilities. Because a large percentage of the residents were Hispanic, all the meetings were conducted in Spanish and English, and all informational materials were in both languages as well.
Eventually, the Town Brookhaven relocation program included benefits such as assistance finding suitable apartments for relocation, security deposit assistance, moving and utility transfer assistance and cash bonuses related to individual moving dates.
Regarding the Castle Lake development, we want to reassure everyone concerned that Fuqua Development remains as committed today as it has been in the past to a substantive relocation assistance program for those affected and, further, that we will implement that plan on a timely basis, so that there will be no last-minute pressure to move."
Mayor Matthews said he, as well as, teachers and school administrators are concerned about the kids and families, and plan to help with the transition.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
A long article about Fuqua is available at: http://clatl.com/atlanta/jeff-fuqua-atlantas-most-controversial-developer/Content?oid=9217716 he is called Atlanta's most controversial developer.
RE: Whole Foods
Subject: RE: Kennesaw Store
Date: 3/7/2014 6:02:36 P.M. Eastern Standard Time
From: Darrah.Horgan@wholefoods.com
Hello Mr. Harris,
Thanks for reaching out to Whole Foods Market about this development and its affect on the neighbors of Castle Lake. We are confident in our partners at Fuqua, and they will be working with the residents to provide assistance and a fair relocation package. At this time, please contact Jeff Fuqua jeff.fuqua@fuquadev.com directly.
3/7/14
Speak Out
- From: Kennesaw Patch
Castle Lake M.H.P.
It seems that the park has been less than forthcoming in keeping residents in the loop as to their future and this has and does give considerable concern to the MHP residents on those 53 Acers.
Residents or other concerned people might contact Mr Fuqua and ask what is going on and suggest that it is past time for details of the promised ‘relocation package’ to be made public.
At a minimum they should expect:
1) assistance of a professional real estate firm to find new housing for them,2) return of any posted security deposits and
3) ‘Key Money’ to assist in any relocation from Castle Lake.
The parties with relevant information can be reached via:
jeff.fuqua@fuquadev.com and jennifer.ledbetter@fuquadev.com
FUQUA DEVELOPMENT HOLDINGS L.L.C.
3495 Piedmont Rd., NE, Bldg 11, #905
Atlanta, Ga. 30305
Tel: 404 214-3332
and the Castle Lake MHP owners are at:
Joseph and Marcos Ergas
The Ergas Group
1045-1185 Georgia St West
Vancouver, BC V6E 4E6
Tel: 604-687-2310 Fax: 604-687-2380
(Typical store front for such developments)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2/24/2014
‘We don’t live in a perfect world’
Advocates calling on community to assist Castle Lake tenants
Advocates calling on community to assist Castle Lake tenants
By Rachel Gray rgray@mdjonline.com
KENNESAW — Two community groups will continue their outreach to a group of often marginalized residents, hoping the rest of Cobb will aid the same people when they are evicted. A 52-acre tract on the northwest corner of Barrett and Cobb parkways is slated for a commercial project by Atlanta-based Fuqua Development, which will close at least part of the Castle Lake Mobile Home Park that houses an estimated 1,500 people.
The mobile home park includes 250 lots, with both rented and purchased prefabricated homes lining the narrow, cracked roads that make a grid in the wooded area.
Last week, residents of the complex addressed the Kennesaw City Council in both English and Spanish, trying to stop the $150 million commercial development.
Those cries of dissent were joined by statements from two community advocates.
One speaker was Pastor Tom Tanner of Riverstone Church, which has been located off Stilesboro Road, less than a mile from Castle Lake, since 2006.
On Sunday, Tanner preached out of the book of Mark, where Jesus challenges his followers to give away their processions to the poor in order to serve the Lord and enter the kingdom of heaven.
On the walls of the Riverstone Church sanctuary are blocks with a few words, including outreach, development and community transformation.
Many members of the church have literally taken those words to the streets, hoping to shape one neighborhood at a time, not by just providing for the physical needs but in building relationships.
“We care deeply about the people of Castle Lake,” Tanner said.
Almost three years ago, Brad and Brooke Kireta started an outreach group for Castle Lake, offering English classes for adults while their children are tutored, providing materials and labor to build a new playground, donating free haircuts, playing host to cookouts and repairing the homes of single mothers and widows.
The promise of relocation help
On Feb. 17, The Kennesaw City Council voted 5-0 to annex much of the mobile home property into the city limits, with a condition requiring Fuqua to submit a relocation plan to move existing residents prior to the beginning of construction.
Attorney Garvis Sams, of the Marietta-based firm Sams, Larkin, Huff & Balli, LLP that represents Fuqua, said the project would break ground in six months and open in the spring of 2016.
After hearing the residents’ cries for help, Mayor Mark Mathews said the developer would work closely with the residents to help them relocate. Jeff Fuqua, who formed Fuqua Development LP in March 2012, attended the public hearing and through Sams told the crowd the company would form a committee this spring to start relocation assistance on a family by family basis.
With four extension churches throughout Cobb and another starting in Smyrna, Tanner said he is not concerned about the Castle Lake residents moving away from Riverstone Church, because there is a great chance a similar congregation will be nearby. But he wants to make sure their other needs are “intentionally cared for,” Tanner said. The Kiretas said Castle Lake is a strong community where neighbors rely on each other for rides to work and child care, and dispersing the close-knit groups could have a devastating impact.
“These people do life together,” said Brad Kireta, including the four busloads of kids who attend nearby public schools from kindergarten through high school.
Brooke Kireta said many of the residents may not know English, but are intelligent, hardworking people who want to contribute to the greater community.
“It is a cultural view that they come to the country to take, take, take, but often they are the ones being taken advantage of,” Brooke Kireta said.
Losing homes, way of life
Another outspoken advocate said the fear of outsiders now seems founded as Castle Lake residents are losing their only sense of security: their community.Shannan Smith Sikorski, who also gave an emotional speech to the City Council last week, is the owner of Big Shanty Barbershop off Main Street in downtown Kennesaw.
Born and raised in Kennesaw, Sikorski said she first began raising money for the Castle Lake residents more than two years ago after reading about a backpack program that provides lunches to hungry kids.
With the support of friends, families and businesses, Sikorski said her charity helps pay utility bills and provided 153 toys this Christmas season, mostly to people Sikorski said are too scared to ask for help or too shy to accept donations.
“We had to force turkeys on them,” Sikorski said about a program she organized around Thanksgiving. “They don’t want to take too much.”
During the holiday season, Sikorski said her charity gave $3,000 worth of donations, but that money could have been used for an even greater purpose if the neighborhood had been told about the impending development.
“Long-term housing might have been a better gift,” Sikorski said.
The young children, who Sikorski emphasizes are American citizens, and work diligently in school
Shannon Smith Sikorski, a small business owner in Kennesaw, has been working with the Castle Lake community to provide food and holiday gifts, and is hoping the Kennesaw community will rally behind Castle Lake to help their relocation be successful and keep families together. Below: A proposed 52-acre development is targeted for the northwest corner of Barrett and Cobb parkways and all 1,500 residents of the mobile home park could be affected or forced to move.
to break the cycle of poverty, but she has been told by parents their grades are already slipping do to the stress of moving. “It is up to us to keep the dream alive,” Sikorski said.
Although Sikorski said she has no plans to picket the new businesses or lie down in front of bulldozers, she will be “barking in everyone’s ear” until the last person is safely relocated.
The city’s economic development
In December, Fuqua filed papers with Kennesaw seeking to rezone the property from a county residential mobile home park to a city planned village community.
The massive mixeduse project would include 450,000 square feet of retail space and 30 townhomes on the western side of the property. The townhomes would be purchased, not rented.
Whole Foods Market has agreed to anchor the large shopping complex. There is also space designated for a sporting goods store, and room to add a drug store, casual dining restaurants, specialty retail shops, office space and even a gas station, Sams said.
Darryl Simmons, Kennesaw’s planning and zoning administrator, said the Atlanta Regional Commission received a copy of the site plans and “determined that this mixed use development is not a Development of Regional Impact.”
Developments of Regional Impact are large-scale developments that are likely to have regional effects beyond the local government jurisdiction in which they are located.
As for the rezoning and annexation decision by the City Council, any party desiring to appeal would have to file with the Superior Court of Cobb County by the middle of March, Simmons said. Riverstone Church is not against the commercial development, “just the way it all went down,” Tanner said.
Tanner, who lives in Kennesaw, said the new stores and restaurants would be good for the city, with more jobs and an economic boost.
Organizers of the outreach from Riverstone Church said the Castle Lake management staff has opened land and buildings to allow the group to help residents.
But Sikorski said the management company has hidden details and purposely miscommunicated, further breaking down the trust the residents have for other officials.
“The most important thing right now is that they understand everything that has been done,” Sikorski said.
At the Feb. 17 meeting, Mathews said the council was not aware the management of Castle Lake had not communicated the plan to sell the land until recently.
Mathews gave his word that the Castle Lake families would be treated fairly and be placed in a better living situation than the one in which they are currently living.
Even with the high possibility of leaving schools that have created programs for the Castle Lake children or quitting jobs that will no longer be within walking distance, Sikorski said in a “perfect world,” being forced to find new homes could be the best thing for the residents.
“But we don’t live in a perfect world,” Sikorski said.
2/18/2014
Kennesaw OKs rezoning for development despite protests
by Rachel Gray, Marietta Daily Journal February 18, 2014 04:00 AM
Link to article: http://mdjonline.com/view/full_story/24598373/article-Kennesaw-OKs-rezoning-for-development-despite-protests?instance=home_top_bullets
Link to article: http://mdjonline.com/view/full_story/24598373/article-Kennesaw-OKs-rezoning-for-development-despite-protests?instance=home_top_bullets
KENNESAW — More than 50 adults, many with their young children, tried to stop a proposed $150 million commercial development during Monday’s Kennesaw City Council meeting.
The proposed 52-acre development is targeted for the northwest corner of Barrett and Cobb parkways.
Atlanta-based Fuqua Development plans to close at least part of the Castle Lake Mobile Home Park, which sits on the site and serves as home to dozens of families.
In December, Fuqua filed papers with Kennesaw seeking to rezone the property from a county residential mobile home park to a city planned village community.
On Monday night, the Kennesaw City Council voted 5-0 to both rezone the land and annex the property into the city limits.
An additional 34 acres of the mobile home park, west of the proposed development, would stay county property and remain owned by Castle Lake Mobile Home Park.
Attorney Garvis Sams, of the Marietta-based firm Sams, Larkin, Huff & Balli, LLP that represents Fuqua, said he believes that 34 acres will most likely be redeveloped and brought into the city limits in the future.
This first project would break ground in six months and open in the spring of 2016, Sams told the council.
Mayor Mark Mathews said Fuqua has the site under contract and knows the market through demographic studies, so the developer will decide what mix of stores would work best.
The massive mixed-use project would include 450,000 square feet of retail space and 30 townhomes on the western side of the property, said Bob Fox, the city’s economic development director.
The townhomes would be purchased, not rented.
Whole Foods Market has agreed to anchor the large shopping complex. There is also space designated for a sporting goods store, with room to add a drug store, casual dining restaurants, specialty retail shops, office space and even a gas station, Sams said.
Fuqua has agreed to stipulations that pawn shops, thrift stores and tattoo parlors would not be allowed.
As a life-long Cobb resident, Sams said he is an advocate for this particular plan for the site. “My wife wants to see a Whole Foods more than you can possibly imagine,” Sams said.
Mathews said neither the City Council nor the Kennesaw Development Authority have any plans to offer tax abatements or other monetary incentives to the developer or the businesses planning to lease space.
If any requests are made, including to the KDA, Mathews said he and the City Council would have to approve the deals.
Residents hold on to American Dream
Some of Monday night’s speakers made their statements in Spanish, with a city-provided interpreter translating the pleas of people who have invested their life savings to purchase and repair homes in Castle Lake.
A mother of two daughters, Jacqueline Lopez, 29, began to cry when she told the council their “American dream was being taken away.”
One man, Joaquin Banuelos, 22, who has lived at Castle Lake for over 10 years, said Fuqua’s plan sounds like a great benefit to the “millionaire” developer, but where does it leave the tight-knit Latino community?
“I don’t even know where I am going to go next,” Banuelos said.
Because he is “poor,” Banuelos said he is worried his words would not mean anything to the councilmembers.
“We work for you, the millionaire people,” said Banuelos, who works in the construction industry.
Councilman Jim Sebastian, who moved to Cobb in 1976 and is an owner of a consulting and brokering firm which specializes in retail service contracts, said development of the land is part of the city’s expansion strategy.
Sebastian said the city has asked the Castle Lake Mobile Home Park property owners to consider annexation for at least three years, with limited feedback until a year ago.
The Kennesaw Planning Commission, at a Feb. 5 meeting, voted 5-0 to recommend approval of the annexation, with a condition requiring Fuqua to submit a relocation plan to move existing residents prior to construction beginning.
Where’s the relocation plan?
Although most of the speakers from Castle Lake came to object to the project, many said they realized the commercial development would not be stopped.
The consistent question became, if the development has been planned for years, why were the mobile park residents only informed of the sale now and why is the relocation plan not finalized?
Sebastian said the exchange of the property was between two private companies, and if the development had been residential and remained part of the county, the deal would never have been reviewed by the Kennesaw City Council.
Monday’s public hearing about the rezoning and annexation was a benefit to homeowners in Castle Lake, Sebastian said. “It gives them time to voice their concerns,” he said.
Mathews said the council was not aware the management of Castle Lake had not communicated the plan to sell the land until recently.
The mayor said the city made every effort to inform the residents about Monday’s meeting.
Mathews gave his word Monday night that from this point forward the Castle Lake families would be treated fairly and be placed in a better living situation than the one in which they are currently living.
Jeff Fuqua, who formed Fuqua Development, LP in March 2012, attended Monday’s public hearing.
After talking with his client, Sams said Fuqua would form a committee this spring to start relocation assistance on a family by family basis.
CASTLE LAKE HOMES CORP.
(Created March 24, 2009)
Officers:
CEO Joseph Ergas,
CFO Joseph Ergas,
Secretary Marcos Ergas
Other names used are:
EGI International Corp
Masal Partners Ltd. L.P.
Amak Partners, L.P.
(all with the same Vancouver address)
Other names used are:
EGI International Corp
Masal Partners Ltd. L.P.
Amak Partners, L.P.
(all with the same Vancouver address)
===================================================================
MHP Reviews From:
http://www.kudzu.com/m/Castle-Lake-Mobile-Home-Cmnty-706183/reviews/
Castle Lake Mobile Home Cmnty
2 reviews
1650 Highway 41 Kennesaw, GA 30152 Phone: (770) 422-7275
Truthbetoldatl
Reviews: 1 Posted on 8/2/2012
Stay Away From Castle Lake and MARILYN HAGY !!!!!
Out of curiosity I looked up Castle LakeI lived there back in the late 1990's / early 2000's.
Marilyn was there way back then and what a dirty underhanded woman she was and apparently still is! Someone should investigate her and the way she runs the office. I'll bet the authorities would love to have some proof of the fact that she rents to illegals without papers! She was doing the same thing back then. AND they also had unregistered sex offenders living there back when I was there and I would not be surprised if they still did and she helped to hide them out. I had issue with her because she tried to put a fraudulent report on my equifax stating I owed money I DIDN'T owe and I had to have them remove it. I noticed some of her illegal business practices then, but had no way to prove it. STAY AWAY! THERE ARE MANY BETTER PLACES IN THE AREA.
And if anyone has proof of her illegal renting activities turn her in She deserves to be in jail!...
gordagorda
Reviews: 1 Posted on 10/10/2010
worse maneger in the world
maneger is abusive toward tenants, abuses her athority as maneger, worst assistant manger yolanda!!!!!!!! very vebaly abusave to tenents, marilyn hagee threatents to evict to scare tenants, she always turns the water off but isist on not giving credits on water bill. exepts money under the table to allow illegals with no papers to move in. pays illegals under the table and americans to work for her. tis tis.
Castle Lake MHP, Kennesaw
1650 Cobb Pky, Kennesaw
If you don’t like what is happening at Castle Lake MHP you can contact the Canadian firm which owns the property and those millionares who are principals in this property investment firm:
The Ergas Group, (Morris Ergas, Joseph Ergas, Marcos Ergas) Tel: 604-687-2310, 1185 Georgia St W, #1520, Vancouver, BC V6E 4E6, Canada
Joseph Ergas, Home (604) 926-6536, 2250 Bellevue Ave West Vancouver, BC V7V 1C6
Marcos Ergas, (604) 925-4350, 1340 Jefferson Ave, West Vancouver BC V7T2B2
Wealthy Vancouver Canada property investors Joseph and Marcos Ergas, owners of Castle Lake Homes Corp (aka 'The Ergas Group'), are probably watching the clock run out on the 30 day window for a possible Kennesaw annexation appeal on the pending sale of 53 of their 87 acre Castle Lake MHP to controversial Atlanta developer Jeff Fuqua and his Fuqua Development Holdings, LLC.
The entire property is valued at $3,250,000 but generates only $39,000 yearly for Cobb County in property taxes.
If the sale is finalized to Fuqua and developed as a mid-sized retail development considerably more taxes will be generated and additional jobs will come to the area.
With an initially estimated 600-700 impacted residents of the Castle Lake MHP you might wonder if there is any recourse for them in the recent 5-0 Council vote for annexation of the unincorporated Cobb County acreage.
There are avenues via both the Superior Court and a direct appeal to the City, if done in the 30 day window of opportunity. The end date for such a challenge would be Wed. March 19th. There is no change in the status of the 53 acres until then and as yet no indication of an appeal.
The major issue at present is the displacement of those on the affected acreage and those remaining 34 MHP acres which will shortly follow to other developers with an eventual removal of over 1,000+ retirees, low income and Hispanic residents, all probable Kennesaw residents/citizens, although such residency/citizenship would be of short duration for most.
An occasionally mentioned 'relocation package' has yet to have any details firmed up and this has caused considerable unrest and anxiety in the Castle Lake community. Speaking at the City Council meeting where the annexation and rezoning was approved Hispanic residents put on record their concern about having invested their life savings into the purchase and repair of their mobile homes in Castle Lake.
A 10 year resident complained that Fuqua's development plan seemed a great benefit to the 'millionaire' developer at the expense of the Latino community at Castle Lake. The MDJ quoted a Mr Banuelos having said that "his words would not mean anything to the Councilmembers" and "I don't even know where I am going to go next".
While the City and the attorney for Fuqua have both indicated that some plan would be put into effect for those to be displaced it remains to be seen what will be done. At minimum it should include hiring a professional real estate firm to assist the displaced finding places in other MHP's or area rental housing, refunding in full all security deposits and providing reasonable 'key money' for those who leave to defray their relocation costs.
With circulation of 16,000 not everyone reads the Marietta Daily Journal on a regular basis. Recently they have been keeping up with the issue of a lack of a firm 'relocation' package for those residents of the Castle Lake Mobile Home Park.
Wealthy Vancouver Canada property investors Joseph and Marcos Ergas, owners of Castle Lake Homes Corp (aka 'The Ergas Group'), are probably watching the clock run out on the 30 day window for a possible Kennesaw annexation appeal on the pending sale of 53 of their 87 acre Castle Lake MHP to controversial Atlanta developer Jeff Fuqua and his Fuqua Development Holdings, LLC.
The entire property is valued at $3,250,000 but generates only $39,000 yearly for Cobb County in property taxes.
If the sale is finalized to Fuqua and developed as a mid-sized retail development considerably more taxes will be generated and additional jobs will come to the area.
With an initially estimated 600-700 impacted residents of the Castle Lake MHP you might wonder if there is any recourse for them in the recent 5-0 Council vote for annexation of the unincorporated Cobb County acreage.
There are avenues via both the Superior Court and a direct appeal to the City, if done in the 30 day window of opportunity. The end date for such a challenge would be Wed. March 19th. There is no change in the status of the 53 acres until then and as yet no indication of an appeal.
The major issue at present is the displacement of those on the affected acreage and those remaining 34 MHP acres which will shortly follow to other developers with an eventual removal of over 1,000+ retirees, low income and Hispanic residents, all probable Kennesaw residents/citizens, although such residency/citizenship would be of short duration for most.
An occasionally mentioned 'relocation package' has yet to have any details firmed up and this has caused considerable unrest and anxiety in the Castle Lake community. Speaking at the City Council meeting where the annexation and rezoning was approved Hispanic residents put on record their concern about having invested their life savings into the purchase and repair of their mobile homes in Castle Lake.
A 10 year resident complained that Fuqua's development plan seemed a great benefit to the 'millionaire' developer at the expense of the Latino community at Castle Lake. The MDJ quoted a Mr Banuelos having said that "his words would not mean anything to the Councilmembers" and "I don't even know where I am going to go next".
While the City and the attorney for Fuqua have both indicated that some plan would be put into effect for those to be displaced it remains to be seen what will be done. At minimum it should include hiring a professional real estate firm to assist the displaced finding places in other MHP's or area rental housing, refunding in full all security deposits and providing reasonable 'key money' for those who leave to defray their relocation costs.
With circulation of 16,000 not everyone reads the Marietta Daily Journal on a regular basis. Recently they have been keeping up with the issue of a lack of a firm 'relocation' package for those residents of the Castle Lake Mobile Home Park.
====================================================
MHP Reviews From:
http://www.kudzu.com/m/Castle-Lake-Mobile-Home-Cmnty-706183/reviews/
Castle Lake Mobile Home Cmnty
2 reviews
1650 Highway 41 Kennesaw, GA 30152 Phone: (770) 422-7275
Truthbetoldatl
Reviews: 1 Posted on 8/2/2012
Stay Away From Castle Lake and MARILYN HAGY !!!!!
Out of curiosity I looked up Castle LakeI lived there back in the late 1990's / early 2000's.
Marilyn was there way back then and what a dirty underhanded woman she was and apparently still is! Someone should investigate her and the way she runs the office. I'll bet the authorities would love to have some proof of the fact that she rents to illegals without papers! She was doing the same thing back then. AND they also had unregistered sex offenders living there back when I was there and I would not be surprised if they still did and she helped to hide them out. I had issue with her because she tried to put a fraudulent report on my equifax stating I owed money I DIDN'T owe and I had to have them remove it. I noticed some of her illegal business practices then, but had no way to prove it. STAY AWAY! THERE ARE MANY BETTER PLACES IN THE AREA.
And if anyone has proof of her illegal renting activities turn her in She deserves to be in jail!...
gordagorda
Reviews: 1 Posted on 10/10/2010
worse maneger in the world
maneger is abusive toward tenants, abuses her athority as maneger, worst assistant manger yolanda!!!!!!!! very vebaly abusave to tenents, marilyn hagee threatents to evict to scare tenants, she always turns the water off but isist on not giving credits on water bill. exepts money under the table to allow illegals with no papers to move in. pays illegals under the table and americans to work for her. tis tis.
Castle Lake MHP Photos 2014
Mathews Accused of Being a Bully
The below MDJ article of 1/23/14 is reproduced here as the MDJ circulation in Kennesaw is limited and residents might not have otherwise seen it.
Speaking of Mathews 'bullying' I would direct you to the Oct 29th entry on this site where you will see many of the rude posts sent to me by this Mayor.
The below MDJ article of 1/23/14 is reproduced here as the MDJ circulation in Kennesaw is limited and residents might not have otherwise seen it.
Speaking of Mathews 'bullying' I would direct you to the Oct 29th entry on this site where you will see many of the rude posts sent to me by this Mayor.
=======================================================
2 councilwomen, resident accuse mayor of bullying
January 22, 2014 11:55 PM
KENNESAW — Two councilwomen and an outspoken supporter Tuesday night called for an end to what they see as bullying by Mayor Mark Mathews, accusing him of setting a tone that has divided the city.
Eileen Alberstadt, a familiar face at city meetings, said during the public comment portion of Tuesday night’s council meeting that she was speaking on behalf of a group of concerned citizens who want to see the city “unite.”
Alberstadt firmly said that the bullying has to stop, or she will personally petition to have Mathews or members of the council recalled and removed from office.
Alberstadt, who has lived in Kennesaw for 10 years after moving from Tallahassee, Fla., to Cobb, said some council members are her friends. But, Alberstadt said she shares “bad blood” with Mathews and other council members over past disagreements.
On Tuesday night, Councilwoman Cris Welsh said she had prepared a statement, but she went off the script to address the crowded room of residents.
Welsh said Mathews has been condescending toward her during their conversations.
And, for the majority of the time she has been on the council, Welsh said she has spent two and a half years “avoiding slings and arrows.”
“I’m done with that,” she said.
Welsh says ‘stop the infighting’
The infighting has caused Welsh to neglect her family and business, she said. Welsh has two young daughters, Isabelle and Shelby, and runs Eaton Chiropractic on Main Street in downtown Kennesaw.
Welsh said her antagonists have accused Welsh of owing past-due property taxes. Welsh said Tuesday night that during the slow economy she has tightened her belt and is paying the taxes in installments, just as other property owners have been forced to do.
“I am not ashamed. I am not alone,” Welsh said.
Welsh won re-election in 2011 for a second term and took office in January 2012. Her term expires at the end of 2015.
“Despite what’s gone on up here the last two and a half years, despite the tone that has been set,” Welsh said the city staff has done an excellent job and the city has moved forward, with more positive news on the horizon.
But, she said, “the infighting has got to stop. It’s the last thing we need. We are going to disagree on a lot of stuff, but we don’t have to disagree and take it personally.
“I just want to finish up my final two years in peace.”
The mayor versus the council
On Tuesday, Councilwoman Debra Williams said the council is composed of many personalities with strong convictions.
And, each council member has supporters “who are going to defend us till the end,” Williams said.
But, she asked those people not to make disagreements between Mathews and a council member personal.
“When we divide, we cannot make progress,” Williams said.
Mathews did not address the outcry by Alberstadt during the meeting, but said afterward he does not know what the real issue is.
“It has evolved into something where no one can pinpoint specifics,” Mathews said. “For months I have asked to be called out on any actions of mine that are questionable.”
Mathews accused members of the council of not talking directly to each other or with him, instead using social media or supporters in the community to address issues and come down on one side or the other.
He said council members should “take responsibility” for their actions, matching what they say.
“I feel like my actions and my words are consistent,” Mathews said.
Mathews said any change in attitude by the council will be up to each individual.
After the public meeting Tuesday night, each council member and Mathews posed and smiled to take a picture together to be hung in the foyer of city hall.
Speaking for the residents
Alberstadt was the only resident who spoke during the public comment section Tuesday night.
She said Kennesaw residents are fed up with the power struggles happening on the City Council, which swore in three new members about two weeks ago.
“I would like to know and the citizens would like to know, when are you going to work together?” Alberstadt asked.
Alberstadt said she does not expect the council members to all vote the same, but they need to join together to address the needs of Kennesaw.
The council should have “no secret projects or backroom handshake deals,” Alberstadt said, and all information about future developments in Kennesaw should be shared between all the council members and Mathews.
Alberstadt is a retired legal assistant who served on the Kennesaw Ethics Board until a year and a half ago. Now, Alberstadt said, she wants to “work in the wings,” helping businesses write grants to update their signage to beautify Kennesaw.
The high voter turnout at last year’s election has stirred Kennesaw residents into action, Alberstadt said, including some community members with extensive educational backgrounds who want to join city boards.
Alberstadt said it will be clear if the council and Mathews heard her warning by their personal encounters with her in the future.
Eileen Alberstadt, a familiar face at city meetings, said during the public comment portion of Tuesday night’s council meeting that she was speaking on behalf of a group of concerned citizens who want to see the city “unite.”
Alberstadt firmly said that the bullying has to stop, or she will personally petition to have Mathews or members of the council recalled and removed from office.
Alberstadt, who has lived in Kennesaw for 10 years after moving from Tallahassee, Fla., to Cobb, said some council members are her friends. But, Alberstadt said she shares “bad blood” with Mathews and other council members over past disagreements.
On Tuesday night, Councilwoman Cris Welsh said she had prepared a statement, but she went off the script to address the crowded room of residents.
Welsh said Mathews has been condescending toward her during their conversations.
And, for the majority of the time she has been on the council, Welsh said she has spent two and a half years “avoiding slings and arrows.”
“I’m done with that,” she said.
Welsh says ‘stop the infighting’
The infighting has caused Welsh to neglect her family and business, she said. Welsh has two young daughters, Isabelle and Shelby, and runs Eaton Chiropractic on Main Street in downtown Kennesaw.
Welsh said her antagonists have accused Welsh of owing past-due property taxes. Welsh said Tuesday night that during the slow economy she has tightened her belt and is paying the taxes in installments, just as other property owners have been forced to do.
“I am not ashamed. I am not alone,” Welsh said.
Welsh won re-election in 2011 for a second term and took office in January 2012. Her term expires at the end of 2015.
“Despite what’s gone on up here the last two and a half years, despite the tone that has been set,” Welsh said the city staff has done an excellent job and the city has moved forward, with more positive news on the horizon.
But, she said, “the infighting has got to stop. It’s the last thing we need. We are going to disagree on a lot of stuff, but we don’t have to disagree and take it personally.
“I just want to finish up my final two years in peace.”
The mayor versus the council
On Tuesday, Councilwoman Debra Williams said the council is composed of many personalities with strong convictions.
And, each council member has supporters “who are going to defend us till the end,” Williams said.
But, she asked those people not to make disagreements between Mathews and a council member personal.
“When we divide, we cannot make progress,” Williams said.
Mathews did not address the outcry by Alberstadt during the meeting, but said afterward he does not know what the real issue is.
“It has evolved into something where no one can pinpoint specifics,” Mathews said. “For months I have asked to be called out on any actions of mine that are questionable.”
Mathews accused members of the council of not talking directly to each other or with him, instead using social media or supporters in the community to address issues and come down on one side or the other.
He said council members should “take responsibility” for their actions, matching what they say.
“I feel like my actions and my words are consistent,” Mathews said.
Mathews said any change in attitude by the council will be up to each individual.
After the public meeting Tuesday night, each council member and Mathews posed and smiled to take a picture together to be hung in the foyer of city hall.
Speaking for the residents
Alberstadt was the only resident who spoke during the public comment section Tuesday night.
She said Kennesaw residents are fed up with the power struggles happening on the City Council, which swore in three new members about two weeks ago.
“I would like to know and the citizens would like to know, when are you going to work together?” Alberstadt asked.
Alberstadt said she does not expect the council members to all vote the same, but they need to join together to address the needs of Kennesaw.
The council should have “no secret projects or backroom handshake deals,” Alberstadt said, and all information about future developments in Kennesaw should be shared between all the council members and Mathews.
Alberstadt is a retired legal assistant who served on the Kennesaw Ethics Board until a year and a half ago. Now, Alberstadt said, she wants to “work in the wings,” helping businesses write grants to update their signage to beautify Kennesaw.
The high voter turnout at last year’s election has stirred Kennesaw residents into action, Alberstadt said, including some community members with extensive educational backgrounds who want to join city boards.
Alberstadt said it will be clear if the council and Mathews heard her warning by their personal encounters with her in the future.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6/19/14
Saw this in the MDJ of 6/19/14 and I will park it here for now as the top of the blog is for Castle Lake info, sent off my 'comment' but who knows if it will be run. I did get a 'letter to the editor' published 2 days ago.
Bill
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kennesaw rejects trip to Dallas for mayor
KENNESAW — Taxpayers likely won’t be sending a local mayor to Texas after the Kennesaw City Council voted against funding for his trip by a 3-2 vote.
Monday night, the council denied Kennesaw Mayor Mark Mathews a $2,500 trip to Dallas for an economic development conference Aug. 24 to 25.
“This was on the agenda as a professional courtesy to my peers, and they decided they didn’t think it was a worthy expenditure,” Mathews said.
Council members Cris Welsh, Debra Williams and Jim Sebastian voted against paying for the trip. Tim Killingsworth and Leonard Church voted in favor of it.
The trip is part of the Cobb Chamber’s Economic Development for a Growing Economy initiative and is called Opportunity Dallas 2014. The agenda item from the council meeting said the trip “is an elite opportunity to gather best practices related to all areas of the EDGE strategy. During the trip, visitors will examine how Dallas attracts talent and defines its communities as well as tour the city’s business incubators and sporting facilities and meet with Dallas’ economic development leaders.”
The agenda item said the $2,500 price tag covers “ground and air transportation, hotel and some meals.”
Welsh said it was too expensive.
“I don’t think it was a wise use of money,” she said. “The price was a huge part of it; $2,500 is a lot of money for a three-day trip.”
New members shake up council
Williams and Sebastian both are in their first year on the council. Williams said the previous council likely would have sent Mathews to Dallas.
“It’d be 3-2 in favor,” she said. “The new members — I know I can speak for Sebastian and myself — we’re looking at this entirely different.”
Williams talked about how some politicians think taxpayers should pay for programs that benefit them personally. She said former Kennesaw councilman Jeff Duckett, who lost to Sebastian last November, worked out a deal where the city paid for half of his $3,000 cost to participate in Leadership Cobb, another Chamber program. Williams said the city paid $1,500 for the program even though Duckett lost and is no longer representing the city.
“Those are the types of things that make career politicians and set politicians up for a lifestyle of staying in politics,” Williams said. “I have a huge issue with that. The citizens paid half of Duckett’s Leadership Cobb, and he was not an elected official.”
After the vote, Mathews seemed upset the council members did not mention anything about their opposition to the trip before voting against it.
“The irony of the whole thing is this was put on the agenda as a courtesy to get the authority to do so,” Mathews said. “The courtesy wasn’t extended to me. They didn’t support it or tell me they would vote against it.”
Mathews said similar expenditures were approved in the past, including “around $2,000” to pay for Welsh to attend a Cobb Chamber program in December 2013.
Welsh said that was a different situation.
“They are not even remotely the same,” she said. “I’m in the Honorary Commanders program through the Chamber. It’s $1,700, which the council voted for. It’s a year-long program and when we do excursions I pay with my own money. It’s also a program Mark has gone through. This is $2,500 for a three-day trip on economic development. Economic development is not his job.”
Welsh said Bob Fox, the city’s economic development director, would have been a better candidate to go on the trip.
Mathews said he may still attend the conference. He could veto the item, pay his own way or go using city money despite the vote.
“I haven’t made a final decision yet,” he said. “Typically, those items are put on just as a courtesy and spread on the minutes. Our charter and everything allows us to do the business of the city as we deem necessary.”
This isn’t the first time Mathews’ use of taxpayer funds has come under fire.
Between December 2012 and September 2013, Mathews spent more than $8,000 on restaurant tabs, flights to conventions and events across the country, iPad accessories and memorabilia for city residents using a city-issued credit card.
Kennesaw has no documented limits on credit card spending by the mayor and council members, who are given the cards after being sworn into office.
The MDJ exposed the council’s use of credit cards in October 2013, and Kennesaw council members Duckett, Jenkins and Matt Riedemann were swept out of office the next month.
Other officials not going
None of the other five mayors in Cobb County said they planned to go on the trip, though Brooks Mathis, executive director of the EDGE initiative and a vice president of the Cobb Chamber, said all were invited. Cobb Commission Chairman Tim Lee, who co-chairs the EDGE program, said he will not be attending either.
EDGE is a five-year initiative which is in its second year. The program’s goals are to create 7,500 new jobs, increase payroll earnings and income by $420 million and $7,000 per capita in Cobb County, reduce unemployment to 5.5 percent, increase the public school graduation rate by 4 percent and increase the number of college-bound students in Cobb by 7 percent, according to the program’s annual report.
Mathis said this is the third trip taken as part of EDGE. The first trip was to Fairfax, Va., and the second was to Cleveland, Ohio, where the group toured that city’s bus rapid transit program. Mathis said the trips help leaders learn from the places they visit.
“They’ve got a stadium in Dallas similar to the project we’re working (with the Braves),” Mathis said. “It will show how they are able to develop and work a stadium project. There are small business incubators we’re going to look at… We compete with Dallas quite a bit on economic development.”
Monday night, the council denied Kennesaw Mayor Mark Mathews a $2,500 trip to Dallas for an economic development conference Aug. 24 to 25.
“This was on the agenda as a professional courtesy to my peers, and they decided they didn’t think it was a worthy expenditure,” Mathews said.
Council members Cris Welsh, Debra Williams and Jim Sebastian voted against paying for the trip. Tim Killingsworth and Leonard Church voted in favor of it.
The trip is part of the Cobb Chamber’s Economic Development for a Growing Economy initiative and is called Opportunity Dallas 2014. The agenda item from the council meeting said the trip “is an elite opportunity to gather best practices related to all areas of the EDGE strategy. During the trip, visitors will examine how Dallas attracts talent and defines its communities as well as tour the city’s business incubators and sporting facilities and meet with Dallas’ economic development leaders.”
The agenda item said the $2,500 price tag covers “ground and air transportation, hotel and some meals.”
Welsh said it was too expensive.
“I don’t think it was a wise use of money,” she said. “The price was a huge part of it; $2,500 is a lot of money for a three-day trip.”
New members shake up council
Williams and Sebastian both are in their first year on the council. Williams said the previous council likely would have sent Mathews to Dallas.
“It’d be 3-2 in favor,” she said. “The new members — I know I can speak for Sebastian and myself — we’re looking at this entirely different.”
Williams talked about how some politicians think taxpayers should pay for programs that benefit them personally. She said former Kennesaw councilman Jeff Duckett, who lost to Sebastian last November, worked out a deal where the city paid for half of his $3,000 cost to participate in Leadership Cobb, another Chamber program. Williams said the city paid $1,500 for the program even though Duckett lost and is no longer representing the city.
“Those are the types of things that make career politicians and set politicians up for a lifestyle of staying in politics,” Williams said. “I have a huge issue with that. The citizens paid half of Duckett’s Leadership Cobb, and he was not an elected official.”
After the vote, Mathews seemed upset the council members did not mention anything about their opposition to the trip before voting against it.
“The irony of the whole thing is this was put on the agenda as a courtesy to get the authority to do so,” Mathews said. “The courtesy wasn’t extended to me. They didn’t support it or tell me they would vote against it.”
Mathews said similar expenditures were approved in the past, including “around $2,000” to pay for Welsh to attend a Cobb Chamber program in December 2013.
Welsh said that was a different situation.
“They are not even remotely the same,” she said. “I’m in the Honorary Commanders program through the Chamber. It’s $1,700, which the council voted for. It’s a year-long program and when we do excursions I pay with my own money. It’s also a program Mark has gone through. This is $2,500 for a three-day trip on economic development. Economic development is not his job.”
Welsh said Bob Fox, the city’s economic development director, would have been a better candidate to go on the trip.
Mathews said he may still attend the conference. He could veto the item, pay his own way or go using city money despite the vote.
“I haven’t made a final decision yet,” he said. “Typically, those items are put on just as a courtesy and spread on the minutes. Our charter and everything allows us to do the business of the city as we deem necessary.”
This isn’t the first time Mathews’ use of taxpayer funds has come under fire.
Between December 2012 and September 2013, Mathews spent more than $8,000 on restaurant tabs, flights to conventions and events across the country, iPad accessories and memorabilia for city residents using a city-issued credit card.
Kennesaw has no documented limits on credit card spending by the mayor and council members, who are given the cards after being sworn into office.
The MDJ exposed the council’s use of credit cards in October 2013, and Kennesaw council members Duckett, Jenkins and Matt Riedemann were swept out of office the next month.
Other officials not going
None of the other five mayors in Cobb County said they planned to go on the trip, though Brooks Mathis, executive director of the EDGE initiative and a vice president of the Cobb Chamber, said all were invited. Cobb Commission Chairman Tim Lee, who co-chairs the EDGE program, said he will not be attending either.
EDGE is a five-year initiative which is in its second year. The program’s goals are to create 7,500 new jobs, increase payroll earnings and income by $420 million and $7,000 per capita in Cobb County, reduce unemployment to 5.5 percent, increase the public school graduation rate by 4 percent and increase the number of college-bound students in Cobb by 7 percent, according to the program’s annual report.
Mathis said this is the third trip taken as part of EDGE. The first trip was to Fairfax, Va., and the second was to Cleveland, Ohio, where the group toured that city’s bus rapid transit program. Mathis said the trips help leaders learn from the places they visit.
“They’ve got a stadium in Dallas similar to the project we’re working (with the Braves),” Mathis said. “It will show how they are able to develop and work a stadium project. There are small business incubators we’re going to look at… We compete with Dallas quite a bit on economic development.”
A poor start for the new City Council?
Did he veto an appointment already put up by the Council?
Why was he giving them a hard time as to the procedure would be for swearing in new members?
Rather than trying to 'get along' with the new lineup on the Council it seems that he wants to bump heads with them right from the start.
If he dosen't like things now that he is a 'lame duck' mayor then he might want to resign and go back to washing Metro ambulances for a living.
The below appeared in the MDJ 1/1/14 and is a good summary of the past years election.
The MDJ has a limited local readership and their online edition has gone to a pay site so the item is reproduced here FYI.
The MDJ has a limited local readership and their online edition has gone to a pay site so the item is reproduced here FYI.
Residents oust three Kennesaw City Council members
December 31, 2013 09:57 PM
KENNESAW — After months of political sniping and controversy over spending and other issues at the City Council, Kennesaw residents voted to oust all three councilmen who were up for re-election in November.
Some say the divide in the council was exacerbated when longtime councilman Bill Thrash died from bladder cancer in May. The council was split in deciding who should take Thrash’s spot on the five-member council.
Mayor Mark Mathews made the tie-breaking vote in electing Matt Riedemann to the council in June, which added angst to the city’s split council members and residents.
Council members Cris Welsh and Bruce Jenkins voted to install Thrash’s wife, Suzie, as his replacement on the council, while Jeff Duckett and Tim Killingsworth opted for Riedemann.
Mathews voted to break the tie in favor of Riedemann.
From there, the council became a two-headed governmental body, split on most of the important votes, with council members Riedemann, Killingsworth and Duckett consistently voting in a bloc to overrule motions made by council members Cris Welsh and Bruce Jenkins.
Welsh brought forward motions this fall to ban smoking in nearly all businesses and public outdoor spaces and another to prohibit elected officials from texting during council meetings. Both motions were overruled and dismissed by Mathews and his allies.
Museum, credit cards spark controversy
The council was repeatedly petitioned by residents concerned with the city’s finances. Critics believed the city’s financial position was burdened by taxpayer subsidies of its top two tourist attractions, the Southern Museum of Locomotive History and the Smith-Gilbert Gardens.
Both attractions have been running deficits for years, pulling money from the city’s general fund, which is fed by fees and taxes paid by Kennesaw residents.
In the 2013 budget, city officials transferred $557,643 to the gardens and the museum in order to balance the annual budget. That figure is expected to rise to $616,322 in the 2014 budget, which was adopted in September by a 3-2 vote of the council.
In late October, city officials came under fire again for the city’s lack of a credit card policy. Residents were upset to learn their elected officials had been using credit cards with very little rules and regulations, funded with their tax dollars.
The mayor and council members had spent together about $33,000 on dinners, including one at Vic’s on the River in Savannah from July 2012 that totaled $923.20, various flights and embroidered clothing between September 2012 and September 2013, according to credit card statements.
Duckett spent roughly $4,500, Jenkins, $6,500, Welsh and Killingsworth almost $3,000 each, and the mayor about $8,200 from December 2012 through Sept. 9, 2013.
The bills were paid for and unquestioned by the city. As news of this and other hot-potato issues broke, residents responded by signing up to run for council.
By the filing deadline, residents had seven candidates to choose from on the Nov. 5 ballot.
Clean sweep of council candidates
Debra Williams, a local businesswoman who owns her own public relations and marketing business and serves on the Kennesaw Planning and Zoning Board, stunned incumbent Matt Riedemann by garnering 60 percent of the votes in the Post 4 race. She outpolled Riedemann by nearly 400 votes, tallying 1,142 to her opponent’s 757.
Jim Sebastian, chairman of the Citizens Advisory Committee and owner of SAFE LLC, a consulting company, squeaked out a win over incumbent Jeff Duckett by about 30 votes.
Former Kennesaw mayor Leonard Church made a political comeback, beating incumbent councilman Bruce Jenkins and Briggett Washington in a tight race, as no candidate won 50 percent of the vote.
Some say the divide in the council was exacerbated when longtime councilman Bill Thrash died from bladder cancer in May. The council was split in deciding who should take Thrash’s spot on the five-member council.
Mayor Mark Mathews made the tie-breaking vote in electing Matt Riedemann to the council in June, which added angst to the city’s split council members and residents.
Council members Cris Welsh and Bruce Jenkins voted to install Thrash’s wife, Suzie, as his replacement on the council, while Jeff Duckett and Tim Killingsworth opted for Riedemann.
Mathews voted to break the tie in favor of Riedemann.
From there, the council became a two-headed governmental body, split on most of the important votes, with council members Riedemann, Killingsworth and Duckett consistently voting in a bloc to overrule motions made by council members Cris Welsh and Bruce Jenkins.
Welsh brought forward motions this fall to ban smoking in nearly all businesses and public outdoor spaces and another to prohibit elected officials from texting during council meetings. Both motions were overruled and dismissed by Mathews and his allies.
Museum, credit cards spark controversy
The council was repeatedly petitioned by residents concerned with the city’s finances. Critics believed the city’s financial position was burdened by taxpayer subsidies of its top two tourist attractions, the Southern Museum of Locomotive History and the Smith-Gilbert Gardens.
Both attractions have been running deficits for years, pulling money from the city’s general fund, which is fed by fees and taxes paid by Kennesaw residents.
In the 2013 budget, city officials transferred $557,643 to the gardens and the museum in order to balance the annual budget. That figure is expected to rise to $616,322 in the 2014 budget, which was adopted in September by a 3-2 vote of the council.
In late October, city officials came under fire again for the city’s lack of a credit card policy. Residents were upset to learn their elected officials had been using credit cards with very little rules and regulations, funded with their tax dollars.
The mayor and council members had spent together about $33,000 on dinners, including one at Vic’s on the River in Savannah from July 2012 that totaled $923.20, various flights and embroidered clothing between September 2012 and September 2013, according to credit card statements.
Duckett spent roughly $4,500, Jenkins, $6,500, Welsh and Killingsworth almost $3,000 each, and the mayor about $8,200 from December 2012 through Sept. 9, 2013.
The bills were paid for and unquestioned by the city. As news of this and other hot-potato issues broke, residents responded by signing up to run for council.
By the filing deadline, residents had seven candidates to choose from on the Nov. 5 ballot.
Clean sweep of council candidates
Debra Williams, a local businesswoman who owns her own public relations and marketing business and serves on the Kennesaw Planning and Zoning Board, stunned incumbent Matt Riedemann by garnering 60 percent of the votes in the Post 4 race. She outpolled Riedemann by nearly 400 votes, tallying 1,142 to her opponent’s 757.
Jim Sebastian, chairman of the Citizens Advisory Committee and owner of SAFE LLC, a consulting company, squeaked out a win over incumbent Jeff Duckett by about 30 votes.
Former Kennesaw mayor Leonard Church made a political comeback, beating incumbent councilman Bruce Jenkins and Briggett Washington in a tight race, as no candidate won 50 percent of the vote.
Read more: The Marietta Daily Journal - Residents oust three Kennesaw City Council members
======================================================================
Misc Info:
The election is now history with all 3 incumbent councilmen having been replaced by other candidates.
So the original purpose of the site, and the others, is now gone but the information will remain as it has historical value and might be useful to people who have an interest in what goes on in Kennesaw.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Misc Info: Despite the article's claim of a 'runoff' there is no provision in Kennesaw for one if candidates do not get over 50%, so Church is the winner in Post 3.
Voters oust two Kennesaw City Council incumbents, shattering its voting bloc
Bruce Jenkins, Leonard Church in runoff Dec. 3
By Hannah Morgan, MDJ Reporter hmorgan@mdjonline.com
KENNESAW — Two new members will join Kennesaw’s City Council as they knocked off incumbents, and a third race will go to a runoff, shattering a tight voting bloc that has controlled many of the city’s policies for months.
Williams in a landslide
Debra Williams, a local businesswoman who owns her own public relations and marketing business and serves on the Kennesaw Planning and Zoning Board, stunned incumbent Matt Riedemann by garnering 60 percent of the votes in the Post 4 race. She outpolled Riedemann by nearly 400 votes, tallying 1,142 to her opponent’s 757, according to unofficial results posted on the Cobb Board of Elections website.
Duckett goes down, barely
Jim Sebastian, chairman of the Citizens Advisory Committee and owner of SAFE LLC, a consulting company, squeaked out a win over incumbent Jeff Duckett by about 30 votes, according to county election results.
“You did it, Jim, you did it!” Williams shouted across the crowded restaurant, 41 Cork and Tap, off Cobb Parkway in Kennesaw Station Shopping Center, pointing to Sebastian, as the election results came in Tuesday night.
Jenkins in runoff with former mayor
Former Kennesaw mayor Leonard Church and incumbent councilman Bruce Jenkins will be in a runoff election Dec. 3, as neither candidate garnered 50 percent of the vote, plus one vote, according to Cobb County election regulations.
Briggett Washington also ran for Jenkins’s seat but tallied only 23 percent of the vote, not enough to make the runoff election next month.
With Duckett and Riedemann going down in defeat, Mayor Mark Mathews will finish out the rest of his term without the voting bloc he has enjoyed.
Posting in pink
Councilwoman Cris Welsh, who was not up for re-election, posted the numbers as they came in from the county on a neon pink sheet, taped against the glass door at 41 Cork and Tap.
Peg Rhoad was excited about the potential for the new faces on the council, and said she hoped they could help to “Get the mayor out of town … and start getting the city where it needs to be,” both financially and ethically, said the owner of Dog Grooming by Peg on Main Street in downtown Kennesaw.
The Hickory Wine Bluegrass Band, with players from Tennessee and Woodstock, played as more than 60 supporters of Jenkins, Williams and Sebastian waited for the numbers to come in.
When Williams heard of her victory, she began to cry, “I made a promise to the people that I fully intend to keep,” she said.
Her best friend for more than 20 years, Lisa Lott, had driven in from Montgomery, Ala., to surprise Williams earlier that afternoon in the parking lot. She hugged Williams when the numbers began to come in.
Jenkins stood in the parking lot and said while he was disappointed with the results, he vowed to continue to support the city and all of the council members, whether or not he wins the upcoming runoff election.
“We need new blood, not old blood. Leadership is about everyone having a chance to serve. We need fresh faces, fresh ideas,” on the council, said 50-year-Kennesaw resident Mike Serkedakis, when he heard about Church’s slim plurality.
Across town, at Mazzy’s Sports bar and Grill off Cherokee Street, more than 50 people came out to support Riedemann, and to watch election results come in.
Riedemann said he felt “wonderful” and happy that so many people had been involved in voting Tuesday. Recent reports of his personal financial difficulties had both hurt and helped his campaign, he said. While the reports had certainly lost him a few voters, Riedemann said that he received many emails, text messages and calls from residents who felt that he was “a real person” that they could relate to.
Duckett, who was narrowly beaten by Sebastian, could not be reached Tuesday night.
In the current council, Mathews has received strong support from council members Tim Killingsworth and Duckett, while Jenkins and Welsh have previously voted against the mayor on important issues for the city, including the city’s budget.
Riedemann joined the council in July, after the death of former councilman Bill Thrash, and has not been on the council long enough to establish a voting pattern.
Riedemann was appointed to the council, however, by a tie-breaking vote from the mayor last June, after Thrash’s death. A picture of Thrash sat nearby on the bar Tuesday night at 41 Cork and Tap, facing out at the crowd as the final numbers came in. Residents were more involved in this year’s election than ever before, they said, as news reports revealed the city’s struggling financial situation, and complaints about a lax credit card spending policy drew them to the polls. Williams, Sebastian and either Jenkins or Church will take office at the start of January. Council members Welsh and Killingsworth, along with the mayor, were not up for re-election this year.
Staff/Jeff Stanton Above: Kennesaw City Council candidate Jim Sebastian, right, receives a victory smooch from his wife, Karen, at the 41 Cap and Cork. Sebastian narrowly defeated incumbent Jeff Duckett. Below: Incumbent Kennesaw City Council member Bruce Jenkins is embraced by Suzie Thrash, the wife of former council member Bill Thrash, who died from cancer in May. Thrash was supporting Jenkins, who will now face former mayor Leonard Church in a runoff.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mayor Mathews is now a 'lame duck'
With an unusually high turnout for a Kennesaw Council election, just over 1,900 voters turned out to cast their votes for the 3 Kennesaw Council positions.
3 incumbents have been swept out of office.
The financial problems with the mis-use of City credit cards was a late developing major facor, also voters expressed their annoyance with the Mayor over his actions in putting a financial burnout on the Council to replace a deceased Councilman.
This was much more than an election, it was a referendum on Mathew's stewardship and almost surely means that in 2 years both Mathews and his remaining Councilman Mr Killingsworth will be gone from Kennesaw politics.
The 3/2 Mathews majority on the Council is history, he now has to deal with 4 Council members who are 'anti' Mathews and in a mood for some major reforms both in financial matters and in any new Council business.
Post 3
L. Church 768 40%
B. Jenkins 720 37%
Washington 434 23%
----------------------------
Post 4
D. Williams 1,142 60%
Riedemann 757 40%
----------------------------
Post 5
Sebastian 964 51%
Duckett 934 49%
PM's from Facebook Account of JimJimgg, now closed
Below are both incoming and replies from me via a now closed Facebook account. When active the account had 30 'friends', one of them was Mathews.
He initiated an exchange of Private Messages and since I found them both annoying and a distraction I initially blocked/unfriended him. Shortly after that I decided just to cancel the account and it was deleted by me.
After this Mathews started contacting me via emails, none of which I replied to.
=====================================================
https://www.facebook.com/NEVRL8
Bill, i hope you are having a great Labor Day weekend. In all of your research on the Burger-Fi project,how did you not see that one of your "anti-mayor" angels was the lead council member over the KDDA for this project? As thorough as you are, I have to assume that you saw that little tidbit but including it would make you look even more foolish. Keep up the good work! Oh, and On your election analysis, I have to thank you for giving me so much credit. It's quite flattering.
Always glad to help! I've said about 20 times that all those on the Council should be replaced. Don't care whether they are 'pro-Mayor' or 'anti-Mayor', all of you did a poor job on the Pawn Shop fiasco and I could not care less if one of you is on the KDDA or if that person is pro or anti Mayor.
Pawn Shop was definitely a fiasco. That crazy thing called "Due Process of Law" really slows things down. Personally, understanding what we had to go thru with "Due Process" I think it went very well. We were made aware of a problem and resolved it.
It must be a very rewarding feeling to try to tear down people and progress. I'm sorry that you are such an unhappy man. What a man!
"Today "
Just remind me how many creditors you stuck in yoour 2009 bankruptcy? I am sure more people are pissed off with you than are with me. Wasn't that a bit over one million bucks you got out from under? People who live in glass houses should probably not annoy others who like to throw rocks.
2:08pm Sep 6
|
Again, I'm glad I can bring enjoyment to your obviously lacking life. Harping on something that is 4 years old really says a lot about the kind of person you really are. It's all public record and I've been in a glass house for over 16 years. While I too enjoy throwing rocks, I've never tried to hide from anything, cover anything up, or take out my personal deficiencies on others from behind a keyboard. I'm happy to answer any questions you may have "man to man" or "face to face". Enjoy your weekend "Mr. Big Man".
-------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------
=======================================================================
Background Information on Mathews:
(This 2 part article is presented with Part 2 first as this is the more interesting of the 2 and deals with current Mayor Mathews and how he handles his financial obligations)
Political Vine: The Insider's Source on Georgia Politics
See article at: http://politicalvine.com/politicalrumors/georgia-races/city-of-kennesaw-elections-part-2/
The Political Vine is the home of political news, satire, rants, and rumors.
City of Kennesaw Elections-
City of Kennesaw Elections - Part 2
by PV
Mark Mathews is the current mayor of Kennesaw, and is running for reelection this Tuesday, November 8th (2011).
First elected as mayor in 2007, he started his term in January 2008.
According to his reelection Website, he states the following as part of his business resume:
“1989-2009: Mathews Carpet Company – a company started by his parents in 1974. In 2001 MR Mathews, Inc. was created to purchase the business, Mathews Abbey Flooring, providing all types of flooring products and services to the residential, commercial, and new construction markets. Forced to close business due to economic downturn.”
A more accurate statement (and, truthful one at that) with regards to being “Forced to close business due to economic downturn” would have been “Filed bankruptcy in 2009 as a result of economic downturn.”
See, Ladies and Gentlemen, there is a difference between merely “closing a business” and a business filing Chapter 7 Bankruptcy. One denotes the act of merely ceasing operations after settling all debts…while the other one denotes a legal filing to a federal court to officially tell 44 some-odd creditors “Hey…ummm…sorry, we ain’t gonna pay you what we owe” to “close” the business.
So, if he’s not accurate in his description of what actually happened to his business, one might wonder if it really went bankrupt due solely to an “economic downturn” OR…could it be because Mathews was spending too much of his time playing mayor and dealing in the “fun” of politics rather than keeping his eye on his business enterprise?
Also in 2009, Mathews and his wife had to personally file for bankruptcy. (We are not in any way implying or inferring anything negative with regards to the character of Mark Mathews or his wife.)
HOWEVER…in referencing the actual filing (a 23 Megabyte PDF file should you choose to open or download it), there are significant instances of the taxpayers of several government jurisdictions being left on the hook for Mathews’ tax debt.
Specifically:
- City of Marietta: $2286.53 (Page 31 of 83 in PDF)
- City of Marietta Section 8 Housing Authority: $2003.43 (Page 39 of 83 in PDF)
- Cobb County Tax Commissioner: $626.00 (Page 40 of 83)
- Cobb County Tax Commissioner: $1553.32 (Page 40 of 83)
All told, Mark Mathews (via himself and MR Mathews, Inc) has left several Cobb County-based municipalities $6,469.28 in the red and OTHER taxpayers having to foot his tax bills (by having to pay higher taxes on their tax bills owed)
Now, the 2nd-term seeking mayoral candidate just happens to be one of the big, Big, BIG proponents of next year’s T-SPLOST. You know, that little vote that will require all Kennesaw inhabitants the additional responsibility of paying 1% more in sales tax on everything they buy in Cobb. Yeah. Mathews is in favor of you paying more taxes so that he can have a hand in spending on your behalf.
Councilman Tim Killingsworth, Post 2 is running for reelection to the Kennesaw City Council. He is also known to be a tight ally of Mark Mathews.
On October 24th, there was a candidate forum held by the Kennesaw Patch (an online local news site that is owned by Huffington-Post).
Here is a link to a PDF version of the transcript.
It is interesting to us that Councilman Killingsworth, at Time Marker 7:32 states “We haven’t raised your taxes, and we don’t plan to do that anytime soon.”
Then…at Time Marker 7:45, Killingsworth answers the question of whether he supports the T-SPLOST vote next year by saying “I would have to say I do support it.”
So, for Killingsworth’s mind, maybe there’s a distinction in his mind of what constitutes “anytime soon” and intending to push (along with Mathews coordinating) for passage of next year’s T-SPLOST vote to…do what? Oh, yeah. RAISE TAXES.
PV’s Conclusion: Frankly, in our opinion, the existence of Mathews’ two bankruptcies (personal and business defaults) are not the direct issues here.
What should be important in this case is the following:
1) Mathews had an obligation to be truthful as to why his business “closed.” It’s easy to blame the downturn…but, not everyone has gone out of business due to the downturn. AND, filing a bankruptcy is NOT the same thing as “closing a business.”
2) The failure to pay nearly $6500 in various taxes to the City of Marietta (hey, Thunder has deep pockets to cover this default, right, Thunder?) and the Cobb County Tax Commissioner’s office (hey, Tim Lee and Helen Goreham will cover for Mathews in a heartbeat…they’ll just raise the rest of our millages, right?).
No, defaulting on taxes should immediately disqualify anyone from “serving” the people. We hope that come the Election Night of November 8, the voters of Kennesaw disqualify the reelection of Mark Mathews.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This entry was posted by PV, on Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 at 11:25 pm and is filed under Cobb County, Georgia Races and Tagged: Candidate Bankruptcy, Kennesaw Mayor, Mark Mathews, Tax Debt, TSPLOST
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Political Vine: The Insider's Source on Georgia Politics
See article at: http://politicalvine.com/politicalrumors/cobb-county/city-of-kennesaw-elections-part-1/
The Political Vine is the home of political news, satire, rants, and rumors.
City of Kennesaw Elections-Part 1
by PV
Last week, we issued a Poll to the Vine readership consisting of this one question: ” If a person running for public office has a bankruptcy of any type in their background, should it be disclosed?”
Out of 142 votes cast, 111 voted “Yes, it should be disclosed” and 32 voted “No, I don’t care to know.”
There was an opportunity for people to give their own insight into the subject, and the personal opinions ran the gamut (see here for opinions…by the way, the site that the Poll is on is not controlled by Political Vine in any way, and it will not be monitored).
In reviewing these opinions, as well as consulting with other people in the world of politics, we’ve come to the following conclusions about bankruptcies (you are free to disagree):
1) Not all bankruptcies are the result of a character flaw in the people who file. It does not mean the person is immoral or unethical for filing a bankruptcy (of course, if any US Senator from Georgia ever files for bankruptcy, we’ll be scratching our heads and wondering why they didn’t get enough ROI from their crony capitalist bank pals after they voted in 2005 to give the homeowner less of a chance for recovery, all the while giving more power and absolution to the banks themselves).
2) Not all bankruptcies are entirely the fault of the person or business making the filing.
3) Barring the actual attempt to defraud, defaulting on money owed to creditors is not a sign of anyone who is being inherently dishonest (the creditors voluntarily took a risk to give credit to the borrower…that is an agreement between two private parties as far as we are concerned and a happenstance of the free market).
4) However, if the person has defaulted on taxes owed to a government entity, AND….that person is a candidate for a publicly-elected office for some position at some level of government, then everyone’s pretty much in agreement that that is a sign of hypocrisy present that is not going to be tolerated for very long by the voters and taxpayers.
It is this 4th point that is crucial to understand why there’s “hypocrisy” if someone is elected to office who hasn’t paid their own tax bills. It is the reason why we felt it was necessary to expose, not only the $137,000 some-odd of current tax liens that HD 43 candidate Robert Lamutt had on his current books, but also his documented 7-year history of having liens at both the federal and state level field against him that made it relevant.
When you are elected to public office, you are, in effect, using the force of government to extract tax dollars from us to pay for your fiefdom.
And, unless you think, as an elected official, that you should be exempt from paying taxes to support your infrastructure, your failure to pay taxes means that the burden must fall on the rest of the taxpayers.
And, taxpayers don’t particularly care to shoulder your load while you are put in charge of making decisions on how to spend their money.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This entry was posted by PV, on Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 at 11:09 pm and is filed under Cobb County and Tagged: Kennesaw Elections, Kennesaw Mayor, Mark Mathews, TSPLOST
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mark Mathews
Manager - Government Relations
Greater Atlanta Area Government Relations
As posted on the site Linked In: http://www.linkedin.com/in/mrmarkmathews?trk=pub-pbmap
Current
Board Member at Atlanta Regional Commission
Manager - Government Relations at METROAtlanta Ambulance Service
Mayor at City of Kennesaw
Past
Owner at Mathews Abbey Flooring
Council Member at City of Kennesaw
Communications Specialist at Honest Face Systems Inc.
Recommendations
14 people have recommended Mark
Connections
500+ connections
Websites
MetroAtlanta Ambulance
City of Kennesaw
Mark Mathews' Summary
Local elected official with over 15 years experience in federal, state, and local government relations in Georgia.
Specialties
Government relations, government liaison, project management, research, computer networking, contract negotiations, sales, dispute resolution.
Mark Mathews' Experience
Board Member
Atlanta Regional Commission
Nonprofit; 51-200 employees; Government Relations industry
July 2009 – Present (4 years 4 months)
Represent the six cities of Cobb County for the region.
Manager - Government Relations
METROAtlanta Ambulance Service
Privately Held; 201-500 employees; Hospital & Health Care industry
June 2009 – Present (4 years 5 months)
Mayor, City of Kennesaw
Government Agency; 201-500 employees; Government Administration industry
January 2008 – Present (5 years 10 months)
Owner, Mathews Abbey Flooring
January 2001 – March 2009 (8 years 3 months)
Family owned and operated flooring store. Provided all flooring products and services to the construction and retail trade. Carpet, Vinyl, Hardwood, Ceramic Tile sales and installation. Purchased business in 2001 from parents.
Council Member
City of Kennesaw
Government Agency; 201-500 employees; Government Administration industry
January 1996 – December 2007 (12 years)
Communications Specialist
Honest Face Systems Inc.
May 1982 – November 1989 (7 years 7 months)
Coordinated and managed all Data Processing functions, network specialist, and project management
======================================================================
Mathews Bankruptcy Information
Below Bankruptcy Schedules B, C and the 22 page listing of the 108 Schedule F unsecured creditors.
Written off debts ranged from $382,353 to the law firm of Haynie, Litchfield & Crane to $30 for UPS. The total liabilities were $1,446,583.43 v. assets of $360,268.
for a larger image right click and open in a new window-
Additional Bankruptcy information is coming soon about the Mayor and another Councilman.
--------------------------------------------------------------
for a larger image right click and open in a new window-
==========================================================================
The Georgia Campaign Finance Commission has some problems with the failure of 2 candidates for the Kennesaw City Council, 1 Kennesaw Mayor and one sitting Kennesaw Councilman (not up for election) in their failure to provide 'Personal Financial Disclosure Statements' as is required by Georgia law.
Riedemann owes $125, Killingsworth owes $125 and Ms Washington owes $250 for a missing 'Personal Financial Disclosure Statement' and a missing 'Campaign Contribution Disclosure Report'.
In the case of the Mayor it goes back to 2011. Mathews owes $250 for 2 seperate failures to file.
The Commission Invoice states in part:
"If you fail to pay the required late filing fee(s) as indicated above, the Georgia Government Transparency and Campaign Finance Commission may issue an Administrative Subpeona commanding your presence before them to give reason why you have failed to remit the required late filing fee(s)."
------------------------------------------------
Kennesaw Campaign Contribution Disclosure Reports are available at the below direct links, copy link and put into your browser to bring up the site:
Kennesaw Campaign Contribution Disclosure Reports are available at the below direct links, copy link and put into your browser to bring up the site:
Riedemann:
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=18848&FilerID=C2013000368&CDRID=95442
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=18848&FilerID=C2013000368&CDRID=95442
Duckett:
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=9030&FilerID=C2011000437&CDRID=96774
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=9030&FilerID=C2011000437&CDRID=96774
Williams:
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=19097&FilerID=C2013000572&CDRID=96560
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=19097&FilerID=C2013000572&CDRID=96560
Sebastian:
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=18917&FilerID=C2013000420&CDRID=96586
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=18917&FilerID=C2013000420&CDRID=96586
Washington:
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=19089&FilerID=C2013000566&CDRID=97571
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=19089&FilerID=C2013000566&CDRID=97571
Jenkins:
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=5901&FilerID=C2009000157&CDRID=97342
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_ReportOptions.aspx?NameID=5901&FilerID=C2009000157&CDRID=97342
Church:
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_Name.aspx?NameID=19088&FilerID=C2013000565&Type=candidate
http://media.ethics.ga.gov/Search/Campaign/Campaign_Name.aspx?NameID=19088&FilerID=C2013000565&Type=candidate
NotMathews.org - Integrity Matters This site was established by those who have been exposed to the
lack of character and integrity of Mark Mathews
and believe that he would not be a good mayor of Kennesaw.
NotMathews.org - Integrity Matters
This site was established by those who have been exposed to the
lack of character and integrity of Mark Mathews
and believe that he would not be a good mayor of Kennesaw.
Character and integrity matter: we suggest that you not vote for Mark Mathews for Mayor of Kennesaw.
Whether Democrat or Republican, you have to admire the courage and conviction of the Swift Vets and POWs for Truth during the 2004 presidential election. The Swift Vets knew from their own personal experience that John Kerry lacked integrity and deliberately misrepresented the truth. They felt it important that someone with lack of integrity should not be President of the United States: “John Kerry … exhibits serious flaws in character and lacks the potential to lead.” They stepped forward, presented the facts, addressed all rebuttals, and stood up to the personal abuse from the Kerry supporters.
While the Kennesaw mayoral race is nowhere near as significant, the mayor of Kennesaw will serve for 4 years and much can happen to influence our town's reputation and our lives here.
In that spirit, this site represents those in the area who have had personal experience with Mark Mathews and know, firsthand, that he lacks the character and integrity to be Mayor of Kennesaw. We will present the facts that are available and allow Mark Mathews to respond at any time.
We shall begin by reviewing Mark Mathews' own words about himself on his website. You will see that he distorts the truth to deceive you, takes credit for the work of others, or really does no work at all.
The "About Mark" and "Accomplishments" pages on his website have only three relevant activities: education, work experience, and city council membership:
EDUCATION:
At first glance, you might think "taken classes at Southern Polytechnic and Kennesaw State Universities" says that Mathews has a college degree or at least a significant college education - this is what he intended that you deduce. The reality is that he quit a computer science degree program from Southern Polytechnic because he was on academic probation after only two semesters. He then transferred to Kennesaw College (not a University at the time) in a business degree program and quit again. Given this poor performance, he was asked why he thought it important to put college classes in his biography and he could only agree that it was lack of commitment and poor planning and that he was "not as well in tune with myself, my goals for life, or my plans for the future." There are at least three things that must be derived from putting his failing college education in his bio:
1. He was trying to deceive the voters into thinking he had a college education. Why else would he place it in his bio? He was asked what courses he took that were relevant to being mayor and he refused to respond. If he wanted you to know the truth, he would have said he was a college drop-out.
2. He failed, twice, at a task that most of the voters would like their children to accomplish. Mark Mathews is not a good role model for our children - not for education, not for commitment and perseverance, and mostly not for integrity.
3. If he is unwilling to commit to an education, how can we expect he will commit to the job of mayor? This was already demonstrated when he was on the city council where, after 12 years, he has still not completed the Georgia Municipal Association classes, required of all public officials. Even knowing he was going to run for mayor, he dropped out of a scheduled class.
Some compensate for not getting a college degree and are honorable citizens. Mark Mathews did not and continues to demonstrate his lack of education and integrity. He could at least have someone check the grammar and spelling on his website.
WORK EXPERIENCE:
The first half of Mark Mathews' work experience was as a LAN administrator and a technical career. He quit this to take over his father's carpet business. We must ask why was there no mention of this in his bio? This would be far more significant to being mayor than running his father's business. But a more significant indicator of his lack of integrity is his carpet experience. This is where his true character is exposed. There are two types of contractors and the test comes not on a job that goes well but when there are problems. Here is where Mark Mathews clearly shows his lack of character and integrity. Here are just a few of his "contractor tricks":
1. Quit an incomplete job and claimed the remainder of the work was warranty. Then demanded full payment before he would do warranty work.
2. Personally showed up and demanded payment and became belligerent when female spouse was at home alone.
3. Used the courts as a weapon instead of an arbiter. Even when he lost the case, he refused to pay and used lawyer tactics to wear down the customer.
Other than demonstrating his poor character, this is important because he is a contractor and a considerable amount of city business deals with contractors and building. Having a contractor of Mathews' integrity as mayor can only cause a conflict of interest that is not in the best interest of Kennesaw residents.
CITY COUNCIL:
As with his deceptive education statement, his "accomplishments" as a city council member are written to deceive the voters. Here are some things to watch for in his claims:
1. His claim under "Leadership" was that he was "elected" by the council as Mayor Pro-Tem. There is no "election" involved. The position is a backup position in case the mayor is absent from a meeting and it is "rotated" among all the council members. Yet using the words elected, mayor, and leadership were meant purely to deceive the voters into thinking he has been elected and performed as mayor.
2. His claim under "Commitment" is again similar to his false education claims. This is actually a failure in commitment for, in 12 years, he has only completed 102 of 120 hours of the GMA education for elected officials.
3. Be very careful reading some of his other accomplishments noting particularly the verbs he uses. "Led the push", "served on", "instrumental in", "worked for", "worked with", "worked to maintain", "supported", "promoted", ... These are passive statements and amount to just talk. His "Vision" claim seems to use the active verb "led" but the reality is that he did not lead the automation project as the statement tries to deceive the voters. He didn't even lead a push, and when asked what specifically he did, he had no reply.
4. Regarding his statements on "Taxes," it is not clear what he actually did because the city manager is responsible for this area. As to his statement about working to maintain the current tax rate of 6.75 mils, his action at a council work session on June 27th, 2007 is to the contrary: "Councilmember Mathews recommended publishing at the highest possible millage rate (9.5 mils)."
5. Lack of character is reflected in his judgment, as well. For example, shortly after Jeff Miller was publicly reprimanded and removed as Vice President by the Legacy Park Community Association Board for improper conduct, Mark Mathews recommended him for the city planning board. Another example is his desire to disband the Kennesaw Police Department.
6. Mark Mathews says his reason for wanting to be mayor was to "bring parties together" to resolve "The slow progress on recent projects in the city [which] has been hindered by weak relationships, both internally and externally." When asked what projects and delays he was referring to, he had no answer. When asked why he hadn't accomplished these things as a councilman, he had no answer.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So, in his two short website pages, Mark Mathews has deceived, mislead, and demonstrated his lack of integrity, skill, and background for the position of Mayor of Kennesaw. His slogan is "building our hometown" but his actual behavior indicates that socializing and self-promotion are his priorities. To summarize his accomplishments from his own words, Mark Mathews is a college drop-out whose only business experience is running a business created by his father. Surely Kennesaw can do better.
This information on this website has been reviewed by Mark Mathews numerous times and he has been given, and continues to be given, the opportunity to correct any errors. Comments, experiences, and corrections may be sent to integrity@notmathews.org.
===============================================================
On October 24th, there was a candidate forum held by the Kennesaw Patch (an online local news site that is owned by Huffington-Post).
See original transcript at: http://www.politicalvine.com/kennesaw/KsawPatchForumPodcast.pdf
Monday October 24, 2011
7:23 And we're live from Ben Robertson Community Center.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:23
7:25 The candidates have been introduced. Now moderator Rep. Ed Setzler takes the podium.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:25
7:26 Format: Four general questions to be asked to all candidates, and two individual questions to each candidate.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:26
7:27 This will be followed by a Q&A from the audience.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:27
7:27 Now 3-minute opening remarks from all the candidates.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:27
7:27 Mayor Mark Mathews takes the podium
Monday October 24, 2011 7:27
7:28 Mathews: Four years ago, ran on platform of "building our hometown."
Monday October 24, 2011 7:28
7:28 Mathews: With hard economic times, budget has been reduced by 12 percent.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:28
7:29 "Thank you very much for the opportunity tonight. I look forward to answering your questions."
Monday October 24, 2011 7:29
7:29 Next, City Council challenger Jimmy Dickens, Post 2, takes the podium.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:29
7:29 I'm concerned about our community. I want to be part of it...
Monday October 24, 2011 7:29
7:29 Dickens: Currently running three mentoring programs.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:29
7:30 Dickens: I have eight kids, beautiful wife.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:30
7:30 Councilman Tim Killingsworth, Post 2: been in Kennesaw for 15 years. Retired from Marine Corps.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:30
7:31 "We changed a lot of attitudes about the way people look at politics and look at leaders here in Kennesaw."
Monday October 24, 2011 7:31
7:32 "One of my passions being a retired Marine is to follow and stay with the veterans groups."
Monday October 24, 2011 7:32
7:32 "We've got a lot of things happening and a lot of things about to happen."
Monday October 24, 2011 7:32
7:32 "We haven't raised your taxes, and we don't plan to do that anytime soon."
Monday October 24, 2011 7:32
7:33 Councilwoman Cris Eaton-Welsh, Post 1, takes the podium.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:33
7:33 "I work here, I live here, my husband Steve and I have chosen to raise our family here."
Monday October 24, 2011 7:33
7:33 "We have got a $1 million renovation going on with the old Cowboys location."
Monday October 24, 2011 7:33
7:34 "I'm very proud of this mayor and council for the relationships that they've built."
Monday October 24, 2011 7:34
7:34 First group question:
There's been a lot of talk for the need for economic development in downtown Kennesaw. What's your vision for downtown? How will you get there?
Monday October 24, 2011 7:34
7:35 Eaton-Welsh: That's my vision for downtown—a walking breathing downtown
Monday October 24, 2011 7:35
7:36 Killingsworth: The development that she's talked about, everybody has seen the Underpass under the railroad tracks. All that land on the other side of that street has been put together by the Development Authority. Now we've got Camp MacDonald. That's gonna be a passive park. Plus 4-story parking deck.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:36
7:37 Killingsworth: Our downtown is moving. We've got development already happening. Kennnesaw right now is staged and prepared to be on the front of the stage.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:37
7:38 Jimmy Dickens: Trackside was a good start. Me personally, I would like to see more restaurants downtown.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:38
7:38 Right now, other than the Trackside, there's not a lot of restaurants.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:38
7:38 People want to be in downtown Kennesaw. If you look at Pigs and Peaches and the big festivals that we have. I would want to redevelop downtown so we're more family friendly.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:38
7:39 Mark Mathews: The vision that we've got for Kennesaw is shared by the entire council at this present time.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:39
7:40 Downtown on Main Street, there is a rendering as well where we have assembled a property behind City Hall. That is intended to be amixed use facility. One of the big problems we have—lack of parking.
Once we address parking problem, we should have influx of additional
business, restaurants and shops opening up in downtown. That vision is well underway and being executed as we speak. The biggest hindrance right now is the economy. I envision over next two or three years, we will start seeing drastic, drastic changes.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:40
7:44 Individual questions for Eaton-Welsh:
With your stated focus on communications, how have you helped increase communication between city and residents? With what tangible results?
Eaton-Welsh:
Communication is the key to everything. The first thing I did when I came into office is I put together a blog. Then we started doing Facebook. Now Parks and Rec has Facebook, Police dept. has facebook.
Favorite thing is electronic newsletter. We've got a good percentage of people that have signed up and staying on top of what's going on. Started doing Survey Monkeys and got great feedback.
Next question: Which of projects currently in development would take first priority for completion if you are re-elected? Eaton-Welsh: The Sanctuary over at McCollum, everything coming together perfectly for this parking garage and downtown development.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:44
7:44 Group Question:
Do you support passage of the TSPLOST? Specifically the proposed mass transit system from Kennesaw to midtown Atlanta.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:44
7:45 Killingsworth: I would have to say I do support it.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:45
7:46 They (Roundtable) all had to work together. You've got all these
county commissioners, you've got these mayors, they're all trying to figure out a way to make it work.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:46
7:47 I'm here to tell you that they did a pretty good job when they
started butting heads and getting together. Tim Lee and Mark Mathews came up here, and they started talking to Cobb County. Everybody knows how that went. Then they went back to drawing table and got in the trenches again. If you look at return on the dollar, I think Cobb County fared pretty well.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:47
7:47 In the event that it comes down to it, I'd probably have to vote
yes. Because in 15 years, we're gonna be in trouble if we don't do something.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:47
7:48 Jimmy Dickens: I'm gonna give it to you straight. Yes, I do support it. I do think it should have been done years ago. Now's a bad time because of the economy.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:48
7:49 Ten years ago, something should have been in place then. If you look down the road, the congestion of traffic, we need to do omething now.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:49
7:49 I do support it, but I want to make sure the monies are gonna go exactly where they say they're gonna go.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:49
7:50 Mark Mathews: No ifs, ands or buts is a little unfair. I've maintained my position since we adopted the final project list. It is too early for me, there are too many unanswered questions that require the state legislature to take action, specifically on the transit
piece.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:50
7:50 Without a regional transit governance model in place to oversee that...if that's not in place, I can't support it.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:50
7:50 But assuming it's in place, will support it.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:50
7:51 I didn't have the choice to say yes or no as to when we would do it. All I had was the choice to be involved in the project list.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:51
7:51 Alternatives analysis study will take 18 months to complete—won't be complete until after the vote.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:51
7:52 Once study is done, then we can move forward with whatever that recommendation is.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:52
7:53 Eaton-Welsh: I do actually support it—something has got to be done about transportation. I've got to commend Mark. He put his neck out there. You know something needs to be done about transportation.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:53
7:53 Question for Jimmy Dickens:
As Kennesaw business owner, why are you running for office? Why now?
Monday October 24, 2011 7:53
7:54 Dickens: I'm not just a business owner. I'm a father. I hear the
complaints. I hear from customers, from knocking on doors. I hear needs people are asking for. People want somebody that's real. Instead of just complaining about the stuff that Kennesaw needs—get involved. I think the best way to get involved is to get on the side making decisions.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:54
7:54 Dickens: I want to do whatever it takes on your behalf.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:54
7:55 Question: If elected to council, what are first changes you would make to what current leadership is doing?
Monday October 24, 2011 7:55
7:55 Dickens: The main thing I want is communication. I feel there is
a link missing from the needs of the people and what's currently going on in some of the positions on the Kennesaw Council.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:55
7:55 I want to be the one that's listening to you because it's you
that makes Kennesaw. Without all of you, Kennesaw wouldn't be what it is.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:55
7:56 As a business owner, I learned a long time ago that the people are my boss. I don't have a supervisor, I don't have a manager. The
customers are what makes the business run.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:56
7:56 You all would be my boss.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:56
7:57 Question:
In a struggling economy, what is your plan of action for bringing jobs to Kennesaw?
Monday October 24, 2011 7:57
7:57 Dickens: We have to first make Kennesaw attractive. We need to work with KBA to have something to attract more business. We need to redevelop downtown Kennesaw so businesses will want to invest.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:57
7:58 Mathews: The plan of action for bringing jobs to Kennesaw is
really a multi-fold solution. I've been asked to work on economic
development plan and identify key opportunities we currently don't take advantage of. Results should be back by end of year. There's initiative called One Georgia at state level. Once we get those plans
in place, we can focus on industry or trade best suited for our area.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:58
7:59 So, our plan is really mainly just to continue focus on economic development in downtown, the student housing projects, continuing to
partner with KSU.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:59
7:59 Eaton-Welsh: Our job as councilmembers is to promote Kennesaw inside Kennesaw.
Monday October 24, 2011 7:59
8:00 With Economic Development Department, we've got all these developments coming in. Cowboys will bring 40-50 jobs into the area.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:00
8:01 Killingsworth: One of the things that we want to be sure to look at is Kennesaw State University. Putting together student housing facility. KSU is gonna start doing something they call football. When football comes in, that's gonna bring a lot more people into Kennesaw.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:01
8:02 We're working with the museum. One little project I've been
doing is looking at our hometown heroes. One of the things we've started doing is interviewing people who are real close to right here—you have a Pearl Harbor survivor, a D-Day survivor, the first female Post Master General right at the end of Moon Station.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:02
8:02 One of my dreams is to interview these people and having them digitized and having them on these tapes, so our grandchildren will be able to say, 'Hey, they lived right here.'
Monday October 24, 2011 8:02
8:03 Individual question for Killingsworth:
You've talked about importance of partnerships and thinking regionally as a city. What is partnership you've helped establish? To what benefit?
Killingsworth:
When this council looked at me and asked if we could get Marine Corp
Platoon here. We got em here twice.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:03
8:05 Question:
If re-elected name at least one project you hope to
complete in your next term that will benefit Kennesaw in the long-run.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:05
8:06 Killingsworth: Camp MacDonald Park, first African American museum. That's the kind of impact we're making. We're gonna make an impact. That gun law will only take us so far.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:06
8:06 Final group question:
KSU is third largest university in Georgia. While KSU is not in city limits, how does university fit into larger picture?
Monday October 24, 2011 8:06
8:07 Eaton--Welsh: There's really two groups of people in economy that have money—seniors who are retired and college students.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:07
8:07 Purpose-built student housing is gonna be great. Also working closely with KSU and having great relationships with KSU.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:07
8:08 Killingsworth: One of the things Kennesaw State's gonna be doing is bringing football. This Wednesday, meeting with new athletic
director. Actually getting to meet with these people and talk with
these people. Dr. Papp has embraced the city government and city of Kennesaw.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:08
8:09 They are asking for our help.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:09
8:09 Dickens: Student housing—we need to give kids something attractive so that they'll want to be part of Kennesaw. Give them something they can gravitate to.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:09
8:10 We need to work on developing downtown area. That will draw them also.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:10
8:10 Mathews: Some of the things we've already put into place at KSU—I was asked by President Papp to be on Citizens Advisory Board.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:10
8:10 We've got two choices: we can either partner with KSU, or we can ignore it.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:10
8:11 Up until last four years, we've ignored it. What we've been able to do in last four years has been amazing.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:11
8:11 We've had high-level discussions with the team, the president's cabinet, to talk about additional housing in or around downtown.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:11
8:11 If I'm allowed to stay in office, we will continue to cultivate that relationship.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:11
8:14 Question to Mathews:
Taxes and trash pickup are higher within city limits. Benefits of parks and rec available to nonresidents. What are benefits of living in city?
Mathews: People do pay nonresident fee. Looking at creating more fees for nonresidents. The areas within the city that we stand out: our police services, the protection we offer you. The average police
response time in Cobb County—20 minutes. In Kennesaw—2 minutes.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:14
8:15 Kennsaw is in a unique position. Kennesaw's age is actually getting younger. Not just because of KSU. It's because we've created a family-friendly environment.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:15
8:16 Question:
If re-elected as mayor, what will be your number one priority?
Monday October 24, 2011 8:16
8:16 Mathews: To continue building our hometown.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:16
8:16 One of the key steps is having property available and having cooperative land owners.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:16
8:17 We can't make people sell, or open business here. All we can do is try and provide the connections and try and facilitate some of these deals to actually be completed. If elected again, one of key
projects will be to continue that downtown development.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:17
8:17 The Pedestrian Underpass is one key piece. If downtown is mall, our job is to create the anchor stores. I think we've done that with
the museum. We've created framework for pedestrian-friendly downtown.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:17
8:18 We have to have something that's drawing people downtown if they don't live here. Things like Dinner at the Depot (food trucks that come in Monday night in downtown area).
Monday October 24, 2011 8:18
8:18 This city has become successful because of the volunteer boards.
Much bigger than just the mayor and council.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:18
8:19 Now, starting Audience Q&A.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:19
8:31 First question for all candidates:
Kennesaw Elementary School enjoys great relationship with city of Kennesaw. What would you do to strengthen relationship?
Monday October 24, 2011 8:31
8:31 Mathews: The only way to improve that, in my opinion, is to improve communication.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:31
8:31 Dickens: I have two kids that go to Kennesaw Elementary. I see that there's a great link that needs to be set forth.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:31
8:32 Killingsworth: In middle of November, got contacted to help in
Jump Rope for Heart.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:32
8:33 Eaton-Welsh: My daughter goes there. I serve on their legislative committee. I'd like to see kids get involved.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:33
8:33 Question: Trash services have been reduced, while costs remain the same. Are you open to competitors?
Monday October 24, 2011 8:33
8:34 Eaton-Welsh: If we bring people in, I think it will be a big mess. A lot of these places dump illegally.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:34
8:35 Dickens: Myself, I would agree to have competition come in. No one should have a monopoly. I think the competition is good.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:35
8:36 Mathews: Sanitation is one of our services. We have tremendous recycling effort going on. As we continue to recycle more, those costs will go down. In order to reduce rate, we have to increase recycling.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:36
8:36 Long and short of it is: Increase recycling and sanitation fees
will go down.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:36
8:36 We surveyed residents: overwhelmingly, people opted for reduction in service rather than increase in monthly bill.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:36
8:38 Sorry, had some connection issues. Now we're back on.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:38
8:40 Why should large company with more than 100 jobs bring them to Kennesaw?
Mathews: Primarily—quality of life for the employees.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:40
8:41 You can go from beginning to end and never have to leave Kennesaw.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:41
8:42 Eaton-Welsh: We've got great economic incentives. We have a fantastic university system, we're right on 75 and we're developing relationship with Cobb Chamber.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:42
8:43 Question:
With growth, comes diversity. What would you do about Wildman's business if you were going to develop downtown?
Monday October 24, 2011 8:43
8:43 Eaton-Welsh: He and my father have butted heads for 20 years. When Wildman called me and asked me for a yard sign, my jaw dropped. Great thing about community—we can agree to disagree. We've just got to build everything beautiful around him.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:43
8:44 Killingsworth: I don't agree with him, but we have to let him
stay where he is. As Cris said, we will grow around him. He won't be here forever. And we'll grow around him.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:44
8:45 Dickens: Knocking on doors and talking to you all, I've been asked this question a lot. My response is, I've had lunch with Dent a few times. He's even come by my barbershop. It's not Dent Myers that concerns me the most. You see his views a mile away. But it's people who have it in their hearts that you can't see that I'm concerned about. Maybe they're serving on a board or are a policeman—that's the scariest thing.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:45
8:46 My concern is beautifying downtown. We must be concerned about overall Kennesaw, not just Dent.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:46
8:46 Mathews: He is a business owner and deserves same respect that any other business owner deserves. As long as he stays within standards we've set, he's just as entitled to be there as anybody else
is.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:46
8:46 I see him as just another piece of that diverse landscape we have here.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:46
8:47 He is a prime example of a diverse business.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:47
8:47 Closing Remarks
Monday October 24, 2011 8:47
8:48 Mathews: I want to thank the Patch for putting this event together. I think it's very unfortunate that all the candidates didn't
choose to show up.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:48
8:48 We've got a lot of things that need to continue to stay in place and to maintain that focus so that we can come out of this strong on the other side.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:48
8:50 Dickens: I do ask you for my vote on Nov. 8 so your ideas, your voice, can be heard and passed along.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:50
8:51 Killingsworth: Who wouldn't want to be part of this? Who
wouldn't want to be part of a great team? We've been able to assemble great people. We've been able to hear your voice. A lot of ideas we've moved forward with have come from you.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:51
8:51 Eaton-Welsh: It has been an absolute pleasure. I would humbly ask you not only to get out and vote but get your neighbors to vote.
Monday October 24, 2011 8:51
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Insider's Source on Georgia Politics
Nov 2013
City of Kennesaw Elections-Part 1
by PV, See article at the direct link:
Last week, we issued a Poll to the Vine readership consisting of this one question: ” If a person running for public office has a bankruptcy of any type in their background, should it be disclosed?”
Out of 142 votes cast, 111 voted “Yes, it should be disclosed” and 32 voted “No, I don’t care to know.”
There was an opportunity for people to give their own insight into the subject, and the personal opinions ran the gamut (see here for opinions…by the way, the site that the Poll is on is not controlled by Political Vine in any way, and it will not be monitored).
In reviewing these opinions, as well as consulting with other people in the world of politics, we’ve come to the following conclusions about bankruptcies (you are free to disagree):
1) Not all bankruptcies are the result of a character flaw in the people who file. It does not mean the person is immoral or unethical for filing a bankruptcy (of course, if any US Senator from Georgia ever files for bankruptcy, we’ll be scratching our heads and wondering why they didn’t get enough ROI from their crony capitalist bank pals after they voted in 2005 to give the homeowner less of a chance for recovery, all the while giving more power and absolution to the banks themselves).
2) Not all bankruptcies are entirely the fault of the person or business making the filing.
3) Barring the actual attempt to defraud, defaulting on money owed to creditors is not a sign of anyone who is being inherently dishonest (the creditors voluntarily took a risk to give credit to the borrower…that is an agreement between two private parties as far as we are concerned and a happenstance of the free market).
4) However, if the person has defaulted on taxes owed to a government entity, AND….that person is a candidate for a publicly-elected office for some position at some level of government, then everyone’s pretty much in agreement that that is a sign of hypocrisy present that is not going to be tolerated for very long by the voters and taxpayers.
It is this 4th point that is crucial to understand why there’s “hypocrisy” if someone is elected to office who hasn’t paid their own tax bills. It is the reason why we felt it was necessary to expose, not only the $137,000 some-odd of current tax liens that HD 43 candidate Robert Lamutt had on his current books, but also his documented 7-year history of having liens at both the federal and state level field against him that made it relevant.
When you are elected to public office, you are, in effect, using the force of government to extract tax dollars from us to pay for your fiefdom.
And, unless you think, as an elected official, that you should be exempt from paying taxes to support your infrastructure, your failure to pay taxes means that the burden must fall on the rest of the taxpayers.
And, taxpayers don’t particularly care to shoulder your load while you are put in charge of making decisions on how to spend their money.
This entry was posted by PV, on Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 at 11:09 pm and is filed under Cobb County and Tagged: Kennesaw Elections, Kennesaw Mayor, Mark Mathews, TSPLOST
City of Kennesaw Elections-Part 2
by PV
Mark Mathews is the current mayor of Kennesaw, and is running for reelection this Tuesday, November 8th.
First elected as mayor in 2007, he started his term in January 2008.
According to his reelection Website, he states the following as part of his business resume:
“1989-2009: Mathews Carpet Company – a company started by his parents in 1974. In 2001 MR Mathews, Inc. was created to purchase the business, Mathews Abbey Flooring, providing all types of flooring products and services to the residential, commercial, and new construction markets. Forced to close business due to economic downturn.”
A more accurate statement (and, truthful one at that) with regards to being “Forced to close business due to economic downturn” would have been “Filed bankruptcy in 2009 as a result of economic downturn.”
See, Ladies and Gentlemen, there is a difference between merely “closing a business” and a business filing Chapter 7 Bankruptcy. One denotes the act of merely ceasing operations after settling all debts…while the other one denotes a legal filing to a federal court to officially tell 44 some-odd creditors “Hey…ummm…sorry, we ain’t gonna pay you what we owe” to “close” the business.
So, if he’s not accurate in his description of what actually happened to his business, one might wonder if it really went bankrupt due solely to an “economic downturn” OR…could it be because Mathews was spending too much of his time playing mayor and dealing in the “fun” of politics rather than keeping his eye on his business enterprise?
Also in 2009, Mathews and his wife had to personally file for bankruptcy. (We are not in any way implying or inferring anything negative with regards to the character of Mark Mathews or his wife.)
HOWEVER…in referencing the actual filing (a 23 Megabyte PDF file should you choose to open or download it), there are significant instances of the taxpayers of several government jurisdictions being left on the hook for Mathews’ tax debt.
Specifically:
- City of Marietta: $2286.53 (Page 31 of 83 in PDF)
- City of Marietta Section 8 Housing Authority: $2003.43 (Page 39 of 83 in PDF)
- Cobb County Tax Commissioner: $626.00 (Page 40 of 83)
- Cobb County Tax Commissioner: $1553.32 (Page 40 of 83)
All told, Mark Mathews (via himself and MR Mathews, Inc) has left several Cobb County-based municipalities $6,469.28 in the red and OTHER taxpayers having to foot his tax bills (by having to pay higher taxes on their tax bills owed)
Now, the 2nd-term seeking mayoral candidate just happens to be one of the big, Big, BIG proponents of next year’s T-SPLOST. You know, that little vote that will require all Kennesaw inhabitants the additional responsibility of paying 1% more in sales tax on everything they buy in Cobb. Yeah. Mathews is in favor of you paying more taxes so that he can have a hand in spending on your behalf.
Councilman Tim Killingsworth, Post 2 is running for reelection to the Kennesaw City Council. He is also known to be a tight ally of Mark Mathews.
On October 24th, there was a candidate forum held by the Kennesaw Patch (an online local news site that is owned by Huffington-Post).
Here is a link to a PDF version of the transcript.
It is interesting to us that Councilman Killingsworth, at Time Marker 7:32 states “We haven’t raised your taxes, and we don’t plan to do that anytime soon.”
Then…at Time Marker 7:45, Killingsworth answers the question of whether he supports the T-SPLOST vote next year by saying “I would have to say I do support it.”
So, for Killingsworth’s mind, maybe there’s a distinction in his mind of what constitutes “anytime soon” and intending to push (along with Mathews coordinating) for passage of next year’s T-SPLOST vote to…do what? Oh, yeah. RAISE TAXES.
PV’s Conclusion: Frankly, in our opinion, the existence of Mathews’ two bankruptcies (personal and business defaults) are not the direct issues here.
What should be important in this case is the following:
1) Mathews had an obligation to be truthful as to why his business “closed.” It’s easy to blame the downturn…but, not everyone has gone out of business due to the downturn. AND, filing a bankruptcy is NOT the same thing as “closing a business.”
2) The failure to pay nearly $6500 in various taxes to the City of Marietta (hey, Thunder has deep pockets to cover this default, right, Thunder?) and the Cobb County Tax Commissioner’s office (hey, Tim Lee and Helen Goreham will cover for Mathews in a heartbeat…they’ll just raise the rest of our millages, right?).
No, defaulting on taxes should immediately disqualify anyone from “serving” the people. We hope that come the Election Night of November 8, the voters of Kennesaw disqualify the reelection of Mark Mathews.
This entry was posted by PV, on Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 at 11:25 pm and is filed under Cobb County, Georgia Races and Tagged: Candidate Bankruptcy, Kennesaw Mayor, Mark Mathews, Tax Debt, TSPLOST
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.
The City of Kennesaw is being greatly damaged by too many apartments and too many extended stay motels and too few nice neighborhoods.
Mark is just as bad as Leonard. They've merely swapped seats but the City still lacks leadership that will ensure Kennesaw develops in a quality way. Bravo to the ladies on the Council for stopping him on this.
Mark and Tim are "bye bye".
How totally SHAMEFUL that he would even threaten to veto when counncil members expressed concern on spending that much TAXPAYER money on a 3 day trip (that NO other county mayor is attending).
If he wants to go so bad, write it off as a sales trip and have his buddies at Metro Ambulance pay for it.
I believe that is the same for Honorary Commanders, GMA Conferences, Economic Development summits, etc. Leaders are always challenged to hone their skills and knowledge to continue to be effective and great leaders.
I guarantee Kennesaw would not be where we are today and in this economic boom if our leaders had not branched out and gathered the knowledge and acquired the relationships that would help us to do so. Look at all the past great events, they were not accomplished on an individual basis. It takes relationships and partnerships, as well as friendships. It takes prior knowledge, existing knowledge, and continued learning.
You say this economic summit is not worth it. How do you know?? I believe learning something to improve or enhance is always worth it. The return on investment can prove to be huge if you are in it for the right reasons.
This article refers to the City credit card, in many cases the City credit card carries as an open and accurate expense account of the individual that is using it. It also has certain advantages of savings to taxpayers if it is used in travel. For example, in the travel industry certain local sales or “Hotel/Motel tax” are removed if the purchaser has a credit card that bears the name of the entity he/she represents and the entity is tax exempt, and in most cases municipalities are tax exempt. In some cases the advantages are easily justified for having the City card. The gray area is created by the phrase, “shall be reimbursed” when the card is used in advance and clear guidelines as to what is expected in return on its usage to the owner, i.e. “taxpayer” (other then just receipts). The City charter needs an amendment to more accurately dictate policy on what exactly is a “justifiable and reasonable” reimbursement, and requiring documentation for future references as to the details of the expense. In this case the people, (taxpayers) are and “shall be reimbursed” with clear understanding of how their funds are being used. Just my thoughts...